Khalid Mohammad: The Khan Syndrome

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

642126

Hibernated

Posted: 11 years ago

#121

If you ask me about remembrance and impact then I feel Aamir's movies from Lagaan onwards (except Ghajini, MP, D3) will age better, stand test of time comparatively more. He will be remembered as better actor and filmmaker because of different movies. SRK will be remembered for popularity, being self made, successful businessman but in movies he has chance of getting slotted only as a romantic hero...he will be remembered more for personal achievements than cinema or acting. Salman will be remembered as a looker, stylish stud with popularity. I see his name gracing gossip discussions more than cinema/acting discussions in future.

Rest it depends on how the three handle their careers and lives. I hope none of them becomes like Dev Anand - dressing same way, showing same old mannerisms and making bullcrap movies till last breath.

Quote

briahna

@briahna

Inactive

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

#122

amir khan is not a better than shah rukh khan. better choices/ better script sense, yes, but better actor...no.

just cos he gave a lagaan and 3 idiots, doesn't make him a better actor. he also gives a bad bad dhoom in between, ..i am talking about acting here.

but thats strickly my opinion. and no, i am not going to shy away from saying, loved him for about 6 months for giving a taare zameen parr.

shahs baazigar, darr, kabhi haan kabhi na, swades, chak deh and DONs ( this will always make my list) and his cheesy kkhh and THE ddlj rocked my boat. still rocks

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

642126

Hibernated

Posted: 11 years ago

#123

@briahna

I was talking of my opinion on how they might be remembered.

How movies age also influences perception of an actor.

Quote

gilmores

@gilmores

Stunner

+ 8

Posted: 11 years ago

#124

Originally posted by: briahna
choco...perfect say there gal.
i hope somebody don't come to me and say BW didn't tap shahs talent. why blame BW for not tapping shahs talent. shah can do the tapping himself, especially now. be more creative, there is no money issue, no kammi of good producers, good directors, he doesn't have to rush, don't have to do 5 movies a yr...

yeh uchalna band karo CE aur ra 1 ke naam parr...and give us a quality product. pls..

btw choco, you must take a peek at rajesh khanna and amits movie list...

no i am not talking about quality and all that, but how they were jamming in 70s.

Mhmm, he's had plenty of opportunities to work with good directors and try something new...if he hasn't then that's his problem, not BW's really. Sure his friends only see him a certain way and cannot try anything new with him but then it's upto SRK to stop doing their films. He started off right...and even uptil 2007-ish he was fine...he's just gone completely downhill post then. Of the top stars, people expect the most in terms of quality from him and Aamir.

The only bad about CE working was just that SRK now found another formula to repeat ...but sadly he'd never tried so hard to fit in before in a film.

Yess I've seen 70's movies with the family! They were fun :D

Quote

HarveySpecter

@HarveySpecter

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

#125

Originally posted by: briahna
amir khan is not a better than shah rukh khan. better choices/ better script sense, yes, but better actor...no.

just cos he gave a lagaan and 3 idiots, doesn't make him a better actor. he also gives a bad bad dhoom in between, ..i am talking about acting here.

but thats strickly my opinion. and no, i am not going to shy away from saying, loved him for about 6 months for giving a taare zameen parr.

shahs baazigar, darr, kabhi haan kabhi na, swades, chak deh and DONs ( this will always make my list) and his cheesy kkhh and THE ddlj rocked my boat. still rocks

😲

Shahrukh is not an actor, he's a good looking guy, charmer. Aamir is what I call an actor! Can you imagine Shahrukh in Lagaan or Taare Zameen Pe? Or even 3 Idiots, which looked easy but was not easy at all! Sharukh turned down 3 Idiots for the same reason. He could not have pulled it off and he himself knew that.