DOTW- Arjuns Death n Ur Views

Teesha thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#1

Hello All,

Im once again here wid another Discussion of the Week n this weeks topic is the most shocking n turning point in Saarrthi-Arjuns death!

Some points to look at n discuss r:

-How has Arjun's death cum across to u?

-How do u feel knwing the main character has died?

-When Mansen n Yuv first planned on killing AB, did u actually think they wud b successful? Wat were ur thoughts?

-Has Arjun's death digest down well? or do u think he will cum back?

-In ur view, how was the whole death scene? Cud they hav shot it better? Cud they hav omitted sumthing?

-Last but not the least, How did Bhoomis realisation of Arjun's death cum across to u? Did u think she cud hav acted it better? Do u think they shud hav taken awhile to make her believe the death? or do u think her progress is well?

Please feel free to share ur views n opinions...Looking fwd to a successful discussion....

Teesha sorry for editing ur post but wanted to include 1 more Q's

- Should Arjun have been killed or replaced?


Saarrthi Dev Team


Edited by pinkykhan - 18 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

9

Views

1.7k

Users

6

Frequent Posters

Teesha thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#2

-How has Arjun's death cum across to u?

I was really shocked! I cudnt believe he died, matter of fact while reading the update I kept on hoping they'd show him turning up either as alive or unconcious...Must say it was a very shocking turn in Saarrthi- Satya's death didnt shock me as much as Arjuns- He was the main lead!

-How do u feel knwing the main character has died?

To b honest I feel least interested in the show now...I dont think a show can survive wid its main lead dying...n at this point especially when all the other important characters such as Suraj, Manasvi, Satya hav either disappeared or died off...

-When Mansen n Yuv first planned on killing AB, did u actually think they wud b successful? Wat were ur thoughts?

No...I thought Mansen wud realise they r taking a wrong step...My thoughts got more positive when Mansen asked Yuv to stop the nonsense as they had gone too far in their hatred...So I felt Mansen wud stand as a sheild supporting AB unknowingly...

-Has Arjun's death digest down well? or do u think he will cum back?

Nope! I still feel he'll cum back, cant say for sure y this feeling is...But its hard to believe AB will never b again...

-In ur view, how was the whole death scene? Cud they hav shot it better? Cud they hav omitted sumthing?

How abt omitting the whole death scene😆 No it was ok- I never like death scenes so cant comment better than that...

-Last but not the least, How did Bhoomis realisation of Arjun's death cum across to u? Did u think she cud hav acted it better? Do u think they shud hav taken awhile to make her believe the death? or do u think her progress is well?

I felt she too simply believed his death...Like Arjun he had a tough time believing it but she too quickly let the realisation sink in...I feel they shud hav shown a bit of more shock in her as she was present during the time of the accident, plus they got separated too soon...

Teesha sorry for editing ur post but wanted to include 1 more Q's

arre no probs yaar...meri galti it flew out of mind...shorry😳

- Should Arjun have been killed or replaced?

well if they knew Karan wished to quit they shud hav either ended the show or replaced him...Its never gud to show ur lead dying off...But I guess they cudnt afford another plastic surgery as Bhoomi had gone through one already...They shud hav jus simply replaced like "From now onwards the role of Arjun will b played by....." that sort of thing...

**Everyone else...I know this show is really no more less than a nightmare but pls share ur views n keep the forum going....

Thanks....

Edited by rajeev4aamna - 18 years ago
mghurye thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#3
I will answer the questions in a moment but i think it is now becoming about what the actors want and not about what the script demands, i mean Neha wants to leave so the show gets plastic surgery and Karan wants to concentrate on his new show so his character is killed off....I mean the actors should be supplyin what the character needs not the other way around, you know!
Now i feel the future of the characters of Saarthi lies is in the hands of its actors and not in the writers...which is really a sad road to be going down on!

I will answer the questions slowly one by one when they are all done i will delete this line

-How has Arjun's death cum across to u?


-How do u feel knwing the main character has died?

I dont feel like watching this show anymore which is why i am not!

-When Mansen n Yuv first planned on killing AB, did u actually think they wud b successful? Wat were ur thoughts?

-Has Arjun's death digest down well? or do u think he will cum back?

-In ur view, how was the whole death scene? Cud they hav shot it better? Cud they hav omitted sumthing?

-Last but not the least, How did Bhoomis realisation of Arjun's death cum across to u? Did u think she cud hav acted it better? Do u think they shud hav taken awhile to make her believe the death? or do u think her progress is well?

- Should Arjun have been killed or replaced?


Edited by mghurye - 18 years ago
simy14 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: rajeev4aamna

Hello All,

Im once again here wid another Discussion of the Week n this weeks topic is the most shocking n turning point in Saarrthi-Arjuns death!

Some points to look at n discuss r:

-How has Arjun's death cum across to u?

-How do u feel knwing the main character has died?

-When Mansen n Yuv first planned on killing AB, did u actually think they wud b successful? Wat were ur thoughts?

-Has Arjun's death digest down well? or do u think he will cum back?

-In ur view, how was the whole death scene? Cud they hav shot it better? Cud they hav omitted sumthing?

-Last but not the least, How did Bhoomis realisation of Arjun's death cum across to u? Did u think she cud hav acted it better? Do u think they shud hav taken awhile to make her believe the death? or do u think her progress is well?

Please feel free to share ur views n opinions...Looking fwd to a successful discussion....

Teesha sorry for editing ur post but wanted to include 1 more Q's

- Should Arjun have been killed or replaced?


Saarrthi Dev Team


Grt post Teesha 😊

I wish that Yuv had dies instead of Arjun...

The producer of Saarrthi says that there is a lot of story telling left in them...if this is the story they want to tell...I am not very keen on it. Y did they hv to bring abt this lousy twist to the story??? 😡

I am really sad abt Arjun's death. There was no need for it. I personally have not been able to see wat good Arjun's death is going to bring. Now we are back to seeing Bhumi suffer again. 🤢

When the evil Mansen's family were plottin 2 kill Arjun ...I never thought that it wud actually materialise...😕

I never wanted to see Bhumi suffer again...but 2 c r her like this without Arjun is really very sad and pathetic.

The writers of Saarrthi hv 2 b truly ashamed of themselves to come up with this thoughtlesl and needless twist in the story.

If they did it 4 trps well they r so wrong then....

Teesha thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: mghurye

it is now becoming about what the actors want and not about what the script demands, i mean Neha wants to leave so the show gets plastic surgery and Karan wants to concentrate on his new show so his character is killed off....I mean the actors should be supplyin what the character needs not the other way around, you know!
Now i feel the future of the characters of Saarthi lies is in the hands of its actors and not in the writers...which is really a sad road to be going down on!

U mentioned two very gud points Maleka...One abt the script adjusting wid the actors n the second abt Saarrthis future lying wid the actors...

n that makes me think, if Neha n the other actors were around, wud hav Saarrthi becum wat it is today? If Karan didnt quit Saarrthi, wud we b able to c AB happy for moments longer then they were?

Mayb it is not right on our parts to get all angry wid the writers n directors, mayb they too feel let down wid evryone moving on- but then there is a way..Its better to end the show n let ppl move on wid gud thoughts abt the show rather than adding needless spice n turns....

Teesha thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: simy14

Grt post Teesha 😊

Thanks for ur comments Simy- Appreciate ur time n effort😊

I wish that Yuv had dies instead of Arjun...

I wish that as well...I wud hav thrown a bigger party then we did when Shefali was out

The producer of Saarrthi says that there is a lot of story telling left in them...if this is the story they want to tell...I am not very keen on it. Y did they hv to bring abt this lousy twist to the story??? 😡

Exactly! I dont c any other story then greed n selfishness..n that has been since day one...There really was no need for this...If Karan was out they shud hav shown him going sumwhere n later replaced him...

I am really sad abt Arjun's death. There was no need for it. I personally have not been able to see wat good Arjun's death is going to bring. Now we are back to seeing Bhumi suffer again. 🤢

for sum reason they keep taking us in circles...bhoomi suffering (i.e. first time she was kicked out of HH by shefali) then bhoomi strong (when Gopal Ji entered) then bhoomi suffering again (wid shefali creating differences n misunderstanding) then bhoomi strong again (wid her revenge plan) n again bhoomi suffering...I mean like wat do they think of us? r we dumb or sumthing? cant we c n realise this? n its getting too boring wid the same things....I too cant c any gud in Arjuns death beside one less person to deal wid for M-Y-G!

I never wanted to see Bhumi suffer again...but 2 c r her like this without Arjun is really very sad and pathetic.

It really makes ur heart cry for her...She has seen just too much...She has struggled more then she has been able to stay happy..frm the day she got married to Arjun till today she has been struggling, whether its to win Arjuns love, to b a gud bahu, to becum a mother or to fight evil...Shes been struggling only! n u think agur acha bunke itna bura hota hai tis better to b bad n live peacefully like shefali, mansen, yuv n gun did n r....

The writers of Saarrthi hv 2 b truly ashamed of themselves to come up with this thoughtlesl and needless twist in the story.

well mallika jus brought up a gud point...i guess the directors hav lost track wid so many actors walking out...but then i guess this is apart of the tv industry, u can never b sure who will go out n when so its always best to hav back up plans...plus viewers arent at fault for wat is happening there, they shud consider that we take time out n watch this but they disappoint us almost all the time!

If they did it 4 trps well they r so wrong then....

they'll understand it soon when they c how badly the trps hav sunk!

great comments simy, thanks once again😊

Edited by rajeev4aamna - 18 years ago
mghurye thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#7
Well you see the reason i think they are not ending the show because of foolish pride! I mean you heard what the director or writer said in his interview..."If the script demands it Karan will have to come back for Arjun or Arjun will be brought back...(i dunno i dont really remember)" but what i mean to say it that it has now become a fight between the director and the actor to either show that the director has the power to bring the actor back or to show that the show can survive without the actor (by making us beleive for a short period that Arjun is dead and see the show still survived)" but what they fail to realize is that althougn Karan has become an important part of our lives since he plays "Arjun" the male protagonist..and parting with Karan will be painful and sad for all of us....parting with Arjun on the other hand is fatal and deadly. I mean we can get somehow get over Karan's role dying in the show but we cant get over Arjun's!!! We saw Neha being replaced by Jhalak and survived... so who is Karan?
Edited by mghurye - 18 years ago
armanijee thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#8
HI FRIENDS I AM ArM@Ni JeE
How are you ?
Friends I notice in a star forum that Karan Grover says that he had no time for Saarrthi , he used to shoot at night , that's why he decided to quit Saarrthi .
He told to the creative team ( 2 months prior) about this matter ,that either they show him as dead ( in the show ) or replace him but they choose the former .
He also says that he was saturated ( in his charecter , Arjun ) in the show Saarrthi ( after completing 500 episode of the show ),
so he wanted to do a different thing & then he got the new show " Meri Awaz Ko Mil Gayi Roshni " ,
& he also wanted to give the best to " Meri Awaz ko Mil Gayi Roshni" , that's why he decided to quit saarrthi .
Friends he gets name , fame & recognition from here & now he has no time for Saarrthi!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!.

I JUST HOPE THAT WHATEVER HE WILL DO , HE WILL GET THE SUCCESS.
GOOD LUCK ,& BEST WISHES TO HIM
StayStrong thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 18 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: rajeev4aamna

Hello All,

Im once again here wid another Discussion of the Week n this weeks topic is the most shocking n turning point in Saarrthi-Arjuns death!

Some points to look at n discuss r:

-How has Arjun's death cum across to u?

Miserable😭

-How do u feel knwing the main character has died?

Like the backbone of the body is broken😭

-When Mansen n Yuv first planned on killing AB, did u actually think they wud b successful? Wat were ur thoughts?

No, i cannot even think abt tht but when thy show the bad omen sindoor falling from Bhumi's hands, than it disappoints me becoz usually in sopas the bad omens happen to be true🤢

-Has Arjun's death digest down well? or do u think he will cum back?

He will definitely come back, laken dugest abhi tak nahi hua hai,Zahra nay theek kaha tha ab saarthi dekhtay waqt hajmola saath rakhna padega.

-In ur view, how was the whole death scene? Cud they hav shot it better? Cud they hav omitted sumthing?

Naaaaa yaar it was quite horrible ab is say ziyada bura aur kya hota🤢

-Last but not the least, How did Bhoomis realisation of Arjun's death cum across to u? Did u think she cud hav acted it better? Do u think they shud hav taken awhile to make her believe the death? or do u think her progress is well?

She acted the shot very nicely, she is still in shock as u can see, and she cannot concentrate on her work, not only because M and Yuv is taking advantage of her weakness but she really cannot survive wothout Arjun,(and so am i 🤢)

Please feel free to share ur views n opinions...Looking fwd to a successful discussion....

Teesha sorry for editing ur post but wanted to include 1 more Q's

- Should Arjun have been killed or replaced?

Neither killed and nor replaced.😭i love KG😳😭

MALEKA


Saarrthi Dev Team


divareena thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#10

I am not happy with arjun's death. 😭 The whole point of saarthi is the love between bhoomi and arjun and how they fight against injustince and lies.

Maybe they will bring arjun back in the serial.

Edited by dee7 - 18 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".