Live Update: 26/5/2007 ASVOI - Page 3

as compared to indores auditions mumbais auditions was little boring,only the selected 3 singers were good 😕 ...........baaki to bohat hi below avereage the 😕 .............but hope aage aur achhe singers mile Delhi se 😛 .....

Originally posted by: mcm226

as compared to indores auditions mumbais auditions was little boring,only the selected 3 singers were good 😕 ...........baaki to bohat hi below avereage the 😕 .............but hope aage aur achhe singers mile Delhi se 😛 .....

I saw the promos.... Aadesh went up to stage to tell a contestant who sang "Jeene ke hain chaar din"

"gaana chhodke bhi kuch karte ho... the guy said he is engineer.... Aadesh said to gaana kyon gate ho...... sangeet koi khel nahi hain pooja hain"

Originally posted by: kabhi_21

I saw the promos.... Aadesh went up to stage to tell a contestant who sang "Jeene ke hain chaar din"

"gaana chhodke bhi kuch karte ho... the guy said he is engineer.... Aadesh said to gaana kyon gate ho...... sangeet koi khel nahi hain pooja hain"

this not fair😕 aadesh ko khayal rakhna chahiye,kisise bhi kuch bhi keh dete hai,jabtak sangeet me koi khaas mukaam nahi banta tabtak ghar-war chalaane ke liye kaam-waam to karna hi padta hai na............all time sangeet ko apna career banana itna aasaan to nahi aaj ke competitive world me.................hey Prabhu is nayab nagmo ke nawaab ko sadbudhhi do😊...........

I failed to understand if this show is to select talent from Mumbai and surounding or import from Kolkata. De is a Bengali, Prantika is Bengali and the other contestants except Sailee Tambekar were all from from the east coast. I thought there was a talent search in Kolkata also. So, why are these contestants from the previously auditioned areas are being brought in? I can understand if they bring contestants from West coast states such as Rajastan and Gujerat. Daal my kuch kaalaa hai.

This is for Abhi's benefit. Roz Shaam ati thee song whcih Prantika sang was also sung by Nihira Joshi in C2005, much much better than this girl sang. Personally I felt Prantika was not as good as Nihira in rendering. She may do well on some other songs.

Originally posted by: corvallisi

I failed to understand if this show is to select talent from Mumbai and surounding or import from Kolkata. De is a Bengali, Prantika is Bengali and the other contestants except Sailee Tambekar were all from from the east coast. I thought there was a talent search in Kolkata also. So, why are these contestants from the previously auditioned areas are being brought in? I can understand if they bring contestants from West coast states such as Rajastan and Gujerat. Daal my kuch kaalaa hai.

This is for Abhi's benefit. Roz Shaam ati thee song whcih Prantika sang was also sung by Nihira Joshi in C2005, much much better than this girl sang. Personally I felt Prantika was not as good as Nihira in rendering. She may do well on some other songs.

Sushim dey.... the name may be bengali but he is from Bangalore.... similarly noone of them is from kolkata.... most of them may be bengali but settled in west side of teh country😃

Originally posted by: corvallisi

I failed to understand if this show is to select talent from Mumbai and surounding or import from Kolkata. De is a Bengali, Prantika is Bengali and the other contestants except Sailee Tambekar were all from from the east coast. I thought there was a talent search in Kolkata also. So, why are these contestants from the previously auditioned areas are being brought in? I can understand if they bring contestants from West coast states such as Rajastan and Gujerat. Daal my kuch kaalaa hai.

This is for Abhi's benefit. Roz Shaam ati thee song whcih Prantika sang was also sung by Nihira Joshi in C2005, much much better than this girl sang. Personally I felt Prantika was not as good as Nihira in rendering. She may do well on some other songs.

Of course Nihira sang roz shaam much better. But Prantika is one of the best singers from VOI. 😊

Originally posted by: corvallisi

I failed to understand if this show is to select talent from Mumbai and surounding or import from Kolkata. De is a Bengali, Prantika is Bengali and the other contestants except Sailee Tambekar were all from from the east coast. I thought there was a talent search in Kolkata also. So, why are these contestants from the previously auditioned areas are being brought in? I can understand if they bring contestants from West coast states such as Rajastan and Gujerat. Daal my kuch kaalaa hai.

This is for Abhi's benefit. Roz Shaam ati thee song whcih Prantika sang was also sung by Nihira Joshi in C2005, much much better than this girl sang. Personally I felt Prantika was not as good as Nihira in rendering. She may do well on some other songs.

I think Mumbai is a very cosmopolitan city and there are lots of people originally from other states and are now settled in Mumbai and call themselves proud mumbaikars... I dont think its fair to bring in this regional flavour here..😊

As for your other comment, I agree.. Prantika has a good voice but her rendition of Raz shyam aati thi was nowhere near Nihira's rendition of the same.. NJ was superb in that song👏

Originally posted by: kabhi_21

yes they also shown displeasure at contestants singing Himesh's conposed songs like "Soniye" and "Aitraaz"....

where as he went up on stage and patted for his song in baghbaan

I personally thought Aitaraaz and the Sajna ki wari wari songs were sung real bad...😕 Soniye was ok (though the voice of Rahul was nothing great)... But I agree that Adesh seems to be taking potshots on HR every now and then 😆 I am sure, HR will start that soon in the other show as well 😆 waise, only after he finds time after selling roti and arguing with the other mentors and judges 😉

As for if Adesh is taking his grudge against all songs composed by C07 mentors - may not be true... Sushim also sang a VS composition from Jhankaar Beats.. but he was praised very well by all the judges 😊

I loved 6/2/07...i.e, today's episode. Most of the singers were good in Delhi...specially the second day. But I don't think Aditi wpould be able to do justice to non classical bollywood numbers. She did great in classical song though 😊

I loved Ashpreet's performance a lot. She resembles Vidya Sinha a lot...I think abhijeet was discussing the same with Alka.....he was pointing towards ashpreet's lips and chin....that resembled Rani Mukharjee as well.

Originally posted by: corvallisi

I failed to understand if this show is to select talent from Mumbai and surounding or import from Kolkata. De is a Bengali, Prantika is Bengali and the other contestants except Sailee Tambekar were all from from the east coast. I thought there was a talent search in Kolkata also. So, why are these contestants from the previously auditioned areas are being brought in? I can understand if they bring contestants from West coast states such as Rajastan and Gujerat. Daal my kuch kaalaa hai.

This is for Abhi's benefit. Roz Shaam ati thee song whcih Prantika sang was also sung by Nihira Joshi in C2005, much much better than this girl sang. Personally I felt Prantika was not as good as Nihira in rendering. She may do well on some other songs.

Namaskar NB,

You do have a point but there is no way to figure out where these contestants are from since Mumbai is big comsmopolitan city.

No one has been able to come close to Nihira's rendition of "Roz Shaam aati thi" 😃

BBVT 😛