Is it fair??? - Page 2

Originally posted by: Super Kool

yup he has confessed it to rattu but not 2 rocky.i guess it ll b better if he pours his heart out in fornt of rocky.Rocky was j of rancho bt still he hasnt realised his feelings for tp. mannu never told rocky directly dat hey dude dats my gal!!!!!! 😉 so mannu shud tell his feelings rather than keeping it to his heart n getting into drugs.

oh cummon as i am saying again n again it was soo OBVIOUS ! remember the scene where they were all were at the adda n tp n rattu hav a bet whether amrita likes rocky or mannu! ....n ok even if he hasnt declared it officially......still can ne1 b sooo dumb to nt see his best frnd so much interested in her😕 wat kind of frnd is rocky then if he cant see sumthin which is so obvious??

n 4get tht point.....bt y din he 4 a sec feel tht watever tips amrita was giving him on bettering his performance even mannu may need it!

4 once plz accept rocky is wrong😕!! otherwise as mannu said yest hes always mr.right of the gang!

Originally posted by: rakhi_uv

oh cummon as i am saying again n again it was soo OBVIOUS ! remember the scene where they were all were at the adda n tp n rattu hav a bet whether amrita likes rocky or mannu! ....n ok even if he hasnt declared it officially......still can ne1 b sooo dumb to nt see his best frnd so much interested in her😕 wat kind of frnd is rocky then if he cant see sumthin which is so obvious??

n 4get tht point.....bt y din he 4 a sec feel tht watever tips amrita was giving him on bettering his performance even mannu may need it!

4 once plz accept rocky is wrong😕!! otherwise as mannu said yest hes always mr.right of the gang!

firstly i agree wid ysh amrita is a genuinely nice female and shes quite innocent in liking rocky moreover shes not at all like the typical vamps and insted al dis hatered of tp might actually turn her into a vampy shes sweet shes normal and shes genuinely concerned about rocky and so not like those who does all pyaar ka natak and wat nt

and now coming to rakhis point firstly rakhi must sya u hav probably hit the bull in his eye its an awesme point and i wldnt hav thot of it had u nt mentioned it👏 👏👏and now to think of it i so agree with you

rocky is realy the one whos is to be balemed i mean rember just wen amrita entered rattu said daat we dnt look at frnds plots and then after the concert even a blind eyed cld hav gauged mannus crushing over her the way he held her hand and went to see her off it was dammm damm obvious he had fallen head over heels for her and all three of them including our Rocky were actually making fun of him so they did notice it and rocky is totaly aware of it that mannu likes her

ok i agree that rocky is not romanticaly interested in amrita so he might nt be guilty of trying to capture his frnds plot but on the face and by the tunr of events it does appear to the onlookers that they hav something brewing between them...the macho fight the dance and al the time dey spned together..i am not doubting rockys intentions but it is he who shld clarify to mannu that bhai i am not interested in her

and as for mannu speaking his heart to rocky wel i think they al shared a frndship were they understood each others feleings by a mare look so were does the question of expressions come up now?

and yupp rocky shld hav thot abt mannu too while taking all the music tipis after al he shldnt forget that he too is particiapting in the compy and its his duty to make sure mannu too gets all the access to inside info just like it happens in reality wen we are competing wid our frnds in any exam or smethng it is our duty to make sure that we share al thngs equaly widout hiding naything coz else that wld be fatal for the terim called frndship and trust

[quote=Smriti]rocky is realy the one whos is to be balemed i mean rember just wen amrita entered rattu said daat we dnt look at frnds plots and then after the concert even a blind eyed cld hav gauged mannus crushing over her the way he held her hand and went to see her off it was dammm damm obvious he had fallen head over heels for her and all three of them including our Rocky were actually making fun of him[/quote]
point noted and agreed upon! but thats what i meant up there yaar that if there is any1 3 b blamed its rocky.. he cant call himself such a good friend if he is so thick... he knws bout mannus crush and all that

but come on see my point of this: rocky doesnt like amritha romantically so he doesnt think he is encouraging her... he thinks of her as a friend and cos of that hangs out with her... acc to rocky he isnt doing naything rong or against friendship.. he dusnt like her so he thinks he is no threat to mannu's luv life... if dat gal strts to lyk him its not his fault na????


[quote=Rakhi]he can invite amrita wen the whole gang is present .....y hang out alone wid her?? [/quote]

why should he? its not fair to say that he cant have any other friend other than the 3 of them... if he wants to have other friends ppl shud b supportive of dat.. .lyk rattu... just cos TP nd mannu have their romantic reasons, which he is unaware of, he cnt change it na?
i mean he knws mannu likes her bt he blieves he isnt a threat to mannu cos he dusnt lik her tht way so acc to rocky hes not doing anything wrong na??? he is not breaking friendship bet them and all.. he is hanging out with another girl...


[quote=rakhi]4get tht point.....bt y din he 4 a sec feel tht watever tips amrita was giving him on bettering his performance even mannu may need it[/quote]

c rocky is serious bout his music.. nd he knws for a start tht mannu isnt...and also, wen it cums to his career, he wunt think of anyone else... will u??? i still dunt think hes doing the wrong thing...

Originally posted by: ~Sirius*Ysh~

[quote=Smriti]rocky is realy the one whos is to be balemed i mean rember just wen amrita entered rattu said daat we dnt look at frnds plots and then after the concert even a blind eyed cld hav gauged mannus crushing over her the way he held her hand and went to see her off it was dammm damm obvious he had fallen head over heels for her and all three of them including our Rocky were actually making fun of him[/quote]
point noted and agreed upon! but thats what i meant up there yaar that if there is any1 3 b blamed its rocky.. he cant call himself such a good friend if he is so thick... he knws bout mannus crush and all that

but come on see my point of this: rocky doesnt like amritha romantically so he doesnt think he is encouraging her... he thinks of her as a friend and cos of that hangs out with her... acc to rocky he isnt doing naything rong or against friendship.. he dusnt like her so he thinks he is no threat to mannu's luv life... if dat gal strts to lyk him its not his fault na????

i agree on this one i too feel that rocky is unintentionlay hurting mannu coz rocky thinks hes nt doing anything wrong as to him amrita is just a frnd and i guess the only solution here is a khullam khula talk between the two frnds coz unsaid thngs do smetimes create misunderstandings that are blow out of proportion

Originally posted by: ~Sirius*Ysh~

naa dnt agree to dis one carear and everything are at one place and frndship at another see its so simple as two best frnds sititng for the same exam and one of them gets to knw an additional chapter is included so isnt it his duty to make sure his frnd is also aware of it?

am sure most of us wld hav gone through such thngs smetimes or the other wen sme of our frnds knwingly or unkwningly hide sme information frm us whose cosequences might hav been fatal

its just that in frndship nothng hsld be hidden ya u r competing bt there shld be the spirit of competiiton there shld be a level plane grnd wid no heavy perks laid on one side only and as for mannu not taking singing seriously...its an al together different thng...even if hes nt taking it seriously that doesnt excuse rocky frm nt shairng the info...coz mannu is stil in the compy and hes in it wid the hope to win

Edited by smritisashi - 18 years ago

ohhhhh sum gheated discussions haan.neways all v can hope dat the two shud realise dat both of them r at fault at sum point or other.as it can never b only one personz fault.Both shud b blamed equally.

so we can conclude that rocky is not saint typo atleast 😆 😆 😆 human beings r not perfect and finally that has been portrayed in rocky's case 😆

well ysh i wud b more than glad if he has sum humanly imperfections n faults in him 😉 trust me i wud b the happiest to see him tht way......

bt they shud put tht across on the show re.....no point we jus predicting things.....i want them to show rocky agreeing tht he was selfish n stuff! like the way the show tp mannu n rattu! .....

i sooo want him to b a human u know 😆...hope wat ur saying is rite ysh n they bring tht out on the show aswell! coz till now they hav never once shown him being selfish or rude or having ne humanly qualities 😉

Rocky's conscience is clear. He is not interested in Amrita. If the others are putting 1 plus 1 and misinterpreting him, how will Rocky know about it unless they ask him directly like TP did.
Anyways I just hope this serial does not become a larger than life sort of serial with sacrifices, unnecessary link-ups, rona-dhona etc.