one thing i did not like !!!!!

stuti123 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#1
hey guys ..as per the precap we know that jalal is gonna get super angry with jodha for siding with shenaaz ..nd i fully agree with jalal here ..he was absolutely right ...after all rahim's life was in danger coz of shenaaz 🤢🤢...but one thing which i did not like was jalal shouting at jodha in front of everyone 🤢🤢..this confontration should have happened in private between akdha ...whenever jalal confronts anyone be it rukiya or maham ...it has always in private ...despite knowing it was ruku who had a hand in putting Kanha statues in every hindu baandi's chamber ..he did not shout at her in front of everyone...he confronted maham in private too ...so he should have spoken to jodha also in private ...

Created

Last reply

Replies

10

Views

1.9k

Users

10

Likes

60

Frequent Posters

luvbarun4ever thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
First of all, looks like they were having a family discussion on what happened and it was Jodha who first raised her voice in support of Shenaaz in front of everyone, she could have explained her POV later to Jalal, in that situation do u expect him to take her to separate room and then control his feelings and shout at her. He was just expressing his frustration and anger to his wife, at that moment. That boy could have died..Please think practically dear...
Wait for the Pre-cap to play out...do you agree Jo siding with Shenaaz and not rAHIM in this case?? sHE IS IN CATCH 20 situation HERE.
shilpagowda thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
i am also feeling the same -- jodha gets humiliated royally in pubic that too front to Ruk everytime😡😡😡
jalal will not learn from his mistakes😭😭 cant he talk to her in private
MyExiledSoul thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
You are comparing two different situations ! Here a father is scolding Jodha who is senselessly supporting Shehnaz. What if Rahim was harmed badly ? who would have been responsible for that ? Jalal cannot punish or interrogate Shehnaz considering her mental state. And Jalal is scolding Jodha in front of family ! you cannot call it public. If Jodha argued with Jalal in private then Jalal would have scolded her then too so how does it matter if Samila, HB and Ruq are present there. Nobody cares for self respect and public insults when its about their child's safety.
Mrs.KimJongin thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#5
yeah u r right .. but jodha must stop taking sides now
luvbarun4ever thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: ---Mehak---

yeah u r right .. but jodha must stop taking sides now


You are sooo right. she should stop doing that. What cant she for once go with the family..i expected her to get mad at shenaaz or slap her when she was laughing...
chembi thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: Shweta16

You are comparing two different situations ! Here a father is scolding Jodha who is senselessly supporting Shehnaz. What if Rahim was harmed badly ? who would have been responsible for that ? Jalal cannot punish or interrogate Shehnaz considering her mental state. And Jalal is scolding Jodha in front of family ! you cannot call it public. If Jodha argued with Jalal in private then Jalal would have scolded her then too so how does it matter if Samila, HB and Ruq are present there. Nobody cares for self respect and public insults when its about their child's safety.


yes i completely agree with you and some are more worried for jo's self respect than rahim's life and don't make conclusion with this half baked precap. Let wait for the precap to be aired.😕
shiningways2407 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#8
I dont take it as public humilation. Agree or not but jallu actually said reality as to how can she take a person with her just becoz she had meethi meethi baatien with her? N here matter is more severe ,its matter of somebody's life. Would jodha have taken blame on herself if something had happened to rahim?? Jallu was talking as a father n not as hubby. If I get into any danger becoz of some silly mistakes of my mother then my father's behaviour will b like that only. Apart from this rahim is also amanat oh his khan baba n resposibility. N it was just a kind of family discussion. Now just tell me if salima will also blame jodha infront of all will u call it public humilation?? N jodha is fully aware that shenu is mad, even people of mathura told her. N jalal didnt declare shenu as mad on the basis of her playing with rahim but on the basis of her laughing after rahim fell from roof.
AbHer_neha thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#9
Had Jodha defended Shen in private, Jalal would have definitely shouted at her in private but she defended shehnaz publicly so he had to shout there. Second thing, it was not a personal matter b/w Jodha & Jalal that should be discussed in private. The matter was related to Rahim's life & everyone was concerned abt him. As u said Jalal's anger was very natural & justifiable there but I think even Jodha was not completely wrong in defending Shen. She took her to Agra on her own responsibility. She knows Shen better than other people in Agra as she has spent more time with her. She knows Shen is good at heart though she's mentally disturbed. So she had to defend Shen. We haven't yet seen the actual scene so its too early to comment. May be Jalal thought that shen pushed Rahim & that's why Jo is defending her. After all we all know that Shen's intentions were not eveil.

Thirdly, Jalal's anger on Jodha should not be taken as insult everytime. His anger was natural & that matter can't be discussed privately. Jodha could have spoken to Jalal privately later on but she defended Shen in front of everyone. Just think what would Salima think of her? It sometimes happens that husband shouts on her wife before the other family members in anger so it should not be taken as Jodha's insult & who all were there? HB, Salima & Ruq. They all are the family members. There was no one except the family. Though, I wish Ruq couldn't have been there as she'll only taunt Jodha on this. For me its a family matter discussed b/w the family & if Jalal shouted at Jodha in anger it should not be considered as insult. We all know later on he will feel really bad for Jodha. I would rather wait for the actual episode to air & then will conclude.
durgarvv thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#10
i too felt little bad. he alwyas yell at her infront of everybody. most of the time that gives space for rukku to add some more. one way she is right. shehnaz didn't do intentionally right.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".