...Jes... thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#1

Okay so as first let me clear I am not on anyone's side.. If I say,I Love both of them equally,maybe I will be lying! Anytime I Love Ajab more,and anybody who knows me knows it very well. But in this case I m on both's side! Here both have done something right yet some mistake. Reason is simple because it is all about heart! Maybe it is explained just as a pump which pumps blood in our body in books yet when someone breaks it,it hurts bad,real bad!


now let's go to epi ride with my right and wrong theory and see the result??! 😃


What Ajab did right - She was certain as a daughter!!! I am so proud of her. Really we keep complaining that MM behaves bad with her and blah blah ...but hello,it doesn't approve any child to turn ungrateful to her parent !! Every child may not share good bond with parents,but that doesn't mean they got the certificate to treat them lightly! They have give you life,maybe it seem really less in this material world but it's really something BIG! And atop she is given every facility to live,maybe less father's love,but that just is not enough to turn your back,so My girl you did totally right here!!!

What Ajab did wrong - Along with her father,I feel here is something related to her! Yes,it is not about Pratap,it is about her. She doesn't want to welcome happiness!!! She has turned her back and so anyone who wants to give her happiness i.e. Pratap,she will hurt him. This is her way,deal with it. She doesn't deserve happiness,right? How dare Pratap think to give her happiness?? Why she is feeling this happiness?? She can't take it,she believes she is destined pain.

Along with her weakness,she should have been thoughtful about Bijolia's security! Still that person is there,everyone knows it .. this was something careless on her part.

What Pratap did right - He listened to her plight,or her order! He understood her dilemma. He knows it is not even easy for her to ask him to go. But without increasing her dilemma more,he decides to leaves. He respected her even if she turned this much cruel on her, yes what she did to him was evil,selfish and more heinous.

What Pratap did wrong - I guess he should have given a thought to Bijolia's security. He knows border issues and MS and other stuff. They are all there. Plus,someone in place is plotting and still there. He should have given a thought to it,more than his pain.

Collectively, both are at fault and also right somewhere. Now epi scenes and my few cents :

Ajab asking him to leave - Okay,now the scene was something! What acting,what direction and perfectly chosen music piece,I feel it is from some SLB's on not! To Pratap's total disbelieve!! Brilliant ..they way he kept assuring her that he was safe and healthy,recovering. Even he would discharge her father from his safety duty. But she was arrogant, she kept on saying same thing till he broke down and said he would leave. Why I feel it was more about Ajab asking for her happiness to leave?? She doesn't want happiness. And also believes because of her feeling happy her father was going through all these. She thinks it was her fault. But my dear,it was more than you being happy,more than Pratap coming into your life,it was about Bijolia and it's safety to much extent. So you failed here miserably.. I know soon you will realize what wrong you did. And also same thing goes for Pratap,it was more than she asking something from him, something more than she breaking your heart. Both are too much over taken by their raw emotions .

Ajab crying in temple - She thought it right,She broke him.She needs to be forgiven,but by him.

Pratap packing up - yes she broke you,but shouldn't you stay and think for your motherland? also when your friends also said the same thing?

Pratap and Ajab's last meet - Well I didn't think he will ask for her so openly.maybe that is why she is so afraid of him,he coming into her life? Ajab looking for him and he standing behind her. Well what this scene served us?? I mean.. the depth of their love. Ajab doing such childish things to ignore him? was it that easy to ignore him? Well,yes you are successful Ajab,he felt it and very hard that you were ignoring him and mind it girl,he has felt it!!! And when he was leaving, you kept running to have a glance of him but still would not ask him to stop.


Okay so all this things are clear now .. It was a wrong demand by Ajab! Because things are just not related to her personal feelings,taboos or anything it is about Bijolia,Mewar and whole Rajputana! Why and How can she become so careless?? Also,same goes for Pratap! I won't be wrong if I say more wrong on Pratap's side! As more than Ajab,I expected him to be thoughtful about Motherland and her safety! So more wrong on his part by agreeing to the wrong demand!


So how to judge it?? It makes me go round and round and i find both of them right and more wrong! so i guess it is more suitable to name it love!!! what say? 😉

sorry for not making any sense! 😆😆

Edited by ...Jes... - 11 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

15

Views

1.8k

Users

8

Likes

24

Frequent Posters

Aholic thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
I don't noe, it's just that seeing pratap soo sad is very heartbreaking and jaan is just hurting herself
...Jes... thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: Aholic

I don't noe, it's just that seeing pratap soo sad is very heartbreaking and jaan is just hurting herself

yes dear .. IK,Pratu!!! 😭 uske dil ke tukde kar diye Ajab ne!! 🤢
....Khushboo... thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
Jes🤗
Thank u.🤗

Ok so jesu brilliantly written everything. 👍🏼
U r right with the title.
I agree wid that.👍🏼
Really that was so so heart wrenching epi.
I just cried and cried in the whole epi.😭
Pratap was really hurt.😭
And can't see Ajab crying my baby.😭
Omg me too confused from which side I'm and for whom I cried. 😆
PrAja situation r same but yes Pratap is really hurt 😭and we can see that.😭
I never seen him like that.😭
And yes u right That BG is totally like SLB movie.
And that last scene was also like HDDCS movie.
And lastly Wat a Terrific performance by RoSal. ⭐️
RoSal Nailed it totally. 👍🏼
Hatts of to them for showing so much pain through his acting so easily. 👏
That not a easy task.
Thumps up for RoSal. 👍🏼
Really jesu u put everything perfectly.⭐️👏
Thumps up to u too.👍🏼
Omg Itna lamba ho jayega post pta ni tha.😆
PrAja effect my god.😆

Edited by _GC-AK-Fan_ - 11 years ago
Vinder90 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#5
gud post😊

i made a thread on this discussin what might be in Ajab's mind. . and i stick to my pov that she did right from all angles overall. . . if I had to say right/wrong. . .
ajab:wrong she did was tell Praatp to leaev to soon, but did say he shud stay till he gets better, but its expected Pratap will not stay after being told "athithi ab tum jao"
As daughter of MM, as rajkumari rajputani. . she was semi right/wrong. . as she, destrusting Pratap's ability to defend himself, and what not, was clear about political side of matter too, Pratap cud say Mm you dnot have to care about my security, but at end of day, Pratap is in if anything happens to him, MM is screwed. . SHe could have tried to be her parents confiodence, and tell em all will be well. . but MM is not the person who bother abotu what she has to stay. . and as a side note if pratap stayed, and ajab just said nothing, all we wud see is Gauhar attempt over and over again. . .so with an asasssin running around. . and Pratap, in mode "come out wherever you are, look i am lowering defense. ." That is too much of a risk.
Also the dialog choices that CVs chose cud have been better to clarify few things for both Praja. . there is always something better that cud have been done. . to get this separation happen . .

Pratap: he says he doesnt fear death. . but technically speaking, he needs to understand the value of his life. . what he means to everyone around him also. . . he is indeed a walking fortress, but that was breached easily by Gauhar, Praatp said he felt that SS was helped by someone, but in the cave did not bother to remain alert as to someone else might be there. . .coz he thought SS might haev suffered a natural death. . .so lowered his watchful guard all round and concentrated on SS, and when SS died made way out. .

As another side note, I feel. . . Pratap knows that someone in mehl is assassin, meaning that when ajab told him to laeve, and idea might have struck his mind. . that if he leaevs/ fakes a departure, the assassin wud follow him. . .and to know who the culprit is Pratap is faking a departure. . this is i believe entirely possible. . Since he said he needs to fnid that person, so by listenin to Ajab he will leave, but hope that the assassin comes behind him so he can identify her, and not come back but send a message that he is safe now. . and will return back when Bijolia is under seige or attack. .

so all in all..

I still feel Ajab did right,, she gave not only Mm a chance to get a calmer mind to focus on his duties, and for that health is paramount. . and also prolonged rest time for Pratap. . in that the next attack will take more time, while praatp regenerates health, as in bijolia his lief wud be under sttack constantly, hide and seek gameplay I was sick and tired of. . now that he is on journey back home, shud spell end for gauhar, or a head on meeting with jalal/bairam. . . whatever. .

As for pratap, he was right to accept ajab request to leave. . . I am certain there is more to the picture that him just agreeing, as i said just a while back. . but overall he needs to understand the value of his life. . .openly risking it by eevn askin MM guards to leave the place. . is fine coz he can guard himself,, but the political implications need to be thought through, as if anything happened to him, not him, but MM wud get the blame. . .where MM wud not be at fault coz Pratap himself overuled security to be dismissed. . . Gauhar suceeded once, this doesnt mean she wond suceed again, or anyone else wont suceed again. . . as rajput i understand the ability to fight/ stick to it/ be fearless. . . but in my pov. . giong on the defensive/ temporarily retreating to recuperate, then strike with a big blow is what i wud not refer to as cowardice, but presence of mind courage. . .and being brainy. . . so Pratap needs some downtime. . .in bijolia he will definitely not take any rest, and will keep jumpin up and down tryin to track gauhar down. . while she will try to sneak attack. . .

SO as for PraJa. . both are right. . . overall. . . at least it will save us torture of seein gauhar face planning the next attack PraJa will undoubtedly get stronger. . and this will definietly set the ground for a MM bashing from Pratap or Udai/JB coz I am certain he will need it . . and set ruote for Praja. . . there is alot more at stake based on precap, so ill not go into discussin that. .
Edited by Vinder90 - 11 years ago
Aholic thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: ...Jes...

yes dear .. IK,Pratu!!! 😭 uske dil ke tukde kar diye Ajab ne!! 🤢


Haan, the way he said

Aap toh Meri taraf dekhna bhi nahi chahati😭
Intrepida thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#7
Thank you for the post so nice! I liked how you said that Ajabdeh is afraid of happiness aka Pratap, and its only natural that she would think of it as a dream!
I think that she is right as a daughter but as the daughter of a Samant of Mewad and as a Rajputani she is wrong, Rajputs do their duty even when their health is failing and i think that much Ajabdeh would know because she was the one reading the veer history of Mewar!!

I made my view pretty clear in my regular post 😆

I come from a family that was very much involved in the Indian Independence movement so the idea of loyalty and desh bhakti was taught to us at a very young age and that nothing tops that!
P.D.S thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#8
After reading a few posts I think ajab was right and wrong. It was just so sad to see both pratap and ajab sad and in pain.
...Jes... thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: _GC-AK-Fan_

Jes🤗

Thank u.🤗

Ok so jesu brilliantly written everything. 👍🏼
U r right with the title.
I agree wid that.👍🏼
Really that was so so heart wrenching epi.
I just cried and cried in the whole epi.😭
Pratap was really hurt.😭
And can't see Ajab crying my baby.😭
Omg me too confused from which side I'm and for whom I cried. 😆
PrAja situation r same but yes Pratap is really hurt 😭and we can see that.😭
I never seen him like that.😭
And yes u right That BG is totally like SLB movie.
And that last scene was also like HDDCS movie.
And lastly Wat a Terrific performance by RoSal. ⭐️
RoSal Nailed it totally. 👍🏼
Hatts of to them for showing so much pain through his acting so easily. 👏
That not a easy task.
Thumps up for RoSal. 👍🏼
Really jesu u put everything perfectly.⭐️👏
Thumps up to u too.👍🏼
Omg Itna lamba ho jayega post pta ni tha.😆
PrAja effect my god.😆

awww thank you Di 🤗🤗
I hope i did.😆
RoSal ..OMG! Such emotions portrayed by them .. god!!! 👏

...Jes... thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: Vinder90

gud post😊

i made a thread on this discussin what might be in Ajab's mind. . and i stick to my pov that she did right from all angles overall. . . if I had to say right/wrong. . .
ajab:wrong she did was tell Praatp to leaev to soon, but did say he shud stay till he gets better, but its expected Pratap will not stay after being told "athithi ab tum jao"
As daughter of MM, as rajkumari rajputani. . she was semi right/wrong. . as she, destrusting Pratap's ability to defend himself, and what not, was clear about political side of matter too, Pratap cud say Mm you dnot have to care about my security, but at end of day, Pratap is in if anything happens to him, MM is screwed. . SHe could have tried to be her parents confiodence, and tell em all will be well. . but MM is not the person who bother abotu what she has to stay. . and as a side note if pratap stayed, and ajab just said nothing, all we wud see is Gauhar attempt over and over again. . .so with an asasssin running around. . and Pratap, in mode "come out wherever you are, look i am lowering defense. ." That is too much of a risk.
Also the dialog choices that CVs chose cud have been better to clarify few things for both Praja. . there is always something better that cud have been done. . to get this separation happen . .

Pratap: he says he doesnt fear death. . but technically speaking, he needs to understand the value of his life. . what he means to everyone around him also. . . he is indeed a walking fortress, but that was breached easily by Gauhar, Praatp said he felt that SS was helped by someone, but in the cave did not bother to remain alert as to someone else might be there. . .coz he thought SS might haev suffered a natural death. . .so lowered his watchful guard all round and concentrated on SS, and when SS died made way out. .

As another side note, I feel. . . Pratap knows that someone in mehl is assassin, meaning that when ajab told him to laeve, and idea might have struck his mind. . that if he leaevs/ fakes a departure, the assassin wud follow him. . .and to know who the culprit is Pratap is faking a departure. . this is i believe entirely possible. . Since he said he needs to fnid that person, so by listenin to Ajab he will leave, but hope that the assassin comes behind him so he can identify her, and not come back but send a message that he is safe now. . and will return back when Bijolia is under seige or attack. .

so all in all..

I still feel Ajab did right,, she gave not only Mm a chance to get a calmer mind to focus on his duties, and for that health is paramount. . and also prolonged rest time for Pratap. . in that the next attack will take more time, while praatp regenerates health, as in bijolia his lief wud be under sttack constantly, hide and seek gameplay I was sick and tired of. . now that he is on journey back home, shud spell end for gauhar, or a head on meeting with jalal/bairam. . . whatever. .

As for pratap, he was right to accept ajab request to leave. . . I am certain there is more to the picture that him just agreeing, as i said just a while back. . but overall he needs to understand the value of his life. . .openly risking it by eevn askin MM guards to leave the place. . is fine coz he can guard himself,, but the political implications need to be thought through, as if anything happened to him, not him, but MM wud get the blame. . .where MM wud not be at fault coz Pratap himself overuled security to be dismissed. . . Gauhar suceeded once, this doesnt mean she wond suceed again, or anyone else wont suceed again. . . as rajput i understand the ability to fight/ stick to it/ be fearless. . . but in my pov. . giong on the defensive/ temporarily retreating to recuperate, then strike with a big blow is what i wud not refer to as cowardice, but presence of mind courage. . .and being brainy. . . so Pratap needs some downtime. . .in bijolia he will definitely not take any rest, and will keep jumpin up and down tryin to track gauhar down. . while she will try to sneak attack. . .

SO as for PraJa. . both are right. . . overall. . . at least it will save us torture of seein gauhar face planning the next attack PraJa will undoubtedly get stronger. . and this will definietly set the ground for a MM bashing from Pratap or Udai/JB coz I am certain he will need it . . and set ruote for Praja. . . there is alot more at stake based on precap, so ill not go into discussin that. .

Thank u Vinder! 😳 and thank you for ur awesome reply! :D

well,yes i can see u have talked about Ajab handling her father .. but u think MM is not that type,right?? Well,i expected that Ajab who made MM listen to her words when Pratap was on death bed.Maybe too much expectations.. Also i believe MM can never give Ajab this much power that she wil come out of her taboos!!! we have seen two forms of Ajab ,one Ajab who conquered even Jaggiri Maharaj's anger for her Love and another version of Ajab who became so weak that asked Pratap to leave ..well this is because there were two persons who inspired her to take steps at tow dif times.. When it was about Pratap,she behaved right from every angle ..but when MM took the lead, she again went back to her old form,which is afraid,weak!

And more than her dad,i feel this taboo is her own made,dear! everyone has weak points ..this is Ajab's..she can't think of letting happiness come into her life.

On Pratap's part,also if felt it was wrong,he was hurt,broken yet still he failed to perform his duty!! it was just not only about Ajab and her cruel words ..it is about her motherland! so i do feel he is wrong in accepting her plight/order.. he should have been more thoughtful about the assassin!

From where i can see both are wrong in case of performer their duties,as Rajput heirs .. as a dutiful daughter Ajab turned out weak so Pratap as a warrior (in this particular case)..yet both are right when it comes to raw emotions which are taking over them!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".