Vinder90 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#1
😭 Sainik 😭

These hard working people, probably spend more time burning calories by standing all day, compared to their leaders, like lets say Mahamurk, who sits all day, and has a short burst of action, then sits/ sleeps again, while the poor sainik is busy healing his comrades, guarding mahamurkh, guarding palace, or just patrolling the area .. . . .

Examples. .. / Scenarios. . .
  • In wars, they die in massive numbers, . . . under the command of their generals. . . but thats how wars are. . they just fight till their leader dies, where some fight on, some retreat. . 😭
  • They stand on castle walls still. . usually facing only one direction. . such a limited scene view for a good couple of hours. . 😭 So if they dont look around much, how can they spot incoming attackers? maybe few of the have patrol duty, but then. . dont they get bored patrolling the same area over and over again. . . but i guess life was made easier by rotations. . e.g. gatekeepers wud switch to patrol units, and vice versa. . so they get a chance to grab a breather. . .
  • in the palace. . .poor guards again. . all they do mostly is guard entrances/exits. . and stand their long hours. . usually in pairs, staring at each other. .. when night falls, if mahamurkh forgets to tell them to go home, they will fall asleep while standing. . imagine what happens to their blood flow. . .how will they chase someone when they might wake up with tingly feet. . .
  • the poor guards also dont have good weapons. . . example, the mahmurkh palace guards equipped with spears only. . .assuming there is an attack, and they throw the spear, they will be weapon-less. . .at least they deserve bow and arrow, with a bug stockpile of arrows close to them, and replacement bows. . .thats what i calla a security. .
  • in some cases, imagine, their spears aer also crooked. . like the guards chasing pratap when he came to bijolia, one of them had a slightly bent spear. . that spear is useless, if thrown on target, it will surely defiate thanks to air resistance not evenly distributed. .
  • again another sad situation for them, when the royals and friends eat, they are busy guarding them. . .willl they get fed? maybe later. . or from whats left. . .shud be nice if cvs someday show pratap doing army services, ensuring their welfare, it was nice they showed pratap once checkin out their weapons, i was thinking, perhaps pratap shown to ensure army is well fed. . and i need more speeches perhaps . . . when ajab/phool made food came, poor soldiers might have also want so badly to eat. .. but all they can really do is face the other side, and just look away. . .nahi dekha jaraha. . muh me pani uncontrollable. . .😭

SO its easy to assume soldiers dont go a good job guarding or what not. . but the main issue is for their leaders/generals, to ensure soldiers are well trained, that their duties are less monotonous like staring at each other while guarding for hours. . , that they are well fed, that they are provided with proper weapons, and alternatives also. . that even their security is taken care of, e.g. a patrol guard on each floor/ segment of palace so that like yesterday, SS wud have perhaps been spotted if there was a seperate guard patrolling. . . sadly enuf ever after the maid yelling for help, not a single soldier was in position close to the radius of the voice projection. . again the laeders are responsible for proper allocations. . . so I would call this failure of the palace guard allocators. . .

Anyways guys. . I dunno what I just wrote, I just wrote it. . .forgive me if there are parts u did not like. . .but this was just my way of in a short time, raw way, dedicating a post to the sainiks of those times. . MP is a historical serial, soldiers are a key part due to wars. . .CVs have done few instances of showing care for soldiers, like Udai and mahamurkh deciding to not make soldiers stampede on foot , and decided to go ahead on their own when defending bijolia. . Praatp speeches to army aer always fantastic. . but I think the audience wud loev to see some subtle smaller moments. . e.g. pratap friendship with a small soldiers batalion, , maybe include his friends and make that battalion the elite guard. . . CVs showed training times when pratap was preparing to retake afghan stolen areas. . .so that was good, but perhaps more interaction with soldiers. . .

anyways, i hope u guys understand what I mean. . .i dunno why again i made this post lol. . just felt like it. .. so yeah. . 😊
Edited by Vinder90 - 11 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

10

Views

1.5k

Users

4

Likes

13

Frequent Posters

Intrepida thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
Thanks for the post! hence the slogan- Jai Jawan, Jai Kissan!
When Pratap lived in the jungles, his close companions and soldiers were one and the same, thats when we will get to see the real camaraderie between soldier and the Maharana!! 👏
nirmalac99 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
Never in my dreams thought ,any 1 would make dis type of Posts...Thanks for sharing ur view.👍🏼...it s an incredible👏👏👏...

I find Bijolia's guards never had any proper training😔...y cant d soldiers used in d battle nd d guards of d Palace can b shifted once and then? so tat both d sainiks ll b trained equally...SS every time used d weakness of bijolia's untrained guards to reach his goals...they should ve used some whistles like thing to contact each other,so tat these types of deaths could b avoidable...

D guards mite ve brought food 4m their home😆...nd i find guards do talk(During earlier epi of MRP,i find guards gossiping) ...

d soldiers 2 decide d loss and win of d battle(eg Jalal's battalion)...
Edited by nirmalac99 - 11 years ago
Vinder90 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: Intrepida

Thanks for the post! hence the slogan- Jai Jawan, Jai Kissan!

When Pratap lived in the jungles, his close companions and soldiers were one and the same, thats when we will get to see the real camaraderie between soldier and the Maharana!! 👏

we said . .

pratap jungle adventures were awesome and very well executed
Vinder90 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: nirmalac99

Never in my dreams thought ,any 1 would make dis type of Posts...Thanks for sharing ur view.👍🏼...it s an incredible👏👏👏...

I find Bijolia's guards never had any proper training😔...y cant d soldiers used in d battle nd d guards of d Palace can b shifted once and then? so tat both d sainiks ll b trained equally...SS every time used d weakness of bijolia's untrained guards to reach his goals...they should ve used some whistles like thing to contact each other,so tat these types of deaths could b avoidable...

D guards mite ve brought food 4m their home😆...nd i find guards do talk(During earlier epi of MRP,i find guards gossiping) ...

d soldiers 2 decide d loss and win of d battle(eg Jalal's battalion)...

thanks 😊 i just felt like makin this post

right about mahamurkh's soldiers. . when SS was catapulted in, the gatekeepers did not even know how to fight at all. . another example is when phool called for sainiks to save her from pratap lol. . .the guards have no idea who pratap is , how he looks like. . they shud have followed phool orders as she said to arrest him. . instead one guard backed off in fact, and looked down. . i mean that is what i call an incompetent failed guard. . . his companion got downed by pratap, and he surrendered LOL. . ..

but overall CVs do a nice job at showin the sainik's involvement or pratap involvement with the armies/guards, backgorunds with guards standing around or just guarding, could be improved by adding dynamism. . as in .. instead of just standing there looking at each other,, guards cud be shown patrolling more actively, instead of just when they are needed in a scene like when pratap hid form guards when he arrived in bijolia. . sometimes guards in the back/soldiers just seem like background fillers lol. . .more dynamism as i said wud be sone pe suhaga. . but anyways i am still happy with what cvs have mustered so far
nirmalac99 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: Vinder90

thanks 😊 i just felt like makin this post

right about mahamurkh's soldiers. . when SS was catapulted in, the gatekeepers did not even know how to fight at all. . another example is when phool called for sainiks to save her from pratap lol. . .the guards have no idea who pratap is , how he looks like. . they shud have followed phool orders as she said to arrest him. . instead one guard backed off in fact, and looked down. . i mean that is what i call an incompetent failed guard. . . his companion got downed by pratap, and he surrendered LOL. . ..

but overall CVs do a nice job at showin the sainik's involvement or pratap involvement with the armies/guards, backgorunds with guards standing around or just guarding, could be improved by adding dynamism. . as in .. instead of just standing there looking at each other,, guards cud be shown patrolling more actively, instead of just when they are needed in a scene like when pratap hid form guards when he arrived in bijolia. . sometimes guards in the back/soldiers just seem like background fillers lol. . .more dynamism as i said wud be sone pe suhaga. . but anyways i am still happy with what cvs have mustered so far



dey showed Pratap was one among d sainik's ,wen he initially joined his Father's regiment...
@bold,dey need not even call themselves as soldier lol😆...
Atleast Marwar's soldiers tried to protect their Rahkumari's wen Jalal,followed them👏
Vinder90 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: nirmalac99



dey showed Pratap was one among d sainik's ,wen he initially joined his Father's regiment...
@bold,dey need not even call themselves as soldier lol😆...
Atleast Marwar's soldiers tried to protect their Rahkumari's wen Jalal,followed them👏


yes, very right about marwar soldiers as well, desipte them being appiointed/trained by jalam lol 😆
Vinder90 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: ...Jes...

awesome post! 👍🏼


thanks 😊
pyaaribehna thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#9
sainik's life is difficult. that is why they turn out to be toughies.

just think of jhansi ki rani with the kid tied to her back and not knowing where she would next going into battle. that takes courage.
Vinder90 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: pyaaribehna

sainik's life is difficult. that is why they turn out to be toughies.


just think of jhansi ki rani with the kid tied to her back and not knowing where she would next going into battle. that takes courage.


very very true

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".