Jo chooses her self respect - Page 43

Created

Last reply

Replies

422

Views

19.7k

Users

34

Likes

1.6k

Frequent Posters

RadhikaS0 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: elasingh

Hi radhika...great post...
I loved ur point abt MV ...she might have tried to save Jo's marriage by refusing to take her back but she should have done it privately...But actually Ameri's have sacrificed Jo for the security...they very well knew that their daughter would not ask to be taken back unless there was some serious issues but they didnot care...
Even after vishpan none of them except Man Singh bothered to visit Jo...No wonder Jo cares more for suja who came to Jalal's territory to meet Jo...
Now MV is ashamed of her behavior ...
Both Ameri and Jallu have realised that Jo doesn't have just two options but a third option too...They better not take her for granted...


Yes, Ela. Though Mainavati gave the reason as saving Jodha's marriage, it seems the Ameris were also reluctant to get on the bad side of Jalal and therefore didn't take Jodha back with them.

The situation that has occurred now had occurred then too. In fact, it was worse. If Jalal hadn't saved Jodha, she would have been dead.

If Bharmal could come and take her to Amer yesterday, why didn't Mainavati then? After all, he said that his daughter was mentally upset and needed to heal amidst her family, away from Jalal for the time being. Jodha was mentally agitated after the MC track too.

Bharmal said that they always invited their daughters home for Gangaur and she would be distracted from her problems by the festivities. Then also it must have been time for Gangaur (after Holi, and the first Gangaur for Jodha after marriage). So Mainavati could have taken her home for the festival and counselled her properly there and sent her back to Agra, after allowing time for Jalal to cool down too.

Didn't Bharmal say yesterday that Jodha's mother and grandmother would counsel her and ensure that she returned to Jalal? This same method could have been resorted to one year back too and it would have worked wonders too.

Somehow, I also feel Jodha has been sacrificed for her family's interests - they are so guarded about their own family and Amer that they don't care what happens to her. Even MS has not done anything for his bua even after being at Agra. Sujamal is perhaps the only one from her family who has time and again risked his life to meet her, whether at her marriage or now.

Now also Bharmal may have come looking for Jodha to appease Jalal. Now he is talking of a daughter's rights - what if Jodha had asserted these rights then and overridden Mainavati and landed up at Amer? Would he have welcomed her? It's also a matter of shame for them in the eyes of society that their daughter is living in an ashram, away from her parental home. So now they are covering up their shame by making a grand show of affection and taking her home. Jodha has given them a befitting reply that she is not at their mercy - she can lead an independent existence.
MaddyO thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: RadhikaS0


Yes, Ela. Though Mainavati gave the reason as saving Jodha's marriage, it seems the Ameris were also reluctant to get on the bad side of Jalal and therefore didn't take Jodha back with them.

The situation that has occurred now had occurred then too. In fact, it was worse. If Jalal hadn't saved Jodha, she would have been dead.

If Bharmal could come and take her to Amer yesterday, why didn't Mainavati then? After all, he said that his daughter was mentally upset and needed to heal amidst her family, away from Jalal for the time being. Jodha was mentally agitated after the MC track too.

Bharmal said that they always invited their daughters home for Gangaur and she would be distracted from her problems by the festivities. Then also it must have been time for Gangaur (after Holi, and the first Gangaur for Jodha after marriage). So Mainavati could have taken her home for the festival and counselled her properly there and sent her back to Agra, after allowing time for Jalal to cool down too.

Didn't Bharmal say yesterday that Jodha's mother and grandmother would counsel her and ensure that she returned to Jalal? This same method could have been resorted to one year back too and it would have worked wonders too.

Somehow, I also feel Jodha has been sacrificed for her family's interests - they are so guarded about their own family and Amer that they don't care what happens to her. Even MS has not done anything for his bua even after being at Agra. Sujamal is perhaps the only one from her family who has time and again risked his life to meet her, whether at her marriage or now.

Now also Bharmal may have come looking for Jodha to appease Jalal. Now he is talking of a daughter's rights - what if Jodha had asserted these rights then and overridden Mainavati and landed up at Amer? Would he have welcomed her? It's also a matter of shame for them in the eyes of society that their daughter is living in an ashram, away from her parental home. So now they are covering up their shame by making a grand show of affection and taking her home. Jodha has given them a befitting reply that she is not at their mercy - she can lead an independent existence.



Radhika I agree! I also wrote something similar, just read one page back here, about Jodha's not going back to Amer.

I do agree with Mainavati's decision not to take Jodha back then. I agree with the why of it but NOT HOW MV did it.

Though she could have taken her for few days certainly. Mainavati was scared Jodha's marriage was ending. Remember this was the phase of extreme ghrina for both. So that time if Jodha had gone to Amer, probably their relations would have ended. What is the guarantee that Jalal would not have forgotten her?
He was the one agreeing to release her. BTW even Jalal knew that Jodha even in Amer will always be HIS WIFE. So he had got her either way.

Now the things are different. Amer family can SEE THE PROOF that Jalal loves her. Now they know that Jalal is trying to mend the relationship. Jalal is doing everything possible to find Jodha and to win her back.

So this time when they take Jodha to Amer - they know it will NOT END HER MARRIAGE. In fact just the opposite, Jodha will think calmly and Jalal will not give up on Jodha.

Wasn't that what Bharmal told Jalal? That he should come to Amer. Bharmal's asking for permission from Jalal to take Jodha to Amer was his way of saying Jodha belongs with Jalal.

I so wish Jalal takes the Gangaur hint and goes to Amer to win his Jodha back. Gangaur is where they started and it is only appropriate that Gangaur is where their love and real relationship would start.

history_geek thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: kmmdesai



I never seen anyone bashing Jalal so strongly when he did any mistake, ever. Why only Jodha?
I never seen people praising wholeheartedly for when Jodha did good, but when Jalal did good, he was heaped with praises. Jodha was called "lecturer", "devi", "Mahan" in a sarcastic way.

Why do we have to be either with Jalal or with Jodha? Can we not be for both of them? I love both.
Why cant we celebrate both of them?

But, extream negetivity puts me off. Then I have to defend Jodha, which would seem as I am opposing Jalal. That is not the case.

Also, people who are so negetive about Jodha, they claim that she is being potrayed as mahan, saint wherein Jalal is always wrong and she always right. And he has to beg and beg for his forgiveness in order to show Jodha as mahan.

If Jodha is doing a mistake by rejecting Jalal's apologies, then how come she is being considered as Mahan? Mahan people do not make any mistakes, right?
If Jodha is being potrayed as Mahan and saint-like, then would it not be that she would have spared Jalal's feelings and forgiven him immediately, even before he utters the word "Sorry"?
Twisted logic???

Love
Kshithi




@Bold...You said it all. 😉

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".