Anu Mallik is being nasty to singers - Page 4

Originally posted by: saan1997

What javed akhtar is doing in indian idol 3?this is a singing competition not mushaira!Does he know anything about singing.only a singer can judge a singer.There are so many things involved in singing.(Aapka ucchaaran thik nahi tha 😡 ),thats the only thing he can say.Aa far anu is concerned he has good ears.He knows what he is doing.May be technical advise sonu used to give to the contestent will sure be missing. 😊

😆 Have you ever heard Anu Malik sing 😆😆 You're ears will be damaged yaar 😆 Anyway I got your point, that only people who have knowledge of music should be in the jury...but I just had to say it 😆

Anyway the harsh attitude is a part of indian idol or any idols-programme in the world. I do think that it's not necessary to be this harsh and totally make a fool out of the people who are standing there...but well that's how they're scoring the viewers. Though his fighting with Javed-saheb is very out of place. Javed Akhtar is respected personality in bollywood, and he is elder than Anu Malik, so he should not fight with him on international television....khair, I agree that Anu Malik is going a bit too far this time.

Originally posted by: Sapno_ki_rani

Well pronouncation is very important while singing...like Farha had nothing to do with singing but she still played an imp. part in last 2 ii. The lyricist sits down with musicians and singers and discuss the songs...And Javed Akhtar is a very intelligent man who has been in the industry even before Sholay was made so he knows what makes a good singer. I respect him so much and Anu is not even half as talented as Mr. Javed Akhtar!!!

very well said!! 😛

I didn't watch II2 but I watched the 2 episodes of II3 and I thought Anu Malik was rude and was putting down the contestants and that's not nice at all.

The best thing they have done in this I I 3 is to remove farha khan as judge.Alisha is much better.I never consider anu as a great singer but he certainly know what is besura!farha and javed makes a good pair of judge in MUJRA AND MUSHAIRA competion! 😆

I agree that he is mean but only sometimes, not all the time. Plus, these people who come in the show...they should self-record their voice, listen to it, and decide if it is good enough to be sung on national television. People sing horribly and IAM SURE they know it. Therefore, I think Anu has the right to embarrass them so that they realize how HORRIBLE some of them sing. But as a matter of fact, people will keep coming even though they know that they sing horribly. So it really does not matter.