Results for Round 6-SRGMP singing Contest

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

DON't-ASK-IT

@Sara_DONT_ASK

Stunner

+ 4

Posted: 18 years ago

#21

Originally posted by: Thakur Saab
🤗
You were good too Saara. Will miss you and your nok jhok with your partner in the contest. Yes do practice. You have the potential to sing much better just that you need regular practice.

Hey Thakur Saab 🤗

Nok jhok abhi khatam kahan hoi hai....😆😆😆

I want Partner's views on the song i have sung for RD Burman round ☺️☺️☺️

And yes we 'Alaapians' gonna give u strong takkar in RDB n ARR round...😈...!!!

Quote

punjini

@punjini

Dazzler

Posted: 18 years ago

#22

I am not too happy with some of the rankings. Ashish and Raju definitely deserved to be above some of the others. Ashish, especially sang superbly in this round.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

greatmaratha

@greatmaratha

Inactive

+ 2

Posted: 18 years ago

#23

Originally posted by: punjini
I am not too happy with some of the rankings. Ashish and Raju definitely deserved to be above some of the others. Ashish, especially sang superbly in this round.

I concur entirely. I also suspect that this could be because the songs they selected were not the typical filmy songs or classical songs, but a different genre.

I recognise the song of Ashish, and the emotions he put into the song are fabulous.... the earthy feel of the song, the simple words depicting the life of the fisherfolk, was very well executed.

I enjoyed Raju's song, again it was capturing the correct emotions of the song/ music/ lyrics, which set his apart from the others.

And I concur with Aparna's ranking. Thats bang on.👏

Quote

punjini

@punjini

Dazzler

Posted: 18 years ago

#24

Oh yes, no fights about Aparna's ranking. 😃 👏

Quote

seemai

@seemai

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

#25

Originally posted by: punjini
Oh yes, no fights about Aparna's ranking. 😃 👏

Very true.. Aparna deserved to be #1. Congrats Aparna!! that song was very well sung, being a Maharashtrian, big fan of Marathi songs myself, your song was not an easy one at all and you sang it with great ease , as always..

Sahana & others, I can understand your feeling about Ashish not getting the place he deserves and if it helps at all, I am ready to step down. I don't want something that people think I don't deserve. Also, I am participating in this contest to get pure joy and be in touch with music by having to sing songs of different types. I know Ashish deserves to be well above me, so if it helps any, I volunteer to step down from my place.

Quote

@AG

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

#26

😃 Keeping with the tradition, I too have changed my id 😛 😆 (Aparna)

Edited by AG - 18 years ago

Quote

punjini

@punjini

Dazzler

Posted: 18 years ago

#27

Originally posted by: seemai

Very true.. Aparna deserved to be #1. Congrats Aparna!! that song was very well sung, being a Maharashtrian, big fan of Marathi songs myself, your song was not an easy one at all and you sang it with great ease , as always..

Sahana & others, I can understand your feeling about Ashish not getting the place he deserves and if it helps at all, I am ready to step down. I don't want something that people think I don't deserve. Also, I am participating in this contest to get pure joy and be in touch with music by having to sing songs of different types. I know Ashish deserves to be well above me, so if it helps any, I volunteer to step down from my place.

No question of anyone stepping down! I will go by the judges' verdict. It was my personal opinion that Ashish and Raju deserved a better ranking in this round. In any case, they are not getting eliminated by this ranking..so no problem at all. Wish you all success in the coming rounds too.

Quote

Barnali

@Barnali

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 18 years ago

#28

Now i hav a request here. At the outset of the contest a rule/guideline was created that 'the judges' decision will be final and there cannot be any questioning of that. please do check the rules topic 😊

we are all very happy to have so many good singers and to judge their performance is indeed becoming difficult by the judges. This fact is also evident to the mentors who are privy to the Judges ratings and they can see for themselves how close the ratings are between two rankings. The mentors are also forwarded the judges comments by PM for the results of a round, so that they get to see the criteria for judgment and the judges opinions (this part when sent). at times maybe a difference of, maybe not even full 1 marks, by one of the judges is causing the difference in the ranking.

It is my request to the mentors to go through the ratings and the judges comments when it is sent AND if there is still any further clarification required, then the mentors are more than welcome to a voice their opinion, concern,issues, but please make it through PM to the coordination team and sort it out.

We should remember that many participants can be demoralized by seeing their rankings questioned when such concerns are voiced openly and i am sure as responsible and senior members here none of us want to undermine their achievements 😊

As we approach the future rounds, it will indeed be difficult to see a participant get eliminated as all of them are just too good. So, we would really appreciate, if the following two rules of the "Rules and Regulations" that was drawn up for this contest is very judiciously followed:

13. The judge's decision is abiding and final and cannot be contested or argued upon.

14. Mentors are requested to maintain cordiality amongst themselves, conduct themselves in a manner befitting their status in the contest. In the event of any disagreement, they are open to resolve it amongst themselves via PM and not bring the same onto forum or bring the same to the notice of other members of sections.

Thanks.
Co-Ordination Committee.