My opinions on today's show

104869 thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#1
Looks like Anu Malik has spent all his idle time ?(as he hardly composes music these days) in studying Simon Cowell's behaviour in American Idol and X factor.
What else can explain his sudden change of behaviour. Atleast Simon seems genuine in his comments, But Anu... he was clearly aping Simon. It looks totally unreal.

Regarding the contestants:

Richa was fabulous. She really deserves a big round of applause. She did what very few have been able to do till today: Singing both classical and light music with great ease. Its so tough to believe that she's 16. It takes a lot of courage to come and sing in front such established musicians.

BTW why did the girl from Assam not get selected? Clearly Anu affected Uditji's opinion. And why was the cxamera constantly panning up and down on her dress. Were they trying to say that her dressing sense was her undoing? If so it's in real bad taste.
The concept of reality show works bcoz ordinary ppl like you and me, who may be shy, not look that attractive or wear ordinary dresses; have an opportunity to make it big. If a person is not seleted on the basis of their dressing, its not a good precedent.

I alos like the guy who sang the song from Kalyug. I think his name is sri... something. Lets see how he gets around in the nxt round.

I was really waiting to hear the orange shirt guys sing teri diwani completely. But alas they did not show it.

The hilarious bits were ok. But none yet to match the All time favourite: the Guy who sang Aashiq banaya aapne last year.
BTW, Wats with that weird Alisha fan. I felt he was actually being hired by Sony to put up a show.

The real star for me today was the editor, who managed to put in a lot of good bits at a good pace, the villain was Anu malik who was trying his best to be rude, but someone needs to tell him that if at all he is coming across something by this behaviour; its not rude but Desperate.

Shoot your opinions.


Edited by pragya0 - 18 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

10

Views

933

Users

9

Likes

1

Frequent Posters

~Poonam~ thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#2
anu as villan 😆

yah i know editer did a grate job 😛

yup anu is simon part two 😆
104869 thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: ~Poonam~

anu as villan 😆

yah i know editer did a grate job 😛

yup anu is simon part two 😆



Simon part Two😆😆😆
Mitesh.P thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 18 years ago
#4
I see what you mean. His comments were not genuine and now you mention it I would agree he is trying to copy Simon's behaviour from American Idol. I don't know why he as arguing with Javed so much. Javed is a former judge too and the way he shut Alisha up was so rude. Great minds think alike....in the case of Simon and Anu Malik that may be true but they are not 'great minds' 😆
kothra thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#5

Lol..Anu is gng to b main vilian nw..lol...

N we r gng to c lots of fight btw Javed akhtar n Anu Malik..

Well Richa was realy good...she is just 16..she is gng to rock ii3...

The funniest part was tht guy from punjab Jaspreet singhJavedji tod him to have his own album Noise Pollution😆

username88 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#6
ye man he was so tryin 2 b simon...buh even simon is better lol

n i dun like da fact dat anu gets da decidin vote if the judges decision is tied...dats not fair at all

Edited by xmuqix - 18 years ago
angelicsmile thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#7
well my opinion on todays episode is i thought it was kindda waste of time.. i dont mean to offend n e one nor do i mean to say it was bad.. i equally love indian idol but today v hardly got to hear n e one sing.. in one whole hr they showed everything except the singing performances.. i think they should hav included more... its probably cuz it was first episode and they wanted to show other stuff s well but i hope to see more of singers n performances than other stuff..

well bout the judgement i m totally against anu.. i dont think he know wat indian idol is lookin for.. again if i m hurting n e of his fans i m really sorry b cuz i dont mean to.. i m jus putting my point of view forward..
he said he is looking for someone who has class, personality, voice n i dont know wat else..
i mean voice is the most important thing..personality comes second.. n like javed akhtar said if someone is coming from a simple family u dont expect that particular class in them but once they r singing gud u can make a total difference to someones looks, personality and class..

when javed said all this anu was like u r gettin emotional.. but that wasnt the point.. i think wat javed said was completely right..n i think that girl in white dress should have been selected to go to mumbai.. also she was way better than that shibhangi girl.. she was totally westernised.. i dont say its bad b cuz i live in london s well but when it comes to becoming indian idol u should b able to represent india...which i think she wouldnt have been able to lookin at wat she was acting...

well that was very long post so i finish here but i would luv to know wat other hav to say bout it
Edited by miss17 - 18 years ago
sweety001 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#8
lolz...i havent seen it yet but will tonight and see.....sounds funny.... 😆
Khushi11 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: pragya0

Looks like Anu Malik has spent all his idle time ?(as he hardly composes music these days) in studying Simon Cowell's behaviour in American Idol and X factor.
What else can explain his sudden change of behaviour. Atleast Simon seems genuine in his comments, But Anu... he was clearly aping Simon. It looks totally unreal.

Regarding the contestants:

Richa was fabulous. She really deserves a big round of applause. She did what very few have been able to do till today: Singing both classical and light music with great ease. Its so tough to believe that she's 16. It takes a lot of courage to come and sing in front such established musicians.

BTW why did the girl from Assam not get selected? Clearly Anu affected Uditji's opinion. And why was the cxamera constantly panning up and down on her dress. Were they trying to say that her dressing sense was her undoing? If so it's in real bad taste.
The concept of reality show works bcoz ordinary ppl like you and me, who may be shy, not look that attractive or wear ordinary dresses; have an opportunity to make it big. If a person is not seleted on the basis of their dressing, its not a good precedent.

I alos like the guy who sang the song from Kalyug. I think his name is sri... something. Lets see how he gets around in the nxt round.

I was really waiting to hear the orange shirt guys sing teri diwani completely. But alas they did not show it.

The hilarious bits were ok. But none yet to match the All time favourite: the Guy who sang Aashiq banaya aapne last year.
BTW, Wats with that weird Alisha fan. I felt he was actually being hired by Sony to put up a show.

The real star for me today was the editor, who managed to put in a lot of good bits at a good pace, the villain was Anu malik who was trying his best to be rude, but someone needs to tell him that if at all he is coming across something by this behaviour; its not rude but Desperate.

Shoot your opinions.




omg I totally agree with every single word of urs!!! I was gonna write this all but am glad I read urs before I wrote mine... 😳... excellent obsevations... I lovedd Richa am her fan already!!!! I listened to her song like 20 times so far..she has such pain in her voice I felt like crying...she is so talented its hard to believe . I pray to God that a simple girl like her with amazing voice and perfect sur wins this years Indian Idol. I also agree that that girls in the white drses should've been selected she was also very good.. I think cuz she was saying dialogues in the middle of the song that might've hurt her concentration on her sur but she was excellent and should've been given another chance
104869 thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: Khushi11



omg I totally agree with every single word of urs!!! I was gonna write this all but am glad I read urs before I wrote mine... 😳... excellent obsevations... I lovedd Richa am her fan already!!!! I listened to her song like 20 times so far..she has such pain in her voice I felt like crying...she is so talented its hard to believe . I pray to God that a simple girl like her with amazing voice and perfect sur wins this years Indian Idol. I also agree that that girls in the white drses should've been selected she was also very good.. I think cuz she was saying dialogues in the middle of the song that might've hurt her concentration on her sur but she was excellent and should've been given another chance



You are right, they cud havew asked her to sing another song to judge

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".