Most controversial judge - Page 4

Originally posted by: archangel

well if any contestant gets on the wrong side of Javed Akthar that will be the end of his idol dream and he will certainly become INDIAN IDLE a la Arpita

welcome archangel...... loved your first one-liner👏😆😛

when I first heard the panel of judges Anu, Udit & Alisha... I was not so excited but when I heard there is also gonna be another judge none other than Javed Akhtar then I got excited as he always adds the spice to the judgement with his controverSial comments sometimes fair sometimes biased sometimes reasonable sometimes funny!!!!!1 he is the only old generation celeb who burns the stage with fire with his words by just sitting at one place 😆 😆 😆

Originally posted by: S a r a h

welcome archangel...... loved your first one-liner👏😆😛

thank you Sarahji😉😆😉

Originally posted by: archangel

well if any contestant gets on the wrong side of Javed Akthar that will be the end of his idol dream and he will certainly become INDIAN IDLE a la Arpita

You are right. The good thing about Javed Akhtar is his apt comments but I have noticed that he doesn't like confident girls and he unnecessarily stresses on pronunciation. Ab har koyi thodi Urdu mein shayari kahega.

Originally posted by: Maya_M

You are right. The good thing about Javed Akhtar is his apt comments but I have noticed that he doesn't like confident girls and he unnecessarily stresses on pronunciation. Ab har koyi thodi Urdu mein shayari kahega.

I think he doesn't like over-confident and brash girls. I agree about the pronunciation issue.. he pushes the difficult ones in urdu.. but I don't think he has a bias against confident gals. Arpita's performance level never matched her attitude and it irked him. ( me too😆😆). Let us see how he treats talented gals with optimum confidence.

I like Javedji as judge. I do not think he dislikes Confident women. It might be the case of Over confident or bit stuck up kind he may not be fond of. Arpita Mukharjee was perfect example of that IMHO.

She was one "empty vessels make lots of noise" she is OK singer but had the attitude of Queen.....

As QT mentioned her attitude did not match her talent-performance.

Actually I dont know who would be the controversial judge. I think the one does not fit in as judge is Miss. Alisha C.😳 It will be fun to see what type of drama they bring on the show 😆

I am very much looking forward to II 3 and see what type of talent we will be watching. 😃

Originally posted by: mermaid_QT

I think he doesn't like over-confident and brash girls. I agree about the pronunciation issue.. he pushes the difficult ones in urdu.. but I don't think he has a bias against confident gals. Arpita's performance level never matched her attitude and it irked him. ( me too😆😆). Let us see how he treats talented gals with optimum confidence.

I always found him partial towards Ruprekha. He picked on her pronunciation but in a sweet way. But it always looked like he couldn't stand Arpita😆. I thought he was there to judge singing talent not their arrogance😉 and this after having two confident women in his life.

I agree that sweet and down to earth contestants connect to ordinary people first like Ruprekha, Sandeep Acharya. But judges should know better. Among these 4 judges Javed Akhtar is still my favorite but I wish he stop commenting on anything and everything and do his job. When his comments surpass a limit that becomes rudeness too. I can't wait to see him picking on Anu Malik's shayari though😆.