Let's look at the evidence....

Page

Next Last

eveline

@eveline

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

Ok..so the argument against Rudra is that he is a trained army officer, plus he should know Paro by now and should trust his instincts. Fine...what does a trained mind do, put the pieces of the puzzle together, pick up the clues, heed the evidence...so lets look at the first overwhelming evidence pointing towards Paro in this case.

Prologue...his first instincts were KaakiSa...but she was present with them, through and through...

1. First hand impartial eyewitness...Sunehri explicitly stated that she saw Paro doing the same. Sunehri has no grouse or enemity against Paro, on the contrary she was a friend and fan of hers. Rudra asked her not once but twice, to think again and respond. Her answer remained firm and confident.

2. Samrat's evidence...The fire was definitely arson. Who was present?? Motive???

2. Paro's own words...Her total insistence that she will not marry him at any cost. Her reference to fire and her jumping in it..again and again. Especially fire being a highlight.

3. Paro's psychological state...No one can doubt how much she hated Rudra, and his sheer presence. Her ill will, her hatred was undisguised. So her trying to harm Rudra would be no surprise

4. Paro's actions...She hit him on the head, from the back, and escaped with the enemy. That itself points to the fact, that she was capable of going behind his back and was not trustworthy. Also her tie up with ThakurSa, meeting him at the fair and choosing him over Rudra, does not show her in a positive light.

5. Circumstancial evidence...Paro was supposed to come to the wedding venue with Ranawat Sr., but turns up alone. When asked about his whereabouts, alludes to Chachi Sa. She does not have an answer. She was the last one to reach the venue, so logically must have been the last one to leave the house too. Last but not the least, she was the one on the run, the only one missing from the scenario.

Are the above evidences not enough for a trained and logical mind to suspect Paro??

Instincts about a woman who has always professed her hatred, her mistrust in him openly. Ok., so she was innocent and guileless and a child...or was she?? It could have all been an act looking at what actually transpired at the fair!!

And the most important, seeing his father at his death bed, Rudra or any other human, would be off kilter. It is the most emotional low a man can be at, and expecting reasonable reactions at such an unreasonable moment...isn't that a bit inhumane??

EDIT - Is Rudra dumb or wrong in suspecting Paro after all the in you face evidence?? And is there enough evidence pointing at Paro to make her a suspect??

P.S...give the man some time, and he might surprise us!!

Edited by eveline - 11 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

Sunara

@princessunara

Trailblazer

+ 8

Posted: 11 years ago

1. She saves his life from the bullet that flies his way. So apparently she kills his defenseless father as a time pass n saves his life!!

2. She kills Dilsher so that she is alone n doesn't have to go with him - n then COMES TO THE MELA and then Hits his head n escapes with Thakur! wow! couldn't she have rather straight away gone to the Thakur instead of coming to the mela?
I mean what a waste of time!
cz she has to kill Dilsher so she doesn't have to come with him, so the whole purpose of it is useless as she anyway goes to the mela~!

3. She does all this and comes back to the BSD instead of fleeing with the Thakur!! Logic kahan hai?

4. Paro has time and again hurt herself or promised to hurt herself when she is cornered, when she has no way else.. SHE HAS NEVER hurt Rudra or threatened to hurt him or any1 of his own when she is hurt or pushed.
She is a person who would hurt herself rather than someone else when she doesn't have any other choice
- burned her own hands instead of throwing the hot tea on him - which she could have done in an instance!
- she gave herself up to save her people - allowed him to hurt her instead of letting others suffer
- was planning to kill herself n NOT kill him to get out of marrying him

So I am not telling that in the heat of the moment he should have kept his head. He is entitled to be upset first.

He is a bloody officer - he has the full time till the press conference ends n he has to think all of these things.
Put aside trying to kill dilsher - his words 'YOU CALLED TEJAWAT TO THE MELA' now how does this make sense?
these r all part of Rudra's accusations..

in the beginning i wouldn't blame him for being upset - and even now i don't expect him to have any charity feelings n think 'paro cannot do that' stuff.

i just want him to put the negative and positive things together n come up with an intelligent option. Not a stupid one!
He is a major in BSD - a senior officer and he is a trained officer who should think of the whole picture!

Edited by princessunara - 11 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Varisha sheikh

@vari3241

Voyager

Posted: 11 years ago

Ya everything goes against paro.

Quote

subiaman

@subiaman

Voyager

Posted: 11 years ago

👏

You have to remember Rudra's words "bewakoof banaya" or something like that... he has every reason to believe that she was acting nice to escape...

Not that I like the scenario... Paro is right here and is innocent! Rudra is on the side of wrong. But he has his own reasons just like paro had hers earlier... But alas... people who were defending paro is busy writing essays on how rudra is wrong... hypocritical?????

Quote

ujwala444

@ujwala444

Navigator

Posted: 11 years ago

Ya but remember .. when Rudra asked where is Ranawat at weddinv Paro looked at Kaki and was saying something which kaki quickly covered saying he said he will come soo as he is still taki g time

Edited by ujwala444 - 11 years ago

Quote

Shree....

@Shreeswathy

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

Eveline, 1 more point is there..

She even burnt her hands to escape from him...

That shows, she was ready to go to any extend to escape from him...

Quote

jayashreesbs

@jayashreesbs

Beginner

Posted: 11 years ago

As I have mentioned in your post "What makes us strong, makes us vulnerable... " also please watch the scene Rudra leaving from hospital and his self talk. He says "Ye Aag haveli mein lagi kaise hai? Kaun hai is k peechay?"
what does it mean

Quote

mona

@automaticstart

Voyager

Posted: 11 years ago

ya u r right but about the surprise i really dont have any high hopes

Quote

Exprimere

@Exprimere

Voyager

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

Yes. All your concerns are legit. But:

1. Maithili saw the fake wedding outfit. Why didn't that ring a bell? If Rudra and Paro are supposedly in love, Mailthili didn't quite inquire after Sunehri's statement.

2. If Paro was responsible, why did she come back? Is she deluded that Rudra would let her go unscathed if she DID try to kill Dilsher?

3. Who was the first to hint out Paro? Mohini. In a nanosecond. Does that make sense? How can she be so certain it was Paro? Even she's supposed to put up a facade that Rudra and Paro are in love. Some level of disbelief must be shown. And Mohini was the first person R looked at for explanation, anyway.

4. Rudra seemed skeptic with the monologue- who's behind the fire?

5. Mohini left before Paro. According to her, Dilsher said he would take some more time AFTER Paro arrived, and that she's sent the car back to pick him. She's not supposed to know, is she?

6. Paro didn't believe Rudra because her first (second, actually) encounter with him was when he killed Varun. She should be terrified of him. Rudra, however, has known her these few weeks. He's seen her stand up against Mohini. He also knows she has self-harm tendencies when desperate. Case in point- mehndi.

The thing is, your arguments require logic, and so do mine. But I don't think the CVs have that level of reasoning.

I agree with you on one point. He may initially blame Paro because his dad is involved. But eventually he should see sense. I can leave that much space- benefit of doubt. Otherwise, it's character inconsistency. For a man of power, emotions need to be in check. His job was under threat because of the thoughtlessness.

Edited by Exprimere - 11 years ago

Quote

eveline

@eveline

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

#10

Originally posted by: ujwala444
Ya but remember .. when Rudra asked where is Ranawat at weddinv Paro looked at Kaki and was saying something which kaki quickly covered saying he said he will come soo as he is still taki g time

I have covered that point too...Paro did not have a definite answer...Kakisa stepped in. It does look suspicious for Paro though.