StarBharat Panchali's Patiyogita (p.142: Yuddhi 10+ Ahead)

Page

119

Next Last

AnjanaYYZ

@AnjanaYYZ

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 11 years ago

There has been much debate on this forum about who is Panchali's Pati No. 1. Who of the Pandavas loved her the most. This post will not answer that question for you. Draupadi does not appear to have kept tally...alternately, Rishi Veda Vyas had more important details to note then who got what flowers for Mahabharat's Yagaseni. So while many may acclaim Bheem to be Pati No. 1 without a full record and analysis of the Pandavas marriage to Panchali we cannot really assess who was truly PANCHALI'S PATI NO.1. But, friends let us not lose heart. While we cannot judge history, which remains a mystery, we can TRACK THE PRESENT and have our own

PANCHALI'S PATI NO. 1 PRATIYOGITA:

- How: We will keep a running tally of the care, concern, connection each of the Pandava Princes express for their Patni Panchali in StarBharat.

- Grading System: We will try to score the candidates objectively. For further details please see post 2.

-YOUR INPUT: We welcome your post episode input daily on which princes should be awarded points and why.

- Daily Score: The score for the most recent episode will be updated in the 3rd post on this page along with rationales.

- Archive: This post on the 2nd page will have the archival data on the past gradings. So, if there are later disputes on gradation we can return to the rationales.

-Progress Graph: Spatel will chart the progress of the princes in post 5 and post updates on an weekly basis at the end of the week.

- PATI of the Week: Poojie assess this weekly on Sundays. Please check final post on this page for details. WINNER OF THE WEEK no. 4 IS...on P.101

State of Competition Now:

Pandava Princes	Total to Date	Daily Score	Updated Total
1. Yuddhi	53.16	8.7	61.86
2. Bheem	30.16	1.2	31.36
3. Arjun	47.41	2.2	49.61
4. Nakul	7.35	0.2	7.55
5. Sahadev	10.85	0.7	11.55

Scores for first week: Y=10.96, B=9.46, A=11.96, N=2.80, S=2.80

Scores for 2nd week: Y=25.72, B=17.72, A=15.72, N=5.90, S=5.40

Scores for 3rd week:: Y=29.42, B=18.42, A=19.42, N=7.10, S=9.60

Scores for 4th week: Y=45.92, B=26.92, A=33.42, N=7.10, S=10.60

Scores for 5th week: Y=52.16, B=30.16, A=47.41, N=7.35, S=10.85

PANCHALI with the PATI PRATIYOGIS:
Embedded image permalink

*This is a fun post - hopefully your sentiments are strong enough survive some lighthearted humor

**We welcome Scoring Controversies - so, if you want to argue why your favorite prince should get more points or another less then please press your case. Unlike King Dhrit we promise to hear first judge later😉

Edited by AnjanaYYZ - 11 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

AnjanaYYZ

@AnjanaYYZ

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 11 years ago

Grading System

Positive Pati Points
1. Care n Concern: if a prince expresses care or concern for Panchali he will earn a point. This includes things like asking her opinion, holding her hand on rough geographic terrain, helping her down from chariots, etc. The expression need not be verbal - looks of concern will be valued.

2. Communication n Connectivity: Princes will also be awarded a point for maintaining communication with Princess Panchali - be it verbal or non-verbal (i.e. eye locks, nods, etc.).

3. Honour: Each prince will earn a point for defending their Panchali's honour either verbally or in deed (i.e. killing/punishing those who have insulted her).

4. Gifting: Princes will earn points for gifts.

5. Make Up: Princes will be also be awarded point for efforts they make to sooth Panchali's hurt feelings when she is upset or mad.

6. Mark Sharing: If an act is shared by more than one prince then the point - i.e. giving Draupadi adhikaar to go to Bhisma or gathering firewood then the marks will be split by the princes involved.

Negative Marks
Princes will lose a Pati Point for any of the following acts:

Staking the Princess
Not objecting to her being staked
Marrying another Princess post marriage to Panchali*
Bringing home another Princess post marriage
Romantic moments with other Princesses
Violating vows to her

*Please note - negative points will be awarded for other wives only if they are specifically shown or mentioned in StarBharat.

Edited by AnjanaYYZ - 11 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

AnjanaYYZ

@AnjanaYYZ

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 11 years ago

Today's Tally

Grading Analysis - March 24/2014

0.2: All Patis share a point for their angry looks when Shishu insults Panchali
+1 : Yuddhi for saying Shishupal insulted Draupadi, his punishment is deserving.
+1: Yuddhi looks towards his right where Panchali is when Pandava-Kurus faceoff. Since rest of the pandavas and Krishna are in the centre;
+1: Bheem for reminding everyone that Arjun too was punished for righteously protecting Panchali's honour.
0.5: Yuddhi & Sahadev both turns towards her when Draupadi calls out "Samrat"
+1: Yuddhi nods at her to speak
+1: Yuddhi agrees with D's statement about no point in hurting Dhrit & Gandhari
0.5: Yuddhi and Arjun contemplate her "shatraharan" suggestion
0.5: Yuddhi and Arjun each react to her suggestion by looking at Kaurav
+1: Yuddhi is not happy when Dury calls her "Drupad Kanya"
+1: Yuddhi understands that Draupadi was only suggesting solution to resolve family problem.
+1: Arjun looks angry when Dury questions her character
+1: Yuddhi implements D's suggestion and orders Dury & Co to surrender shashtra inside IP

Total Tally

Yudi = 8.7

Bheem =1.2

Arjun = 2.2

Nakul = 0.2

Sahadev = 0.7

Edited by AnjanaYYZ - 11 years ago

Quote

guenhwyvar

@guenhwyvar

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

~"Patiyogita" Graphs~

Dharma-Ke-Pratik: Yuddhistira

=====================================================

Vrikodhara: Bhimasen

=================================================

Gandeeva Dhari: Arjunnaaa

======================================================

The Handsome and Dashing: Nakula

========================================================

Phoorvabhasing Pati: Sahadeva

======================================================

Sabhi Pratiyogitas Overall (updated/replaced weekly)

*Nakul and Sahadev have scored the same point, hence why Nakul's curve doesn't "show"

Every new week, the old week's graphs will be replaced with the new weeks. If you want to get more info about previous weeks, please visit: http://shyam09.imgur.com/

Edited by shyam09 - 11 years ago

Quote

AnjanaYYZ

@AnjanaYYZ

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: spatel23
Couple of questions before I begin analyzing the shows 😆
a) Is there a chance for Patis to get more points in each category if they do it multiple times but in different scenes within the same episode or is it only one point per category per day?
A: Its per act. So if there are 2 eye contacts by a pati then he gets 2 points.

b) shall we set up a system to not over clog the thread where each user who wants to participate just "edits" his/her first post to add another date and rating? Or should we just post normally (like in other threads)?
A: Just post normally as in other threads. But I will make note of which page we are on for day's rating discussions in the title. I will also update the final daily scores after all discussion

I think i'm going to keep track of this too (based on Anjana's post) on a google docs spreadsheet and then at the end of the week, I could post a graph on Sundays to see how each prince is doing. We can get mathematically while talking about patis and patnis!
A: Perfect - if you are comfortable I can upload the graph in the spare post I have reserved 😊

Quote

guenhwyvar

@guenhwyvar

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

No problem, that would be awesome 😊

If anyone wants to help out with inputting data (in case I don't get the time) or to see how the trends are going so far

Link to Google Drive Spreadsheet Page!

I've separated it into 6 spreadsheets (all 5 Patis together, and then one for each pati)

UPDATE: Made it a working link 😃

Edited by spatel23 - 11 years ago

Quote

Pooja Menon

@pooja-menon

Trailblazer

+ 7

Posted: 11 years ago

~~~~~PATI OF THE WEEK~~~~~

~~~~CALCULATIONS FOR THE PATI OF THE WEEK~~~~

PATI OF THE WEEK = HIGHEST POINTS + BEST GROWTH OVER THE WEEK + STANDOUT PERFORMANCE

Weightage: 45% (Highest points) + 45% (Best Growth) + 10% (Standout Performance)

For calculating Highest points, we will multiply each candidate's points by 0.45 (45%). From week 3 onwards, we would only be factoring the weekly performance and not the total till date. So highest points = This week's score - last week's score.

For calculating Best Growth, we will be ranking them, for. eg. if Nakul grew the most he gets 5, Sahadev next so he gets 4..etc. We will then multiply the rank number by 0.45 (45%). To calculate the best growth, we will be using this equation =( (This week's total - Last week's total)/ Last week's total)

For calculating standout performance, the one chosen candidate will be earn fixed 10 points which when multiplied by 0.1 (10%) will get him an extra 1 point.

Adding these three figures will get us the grand total and the one with the highest figure is the winner. 😊

Example: Credit goes to Anjana

Hypothetical situation

Scores for the week: Arjun 10 pts, Nakul 8, Bheem 6

Standout performance: Bheem gets 10 pts

Growth = if Nakul grew most he is given 5, Arjun 2, Bheem 1

Arjuna = 10(.45) + 2 X.45 + 0 (0.10) = 5.4

Nakul= 8 (.45) + 5 X 0.45 +0 (0.10) = 5.85

Bheem= 6 (.45)+ 1 X 0.45 + 10(0.10) = 4.15

So, winner is Nakul!

~~WINNER~~

Week 1 - PATI OF THE WEEK - PRINCE ARJUN (Pg 13)

Week 2 - PATI OF THE WEEK - CROWN PRINCE YUDHISTHIR (Pg 41)

Week 3 - PATI OF THE WEEK - PRINCE SAHADEV(Pg 61)

Week 4 - PATI OF THE WEEK - KING YUDHISTHIR (Pg 101)

Week 5 - PATI OF THE WEEK - PRINCE ARJUN (Pg 132)

Scores for the week:

Yudi - (53.16 - 45.92) = 7.24

Bheem - (30.16 - 26.92) = 3.24

Arjun - (47.41 - 33.42) = 13.99

Nakul - (7.35 - 7.10) = 0.25

Sahadev - (10.85 - 10.60) = 0.25

Growth:

Yudi - ((53.16 - 45.92)/45.92) = 0.16

Bheem - ((30.16 - 26.92)/26.92) = 0.12

Arjun - ((47.41 - 33.42)/33.42) = 0.42

Nakul - ((7.35 - 7.10)/7.10) = 0.04

Sahadev - ((10.85 - 10.60)/10.60) = 0.02

Ranking: Arjun - 5, Yudi - 4, Bheem - 3, Nakul - 2, Sahadev - 1

Standout Performance: Arjun earns 10 points for his intense eyelock with Draupadi when she welcomes him with Subhadra.

[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NUi3ZKnr16o[/YOUTUBE]

Yudi = 7.24(0.45) + 4(0.45) + 0(0.1) = 5.06

Bheem = 3.24(0.45) + 3(0.45) + 0(0.1) = 2.81

Arjun = 13.99(0.45) + 5(0.45) + 10(0.1) = 9.55

Nakul = 0.25(0.45) + 2(0.45) + 0(0.1) = 1.01

Sahadev = 0.25(0.45) + 1(0.45) + 0(0.1) = 0.56

Hence Arjun is the winner!! 😊

Credit for the trophy: Shyam09

Credit for the gif: chippedcupofchai/Tumblr

Credit for the banner: Abhishek_King

Edited by ....Poojie.... - 11 years ago

Quote

Nripendra

@Abhisheking

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

Awesum post,Anjana di!!!🤣

But one thing I couldn't understand is that why the daily scores r different for each pratiyogi???😕

Quote

Pooja Menon

@pooja-menon

Trailblazer

+ 7

Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: Abhishek_King
Awesum post,Anjana di!!!🤣
But one thing I couldn't understand is that why the daily scores r different for each pratiyogi???😕

Coz some pratiyogis did better than others 😊 ..Daily score corresponds to the most recent episode..

Edited by ....Poojie.... - 11 years ago