Who is no.1 of these no.2’s !

AMIT SANA : Indian Idol 1's 1st Runner up

Playback success in films : Kalyug , Delhi Heights ,Jaan-E-Mann ,and others...

Albums : Chal Diye ( Solo debut ) & Sun Zara ( With Elite singer Shreya Ghosal )

N C Karunya : Indian Idol 2's 1st Runner up

Playback success in films : Lage Raho Munnabhai , Jai Santoshi Maa ( 2006 ) , Bunch of Telugu films !

Albums : Yet to come !

Vinit Singh : SRGMP Challenge 2005's 1st Runner up

Playback success in films : Rocky the rebel & others under Himesh Reshamiya's direction !

Albums : Yet to come !

------------------------------------------------------------ --

Please do specify your reason for choice !

My vote goes to Amit Sana

For the way he made it to top2 inspite of ordinary looks !

A Great example of the power of natural talent !

Karunya & Amit Sana !! 😃

they both r talented & versatile !! 😃 😃 😃

Ohh that is a hard choice. I don't know Vinnet that well leaving Karunya and Amit..but if I had to choose one it would have to be karunya but both are fab! 😃

Ohhhh , this is a hard choice. In Idol I my fav was Amit Sana and in II I loved Karunya's singing...

both are very very talented but if I really have to pick one while taking into account of everything...singing, performance, stage presence , over all persona, then I'll go with Amit Sana 😃 👏 ....

Originally posted by: bruno4

Ohhhh , this is a hard choice. In Idol I my fav was Amit Sana and in II I loved Karunya's singing...

both are very very talented but if I really have to pick one while taking into account of everything...singing, performance, stage presence , over all persona, then I'll go with Amit Sana 😃 👏 ....

everything koeli said....both were really good...but if i HAVE to...den amit sana 😊

I don't know who was closest to win based on number of votes. 😕

But no. 1 from the three contestants is Karunya. 👏

Originally posted by: Vijey Umang

Please do specify your reason for choice !

My vote goes to Amit Sana

For the way he made it to top2 inspite of ordinary looks !

A Great example of the power of natural talent !

Mine too.....but closesly followed by karunya and then after a bit comes vinit.(He's reeli good too though but the other 2 are better)!!!

Infact i think he was even good enough to be no.1 but even abhijeet and rahul and prajakta and aditi deserved that so!!!!!lol

Actually i think amit dada is quite handsome!!! 😉

awwwwwwwwww Amit my most fav in indian idol 1. 👏 👏 👏 i jus never get bored watching his awesome perforamnces & he was da most interesting contest in idol - 1.. 😃 frm idol 2 karu reminded me Amit 😛 .. soo its hard choice for me to pick one.. soo dis time i'll give my vote for amit nd next time wen i refresh this thread i'll leave my vote for karu as he is a superb singer nd my most fav along wit Antara nd Amey. 👏 👏 👏

its really very hard for me 2 choose 1 between karu and vinit, bcoz kau was my 2nd fav among boys in ii3, and as many people know i am a die-heart supporter of vinit, so i cant choose, so i cant vote 😳

hmmm hard 2 cose both amit and karunya wre gr8