How can Bani be termed 'Mentally ill'?

soni595 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago
#1

Call me stupid, for asking this question, as we all know BT / any other soap production displays 3/4 illogically portrayed stories..but STILL..

- First of all, how can Jai Walia testify against/for his wife...Correct me if I'm wrong,but I thought spouses were discouraged from testifying for/against their spouses in court? Or am I just talking the American legal system here? Am not really sure of India's legal system that's why..

- Secondly, how can just a "Witnesses' testimony" prove someone mentally ill? Since when did people with no background in psychology certify that a person is bad based on a few day's worth of experience, with no real trauma to back it up? Or are they trying to tell us, since Bani killed Saahil, she turned mentally ill, and hence these weird behaviors?😕

(I'm fed up of BT, for making every character mentally ill to be dangerously malicious/evil or obsessive..I mean like what they did to Tarun..first of all how does Tarun's behavior define OCD in any way? OCD may lessen with treatment and medications and all, but how does it stop? What are Tarun's compulsions and obsessions exactly? Married women are his obsessions and compulsions?)

- How can a qualified, intelligent judge issue a person to be sent to a mental assylum for FIVE years, without a psychiatrist's report? Um seriously, that's the most illogical thing I've ever heard..Five years are a long, long time, how can you submit someone to medications and treatment of a mental assylum without certified authority of them being admitted there?

- How is it proven Saahil has been ruthlessly murdered by Bani? Hello, the lawyer did not have the decency to provide solid reasons...Saahil I believe was murdered/if dead to have died of poison consumption right? Where is the poison bottle? Does the bottle have Bani's fingerprints on?

- Where is Bani's lawyer? Fine, JW was helpless (Although I fail to believe that) Couldn't Rano, Ranveer, Aditya hire a lawyer for Bani? Or am I terribly mistaken and Bani did have a lawyer, he just did not appear physically to defend Bani's case?

- Even when Bani was admitted in the mental assylum, no psychiatrist appeared to even check her up? How can a pregnant women be putten in the same room as people who are mentally ill (no saying they will definitely harm her, but ther mental state of mind, may turn violent depending on the disorder they have) Yes, the woman is supposedely guilty, but the unborn children shouldn't have to suffer for that..

- Was that a police station/something else? A supposed criminal runs right under their noses, and they take minutes before they realize this, so much that a woman carrying two newborns and who is weak can beat all of them till outside??😕

Keep smiling...

Love

Soni

Created

Last reply

Replies

5

Views

725

Users

4

Frequent Posters

salmansgirl thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#2
hun, you're stressing yourself out by thinking about all this. We're talking about an Ekta serial here.... 😆

Anam
soni595 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: salmansgirl

hun, you're stressing yourself out by thinking about all this. We're talking about an Ekta serial here.... 😆

Anam

I know unfortunately it's a BT production, and sadly other serials too seem to follow the same route...but I can''t help it, every time I see things like that...anything related to psychology or mentally ill people, I begin to stress my nerves😆

Keep smiling...

Love

Soni

555W59 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#4
Soni,

This is the production house that feels high sugar people besan ka ladoos, guzzele alcohol (india has one of the highest incidence of diabetes)

A cancer patient insteadd of getting treatment is busy forcing husband to commit bigamy

a man drugged and drunk is assumed to have impregnated someone

a woman is 20 months pergnant

a woman gives birth when she is 3 months pregnant and has a healthy child

all properties worth millions are turned over with one signature....i cannot get a drivers liecense with one signature

I mean nothing makes sense in this serial
soni595 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: m3ghna

Soni,

This is the production house that feels high sugar people besan ka ladoos, guzzele alcohol (india has one of the highest incidence of diabetes)

bloopers..bloopers/ignorance..ignorance

A cancer patient insteadd of getting treatment is busy forcing husband to commit bigamy

I know, no sign of Raashi ever looking like a cancer patient..seemed more like she was taking asprin than under going chemo therapy...not even a single hair of hers fell off (or maybe she was wearing a wig and we weren't told lol) Chemo therapy is a serious thing, yet no signs of weaknesses..instead she is busy excited on her husband's wedding lol...felt sorry for Ranveer..

a man drugged and drunk is assumed to have impregnated someone

That was the sickest thing till date...Urrgh every time I think of the ONS..it makes my blood boil...😡

a woman is 20 months pergnant

Yea, Pia was pregnant way before Bani, and yet Bani gives birth tooo soon, that too to twins..

a woman gives birth when she is 3 months pregnant and has a healthy child

all properties worth millions are turned over with one signature....i cannot get a drivers liecense with one signature

A successful businessman, who built an entire empire on his own, just does this...Thankfully Ranveer has changed, but still the three Macbeth witches are still hovering near him.. Hopefully he won't and am guessing he won't be foolish enough to sign anything as of now without reading its contents..

I mean nothing makes sense in this serial

I know, there's just so much ignorance/should I say bloopers in this serial, I would've included all the bloopers, but then a whole page would've fallen short na?😆 so just the recent ones...

snmirza thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#6
well that's ekta for u... with all the not making sense stuff...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".