Logic hunters nightmare!

Go4welkin thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#1
Splendid action and fast paced story telling alone don't determine the quality of entertainment, there is one more essential ingredient called logic, which I felt slipped through the cracks in today's episode.
No doubt the episode was full of interesting scenes such as intense Haider-Gaffy face off, Gaffy shocker to Razia and Zoya-Razia encounter but in the maze of power packed performances, logic seems to have taken a back seat.

Shaky logic:

1. Razia picked up the note that Rashid scribbled for Zoya, Razia being smart should have figured out that it was written by Rashid (all others can talk except him) and Zoya didn't get the note, otherwise, she would have not left such an important note flying around in SM. Razia's focus should be to destroy the evidence before Zoya come to know about it instead of planning Zoya's murder.

2. If Gaffy's only reason to agree for Zoya's murder is to save Humaira then why can't he kill Haider instead.

3. Even if Razia believes that Zoya know about the recording, how will the killing of Zoya alone keep their secret safe? if Zoya know about the recording, she will for sure share it with Asad right? if yes, killing Zoya alone won't solve the issue ...does it?

Except for logic rest seems to be in good shape.

Created

Last reply

Replies

17

Views

1.7k

Users

7

Likes

18

Frequent Posters

latanzia thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
Perfectly said I think you forget Haider spilling his guts to Gaffy, what is the point , the element of surprise is gone.
At present Both Haider and Zoya are a threath to them so why kill Ziya it makes no sense, then again when it comes to Qubool hai, logic and common sense always goes missing.
They are in such a hurry with this track, that it is not making any sense, too many loop holes, and unanswered Question.
Go4welkin thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: latanzia

Perfectly said I think you forget Haider spilling his guts to Gaffy, what is the point , the element of surprise is gone.

At present Both Haider and Zoya are a threath to them so why kill Ziya it makes no sense, then again when it comes to Qubool hai, logic and common sense always goes missing.
They are in such a hurry with this track, that it is not making any sense, too many loop holes, and unanswered Question.


I left it out as benefit of doubt that Haider is over confident that Humaira is irreversibly in love with him. It's nice to see a fast paced story telling but they can't lose track of logic in the process ...I mean we can ignore small details but a big decision such as murdering someone should be driven by some sensible reasoning.
rajnid68 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
Neend bhi haraam kar diya inn sawaalon nay..
TOI ka riddle ko straight competition tha ...
Solve cvs ko hi kar na padayga...
May tho..
Goli mar bhejay ko...
Yeh riddle neend haraam kar raha hai...😃
Go4welkin thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: rajnid68

Neend bhi haraam kar diya inn sawaalon nay..

TOI ka riddle ko straight competition tha ...
Solve cvs ko hi kar na padayga...
May tho..
Goli mar bhejay ko...
Yeh riddle neend haraam kar raha hai...😃


Goli mar bhejay ko is apt for the situation of characters in QH and the viewers situation in understanding CVs logic. 😆
lowet thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#6
rasiya is just worried that if her husband gets to know that Zoya is his daughter then he would leave her and zoya might not say anything to him because he is her father she wanted to be with for a long time. then Rasiya would be alone. her biggest threat is zoya and truth about her. She is unsecured and jealous as nobody would tolerate their husband illegitimate child though zoya is not but for rasiya she is. She does not want her husband to leave her and her daughter for zoya and that's why she killed her mother in first place. she is blind by jealousy and anger and also things do not happen logically in real life nor does people react always as they were supposed too.
Go4welkin thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: lowet

rasiya is just worried that if her husband gets to know that Zoya is his daughter then he would leave her and zoya might not say anything to him because he is her father she wanted to be with for a long time. then Rasiya would be alone. her biggest threat is zoya and truth about her. She is unsecured and jealous as nobody would tolerate their husband illegitimate child though zoya is not but for rasiya she is. She does not want her husband to leave her and her daughter for zoya and that's why she killed her mother in first place. she is blind by jealousy and anger and also things do not happen logically in real life nor does people react always as they were supposed too.



A very sensible explanation of Razia's POV but I still don't get Gaffy's logic in giving in to Razia's ideas. He was not afraid of jail like Razia and he changed his mind to kill Zoya only after his encounter with Haider and in no way killing Zoya will help saving Humaira from Haider.
Edited by Go4welkin - 11 years ago
rajnid68 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: Go4welkin


A very sensible explanation of Razia's POV but I still don't get Gaffy's logic in giving in to Razia's ideas.

Are we beating around the bush...
lag tho yahi raha hai...!!??!!??
Go4welkin thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: rajnid68

Are we beating around the bush...
lag tho yahi raha hai...!!??!!??


People some times don't react logically to the real life situations but murdering someone is a big deal and a person like Gaffy, who want to redeem himself for his past mistakes now agreeing to murder Zoya for not so compelling reasons is morbid, while I am convinced with lowet's explanation of Razia POV, Gaffy's POV is iffy and so the repetition of the lack of logic rant. Bejhey ko goli marna ithna bhi aasan nahin hai! 😆
Edited by Go4welkin - 11 years ago
Niharika17 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: Go4welkin

Splendid action and fast paced story telling alone don't determine the quality of entertainment, there is one more essential ingredient called logic, which I felt slipped through the cracks in today's episode.

No doubt the episode was full of interesting scenes such as intense Haider-Gaffy face off, Gaffy shocker to Razia and Zoya-Razia encounter but in the maze of power packed performances, logic seems to have taken a back seat.

Shaky logic:

1. Razia picked up the note that Rashid scribbled for Zoya, Razia being smart should have figured out that it was written by Rashid (all others can talk except him) and Zoya didn't get the note, otherwise, she would have not left such an important note flying around in SM. Razia's focus should be to destroy the evidence before Zoya come to know about it instead of planning Zoya's murder.

2. If Gaffy's only reason to agree for Zoya's murder is to save Humaira then why can't he kill Haider instead.

3. Even if Razia believes that Zoya know about the recording, how will the killing of Zoya alone keep their secret safe? if Zoya know about the recording, she will for sure share it with Asad right? if yes, killing Zoya alone won't solve the issue ...does it?

Except for logic rest seems to be in good shape.

Word.I have been wodnering for the point 1 & 3 myself..i am still waiting some other thing to happen so that killing Zoya looks like the best way out for Gaziya

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".