Episode Discussion Thread # 1 - Page 11

Originally posted by: Julie0001

@ infofan

It feels like a masala cooking show. CVs I think are testing out different ingredients. We have teasers for sexy sherda dance, a slap on rani, jail time for sher...

I wish they would stay true to the different characters. Sher is in a dirty family business but honest about his feelings and can see his mother for who she is. He loves Shraddha in a pure way but is who he is.

Shraddha needs to remain strong and not people pleasing. Please no puppy-bahu running after everyone trying to feed them. Let her remain strong. She had complicated feelings for Sher. Let's watch her wrestle with them.

Are the CVs listening?

Tried and tested formula... if the viewers are complaining a lot about content, creative work, acting etc then throw in a passionate embrace or a sizzling dance. All grievances shall be forgotten and forgiven 😆

It is the jodi that brings in viewers ultimately and once they get popular, I have seen in other shows, CVs capitalize on them and dont pay much attention to content.

Today again he said his and BD's death will make her happy. Is he trying to convince himself by repeating it or does he really believe she wants them dead so she can be free?

Originally posted by: Infofan

Today again he said his and BD's death will make her happy. Is he trying to convince himself by repeating it or does he really believe she wants them dead so she can be free?

@peaches

The hug was nice. It was slow and long and unexpected. Sher's expressions were nice and mixed. He looked horrified and remorseful. I liked how unapologetic Sher was. That was the Sher we were introduced to. Yes, it is complicated but he is okay with that.

I was not crazy about the killing of an innocent man. I understand that violence is part of the show, but it should have meaning and consequence. Earlier when Sher mercilessly beat Sameer to punish Shraddha, I would have liked her to be repelled by him and still attracted to him. But they just glossed over it. Here as you say they should use this as a way of bringing Sher's reality to Shraddha. This is the dark world she is a part of.

I wish the story would develop slowly. The moral dilemma for Shraddha is that she is attracted to a man who comes from a dark background. She should be wrestling with the morality of what Sher has done: let an innocent man die.


Above Infofan said that they just throw in the hug to pacify the audience. This seems true.

CVs seem to be selective in the feedback they read and consider. They seem to have toned down Rani's makeup. She looks decent now with lighter lipstick.

But... but they are continuing the ridiculous Rani track despite knowing its not going down well with us.

I think most folks on the forum here find it hard to watch Rani. Her track was completely unnecessary. Who is this woman who walks around BD's house like she owns it ordering Shraddha to serve them food, challenging a married woman that her husband would be in her (Rani's) bed in a few days and makes out with him public while he doesnt do much to push her away or stop her?

What is all that nonsense yaar?

@ Peaches - the killing was unnecessary. Sher, the one who thinks himself to be so smart and brave did nothing to stop Rani from killing their partner was shocking.

Sher is in part responsible for the killing but I doubt Shraddha would blame him. She is too bhartiya naari types. Instead she would feel immensely guilty that she didnt do anything when that man was begging her to help.

The hug was nice. The guilt was on Sher's face was a case of too little too late. The man lost his life due to Sher's brilliant plan. But he did want to use Rani to eliminate all his mom's enemies so then why did he feel guilty??

BD is behind all this. She told that man to admit to stealing the liquor and it didnt seem to matter to her if Rani killed him as long as her son was safe.

Originally posted by: peachesandcream

Today what Sher said about Shraddha wanting him to be killed seemed more his bitterness. It felt as if he was stressing on her being caught in an unhappy situation from which she should be free. It didn't sound as if he believed it. Cv's need to clear up this issue because it is important to the characterization and the story.

There was an overdose of Torture Rani again. I have a lot of difficulty watching her. The killing was awful. I was surprised that Sher did not make an attempt to intervene. He had given himself up to Pandey earlier to ensure the safety of Shaurya's friend, so I would have expected him to at least try to talk Rani out of the killing.

Shraddha knows that the guy killed was innocent. I wonder if this changes her opinion of Sher since he allowed him to be killed.

I hope the story move past this Rani character soon. Judging from the precap I am wondering if somehow BD is behind this as well.

@ blue - Yup he is embittered due to her initial rejection, fed by BD's lies, his massive ego is still hurting about Shraddha trusting Virat. The CVs are using 'serial logic' of Shraddha not being able to clarify her thoughts to continue this MU and keep the leads separate.

But it is annoying that Shraddha doesnt even try to clarify her POV. Well even if she did, our hero wont believe her. Serial logic 😆

Originally posted by: Julie0001

@peaches

The hug was nice. It was slow and long and unexpected. Sher's expressions were nice and mixed. He looked horrified and remorseful. I liked how unapologetic Sher was. That was the Sher we were introduced to. Yes, it is complicated but he is okay with that.

I was not crazy about the killing of an innocent man. I understand that violence is part of the show, but it should have meaning and consequence. Earlier when Sher mercilessly beat Sameer to punish Shraddha, I would have liked her to be repelled by him and still attracted to him. But they just glossed over it. Here as you say they should use this as a way of bringing Sher's reality to Shraddha. This is the dark world she is a part of.

I wish the story would develop slowly. The moral dilemma for Shraddha is that she is attracted to a man who comes from a dark background. She should be wrestling with the morality of what Sher has done: let an innocent man die.


Above Infofan said that they just throw in the hug to pacify the audience. This seems true.

@ bold - Jules - I didnt mean this specific hug. It was a general statement about the trend I have observed over the years in many, many shows. Although this hug could have also been a carrot dangling, pacifying tactic.

Is Shraddha attracted to Sher already? Why?


@ blue - Logically that is what Shraddha should be feeling and that is what I would love to see as well. It maybe such scenes are challenging to write, execute and portray hence are glossed over and rarely seen.

Though hug was icing over the cake...but i can't ignore the fact that Sher is chuha Singh...he din't say even a word...how the hell in his own house...other lady is ordering like owner...and as someone said..he is acting like a slave...*pukes*...

I am so sorry Babbar about your dog. That is rough. I hope you were diverted a bit here. I always like reading your posts.

Babbar Sher hope you're fine now...so sorry about ur dog