Abeer and Mehar : Reason for their Contrasting Stands

melody442 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
Off late we are seeing the transformed Abeer and falling for him more and more. Who would not fall for such a sanskaari damaad, cute charmer and incorrigible flirt? Why is it then that Mehar is still so cold and indifferent to his charms and persuasion? Why is she still holding the facade of indifference when Abeer is ready to rekindle the sparks of their realtionships? There is a very valid reason that. See I am thoroughly enjoying Abeers antics and his cute harkatein to gain care and attention from all. It is good to see that he is no more bitter, atleast for now. But scratch the surface and you will find that nothing has really changed. Point is Abeer was bitter and angry because he thought Mehar was a gold digger, chose money over him, is unaffected by the divorce and is living her life happily. It hurt him that he and their relationship mattered so little to her. Now ever since he started living with Mehar and her family his illusions started shattering one by one. He found that Mehar too was hurt by divorce, it wasnt as easy for her to collect herself and move forward as he thought. She is still somewhere blamed for following her heart even in her own home. And then the concern he showed for Abeer when he was captured by Pinky Bhai was the last straw. It showed him that she still cared. So from carrying this bitterness from last 8 year that the girl he loved didnt value him at all, he is suddenly enjoying and reveling in the fact that she does care and he does make a difference in her life. Its like a victory, a vindication of his love after all these years. And so he is doing everything he can to get more love, care and attention from Mehar, garner more evidence of the feelings she has betrayed, even extract a confession if possible, so what if it means playing on her sympathy and innate goodness. But the thing is it is still fun and games for Abeer. He hasnt really introspected about his feelings. His progression is like 1-2-1. Stage 1 was falling for the innocent, sweet, serious Mehar- The Good Mehar, and getting her to fall for him through whatever means, his cute antics, showering attention on her, being stubborn whatever. Stage 2 was hating Mehar - The Bad Mehar- The imaginary Mehar he created out of his anger and bitterness -- Manipulative, selfish, uncaring and gold - digger Mehar. But as I said moving in Mehar's home broke his illusion. He has forgot the bitterness, differences, break-up, alimony and is now back to Stage 1. Again falling for the Good Mehar- One who loves and cares about him beneath the mask of seriousness and indifference, and he is again trying to do all he can to get her to confess her feelings. But what he is not realizing is what happens after this stage. Even if Mehar confesses and gives in, what is the guarantee that the history would not repeat itself? But as I said he has conveniently forgotten the stage 2.

And this is exactly where Mehars approach towards this relationship is different from Abeers. Her progression in this relationship is 1-2-3. Stage 1 was falling for Abeers charms despite all her resistence and apprehensions, following her heart, giving in to her feelings. Stage 2 was the realization of their differences, their contrasting personalities, Abeers immaturity, their separation. What is important here is that Mehar never demonized Abeer like he did. Yes she called him immature, impulsive and the one who runs away from problems. Yes she may have exaggerated it a bit, but from what we have seen of Abeer this is not far from truth at all. She accepted the bitterness and reality of their separation, but her acceptance was based on real grounds, real assessment of their contrasting personalities and the real failings of their relationship. She never created an imaginary or overtly bad version of Abeer to console herself. She faced the cold facts and accepted the bitter truths of their relationship. And that is why instead of returning to Stage1, she has moved on to Stage 3, not falling for outer charms but realizing the real differences. She always knew that Abeer loved her, even while separating, so this renewed attention from Abeer is not exactly a breaking news for her. She knows that. The flirtation, the attention, the charm Abeer is displaying for Mehar, she has experienced it all before, gave in to it and saw the result too. So nope, she is not giving in this time. Not until Abeer faces the real issues that led to break down of their relationship first time around. Abeer wants to forget the past like a bad memory but Mehar realizes that it was the harsh reality. Mehar is wiser from the relationship and knows that
they separated despite the love, because sometimes only love is not enough to sustain the relationship; you also need trust, maturity & understanding. Abeer is yet to learn this fact and tackle the real issues that led to their separation.
Edited by -enchanted- - 10 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

22

Views

3.9k

Users

10

Likes

79

Frequent Posters

war_is_peace thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
brilliant post!! 👏 👏 👏

u explained it clear n crisp!
thank u ..i have a better idea about their current state of mind now!



but, i have a few doubts...incase u have an explanation i would love it 🤗

1) abeer had come back to her to beg and not sign the papers ...doesnt that mean he wanted to solve the issues that time itself? he didnt make an image of hers immediately...he did it coz she accepted the alimony money and rejected his proposal to solve issues and be back together.

2) where as, abeer never gave such a chance to meher that she would make an evil image of his but, she still did! it was she who wanted to come to groove and show abeer that she is powerful and could sign his pay cheque. so actually it was her who came back first and not abeer.

3) in all his hatred for meher he still fought for her at the mall and he regretted that they were all over the newspapers after the swimming pool scene and he was worried for her state next day in office. but, she disclosed everything in office to everyone and blamed him for the picture.
since the beginning abeer has always only wanted her back...the hatred was always a facade.
-the jacket lending
- the story telling (where he actually tells her when n how he fell for her..u know)
- punching office staff when they spoke ill abt meher
- goons
(so all this happened before he went to meher's house...he never hated her...always wanted her back...did everything to get her reaction)

4) as for meher, she hasnt yet spoken out about her reason. the day she speaks the misunderstanding will be cleared.


ps - m waiting for her reply to abeer today 'tumhe nahi lagta alag hona ek galti thi?'
her reply to this will make or break things ahead.


-love
Hiya

Edited by war_is_peace - 10 years ago
melody442 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: war_is_peace

brilliant post!! 👏 👏 👏


u explained it clear n crisp!
thank u ..i have a better idea about their current state of mind now!

Thank you so much for your kind words 😳


but, i have a few doubts...incase u have an explanation i would love it 🤗

1) abeer had come back to her to beg and not sign the papers ...doesnt that mean he wanted to solve the issues that time itself? he didnt make an image of hers immediately...he did it coz she accepted the alimony money and rejected his proposal to solve issues and be back together.

See one thing that defines Abeer is his child like heart and impulsiveness. He thinks with his heart and not his mind. Its not in his nature to analyze things or read between the lines. This child like innocence is a blessing as well as a curse. Abeer asked for forgiveness and Mehar refused to do so. They divorced and Mehar got the alimony. So Abeer concluded simply that Mehar chose money over him. He loved Mehar so much, knew him for a year and yet believed that she is a Gold - digger. Now tell me if their relationship had trust, would it have been possible? He would have tried to know the exact reason behind her accepting the money instead of doubting her intentions. Even now when Abeer is realizing that Maher still cares for her, what should have been his first question logically? That if she still loves me, why did she separate from me or chose money over me? He would have wanted those answers. But he does not want to face the tough questions. His heart sees that he still loves Mehar and Mehar loves him too and they should start afresh... See where the problem is? Even if they get together again now for sake of love, tomorrow again an ugly issue may arise which would shake their relationship and break them apart. This is why it is very necessary that first he finds and sorts out the reasons for their separation before dreaming of reunion. They need to develop that trust and understanding first. And Mehar also would have to open up regarding her feelings to get there.

2) where as, abeer never gave such a chance to meher that she would make an evil image of his but, she still did! it was she who wanted to come to groove and show abeer that she is powerful and could sign his pay cheque. so actually it was her who came back first and not abeer.

Mehar did want to sign Abeers pay cheque, but not to put him down. She wanted to prove to herself that she has moved on. Also the fact that she had to accept the money from Kuber hurt her pride somewhere. More than Abeer, perhaps she wanted to prove to Kuber that she is not helpless. So more than hurting Abeer, it was a pride thing for her.

3) in all his hatred for meher he still fought for her at the mall and he regretted that they were all over the newspapers after the swimming pool scene and he was worried for her state next day in office. but, she disclosed everything in office to everyone and blamed him for the picture.
since the beginning abeer has always only wanted her back...the hatred was always a facade.
-the jacket lending
- the story telling (where he actually tells her when n how he fell for her..u know)
- punching office staff when they spoke ill abt meher
- goons
(so all this happened before he went to meher's house...he never hated her...always wanted her back...did everything to get her reaction)

That Abeer loves Mehar is no secret. That is the reason he wasnt able to forget her supposed betrayal even after all these years. He loved her even in his anger, his bitterness, his accusations, his sarcasm... There has never been any doubt on his love. Mehar loves him too but keeps her emotions suppressed.

4) as for meher, she hasnt yet spoken out about her reason. the day she speaks the misunderstanding will be cleared.

We are all waiting for that day.



ps - m waiting for her reply to abeer today 'tumhe nahi lagta alag hona ek galti thi?'
her reply to this will make or break things ahead.

Her reply would be interesting indeed. Would she evade the question or pretend to be indifferent or actually reveal something that atleast provides a hint that why she thought it was right to separate...

-love
Hiya

Edited by -enchanted- - 10 years ago
-farzana thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#5

I love your analysis on the given scenario.

Since past few episodes we are seeing a change in Abeers behaviour while being around Meher & family. He's gradually realising that Meher is hurt and their separation has affected her & not just him.Though he hurts her he does try making it up to her. Back then Abeer did come back though it was last minute he still wanted to give their relationship another chance & sort things out, but guess it was too late on Meher's side. She accepted the harsh reality of life by then and decided to move on. She probably thought there's no point holding on to their marriage when things aren't going to change for good and it all will go back to square one in no time. Marriage requires more than just love - Meher understand this where as Abeer doesn't as much hence right now he wants to know her feelings regarding him are still there or not and wants a reaction from her to prove that she still loves him & that he still matters to her. Is it really that easy? Abeer should try finding out why Meher doesn't want to get back with him, though she still loves. What makes her step back instead of coming forward to solve things? How can she trust him again after what happened 8 years back? If only they communicated even in disagreement it would have been a different situation.

melody442 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#6
@ war_is_peace : Agree with most of your points. I am not at all complaining about Abeers child like innocence. That is one of the most endearing qualities about him and sets him apart. I am just saying that it can be a little disadvantageous in certain situations, doesnt mean that I want him to lose it. About Mehar taking the alimony or reasons behind hiding it, that is one of the biggest secrets, isnt it ? We have no option but to wait and watch for that one... About Mehar and Abeer developing trust and understanding required to move forward...I would still say its too early. Yes 8 years have passed since their separation, but all these years they have spent apart, carrying the resentments and bitterness arising out of their failed relationship. It has been only a month since Mehar rejoined the office ( approximate assumption) and perhaps a week or 10 days since Abeer moved in Mehars house. It is only now that their resentment has started to melt, though love was always there. The issue of alimony is still to be resolved. So I think MehBeer still need a lot of maturity, trust and understanding before moving forward, perhaps even more than the first time.
Edited by -enchanted- - 10 years ago
melody442 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: -Shiiya-

I love your analysis on the given scenario.

Since past few episodes we are seeing a change in Abeers behaviour while being around Meher & family. He's gradually realising that Meher is hurt and their separation has affected her & not just him.Though he hurts her he does try making it up to her. Back then Abeer did come back though it was last minute he still wanted to give their relationship another chance & sort things out, but guess it was too late on Meher's side. She accepted the harsh reality of life by then and decided to move on. She probably thought there's no point holding on to their marriage when things aren't going to change for good and it all will go back to square one in no time. Marriage requires more than just love - Meher understand this where as Abeer doesn't as much hence right now he wants to know her feelings regarding him are still there or not and wants a reaction from her to prove that she still loves him & that he still matters to her. Is it really that easy? Abeer should try finding out why Meher doesn't want to get back with him, though she still loves. What makes her step back instead of coming forward to solve things? How can she trust him again after what happened 8 years back? If only they communicated even in disagreement it would have been a different situation.



@Bold : This! This is the real issue. Agree completely with what you said.
coldy07 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#8
Hi!
It's so good to see a post like this. 😊 I love reading any analysis like this . 😃 So, Thank You!
You have brilliantly tried to introspect on their actions.
And it's true. While Abeer may act all cool and goofy, he doesn't consciously tell Meher, himself or us as to why he is doing all this. Yes, on one hand , he says he was there to protect Meher, but the next minute we just see him trying to prove a point, make Meher feel that she needs him.
But consciously, he doesn't say that he needs her. Of course, when there's a question of life and death, he becomes all serious and goes on to show his desperation. So yeah, even in the last scene, he puts the ball in Meher's court. He asks HER , if she still reconsiders their decision to separate. Even in the horror sequence, he stopped after telling Meher, that SHE needs him, point made.
As much as I want them to unite, I want Abeer to realize his feelings. Meher is very mature, and even if it hurts her from inside, she knows she cannot say it. I'm waiting to see how she responds to that question from Abeer.
Until a point comes when Abeer and she are on the same ground, things are not going to be that easy. There's definitely more than what meets the eye.
Samanalyse thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#9
Beautiful analysis! I just wrote down a lot of similar feelings on another post. Meher will absolutely not give in this time until Abeer addresses the basic fault lines that rocked their relationship the last time. And Abeer won't be able to do that unless his perceptions about why the divorce happened are questioned. That can only happen if Meher reveals just what the 2.5 crores was for and whatever it is she is hiding in those cardboard boxes.
malikakas thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#10
The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again, expecting a different outcome. That's what Meher understands and what Abeer does not.
As far as Meher is concerned Abeer hasn't changed one bit. The issue for her was never love, it was about the maturity to handle life. Although Abeer means well, he doesn't think about anyone else's point of view.

Until Abeer starts seeing things from Meher's perspective they are not going to get anywhere. Personally, it seems to me that when Abeer came back to ask her to get back together, he still wasn't taking Meher's mindset into account. I don't think she wanted a divorce but I think she was hurt enough that she didn't immediately capitulate to his demands which sparked his anger and the divorce. In the first episode the comment was made that he signed the divorce papers first.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".