Disappointing Treatment of the Rape Track

Laila2009 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#1
I am very disappointed in how the PR team is handling the rape track.
First and foremost, are the police in India that insensitive. Surely the female police officers would have done a better job at interviewing Mansi. I was mortified a the poor interview technique and the lack of empathy or concern for them.

Second, has no-one even bothered to address the issue that Mansi might be at risk of getting pregnant from the rape? Has no-one even bothered to get her checked out? How about a visit to a doctor?

Third - in the west we have victims assistant programs where individual's can get counseling. Is there nothing like this in the India with the NGOs?

Fourth, Ahana/Anitka is portrayed as a weak and passive woman. When Naren slapped her, I would have rather seen her say to him "Get out of my house." I am sorry, but his man has pushed her and then slapped her and she's acting as though this is perfectly acceptable? Why do women producers and writers continue to show that it is perfectly acceptable for men to slap their spouses or girlfriend's? How is this even manly or respectful. I don't care what the woman has done - it is completely disgusting.

Fifth, Will Ahana/Anitka, quit trying to get into the bosom of a family that does not want her? I mean the woman is getting insulted and so is her sister and she's continually trying to get their acceptance, protect them from the press and see Naren. Who cares about these people? They do not want or like her...she should focus her attentions on her sister. I'd tell my own family to take a hike if they defended someone like Runaq.

Sixth. If Runaq can blackmail and sexual harass his female staff into giving him sexual favors for protecting them, why cannot he not capable of rape? Someone who does all these file and disgusting acts is a perfect candidate.

Just a disgustingly bad and pathetic track. After all these years in the business and the money to hire good writers, Ekta Kapoor continues to remain an insult to women. I would have expected more from her but it goes to show that even with all the money in the world, you cannot buy taste and education.

Has someone who has worked with victims of abuse, I am beyond disgusted with this story line. Thus far NO show in India is even capable of effectively addressing a story line that involves a rape...disappointing, very disappointing.


Edited by Laila2009 - 11 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

13

Views

1.4k

Users

7

Likes

28

Frequent Posters

933624 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: Laila2009

I am very disappointed in how the PR team is handling the rape track.



lol.. whats there to be disappointed.. what else did u expect of this serial...
first of all they ruined the whole serial.. showed crappy storyline.
i never expect anything out of this show.. that is one good technique for not getting disappointed..
Edited by pari-kirloskar - 11 years ago
Laila2009 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: pari-kirloskar

lol.. whats there to be disappointed.. what else did u expect of this serial...
first of all they ruined the whole serial.. showed crappy storyline.
i never expect anything out of this show.. that is one good technique for not getting disappointed..


True...but that doesn't mean we should completely turn a way and not express our disappointment with what we see...don't you think? I think this is a serious issue and has been treated with a lot of irresponsibility. It is not like she does not have the money to hire a good team of writers...it actually shows instead she is rather ignorant and a naive person who has yet to learn or grow as a person in her ability to produce and present such a sensitive topic.
pallavi25 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
Mansi shd have been taken to a hospital and tested with a rape kit, even after 2-3 days there might be traces and evidence that rape had taken place!

They could have checked Ankita's mobile for Raunak's message to Mansi to come up on the terrace...why did Ankita just reject the mobile as unimportant? 😕 Even if its a broken mobile, cant messages be retrieved from it?
Mansi's mobile would have Raunak's messages and calls...even if he used his friend's mobile, that can be tracked as being his friend's.
There are other physical signs of a rape like bruises, etc. did they even check her for that?






933624 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: pallavi25

Mansi shd have been taken to a hospital and tested with a rape kit, even after 2-3 days there might be traces and evidence that rape had taken place!


They could have checked Ankita's mobile for Raunak's message to Mansi to come up on the terrace...why did Ankita just reject the mobile as unimportant? 😕 Even if its a broken mobile, cant messages be retrieved from it?
Mansi's mobile would have Raunak's messages and calls...even if he used his friend's mobile, that can be tracked as being his friend's.
There are other physical signs of a rape like bruises, etc. did they even check her for that?






i completely agree..👏
they shud have checked for the physical signs..
Laila2009 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: pallavi25

Mansi shd have been taken to a hospital and tested with a rape kit, even after 2-3 days there might be traces and evidence that rape had taken place!


They could have checked Ankita's mobile for Raunak's message to Mansi to come up on the terrace...why did Ankita just reject the mobile as unimportant? 😕 Even if its a broken mobile, cant messages be retrieved from it?
Mansi's mobile would have Raunak's messages and calls...even if he used his friend's mobile, that can be tracked as being his friend's.
There are other physical signs of a rape like bruises, etc. did they even check her for that?



Excellent points! Yes, what was he doing calling her - and the outfit she wore - he had purchased it - they can trace it...they could have even tried to trace the purchase of the bracelet. I think the writers are either under pressure or simply not capable and perhaps too inexperienced to know better.

pallavi25 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: Laila2009


Excellent points! Yes, what was he doing calling her - and the outfit she wore - he had purchased it - they can trace it...they could have even tried to trace the purchase of the bracelet. I think the writers are either under pressure or simply not capable and perhaps too inexperienced to know better.

Thanks! 😊
Ekta's writers are dumb, underpaid and overworked! They simply dont care!
And Ekta is just sensationalizing this whole rape track! She has no decency left in her! Only cares for business at the end of the day!
Edited by pallavi25 - 11 years ago
katy kay thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#8
I'm quite outrage of this story
COMOON were are in 2014 until now no cv
Can show correct and right way for procedural concerning
A rape case its a shame
The evidence against raunaq is so compelling
-his behavior toward women
-the female complaints against him + witnesses to his personality
-the bracelet must have his DNA on it
-the fake bracelet just some research they will find he lied
-the victim shouldve went to do a rape kit,
She must have scratch him so his DNA on her nails
the semen they would've find if they had done a check up
-the SMS
-the phone its self
Note to the cv if you can't or don't know how to do something
Its better you stay away from it instead of ruin it
pallavi25 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: katy kay

I'm quite outrage of this story
COMOON were are in 2014 until now no cv
Can show correct and right way for procedural concerning
A rape case its a shame
The evidence against raunaq is so compelling
-his behavior toward women
-the female complaints against him + witnesses to his personality
-the bracelet must have his DNA on it
-the fake bracelet just some research they will find he lied
-the victim shouldve went to do a rape kit,
She must have scratch him so his DNA on her nails
the semen they would've find if they had done a check up
-the SMS
-the phone its self
Note to the cv if you can't or don't know how to do something
Its better you stay away from it instead of ruin it


Very good points!
Raunak's bracelet that they found on the terrace will have his DNA...
Arjun and Ankita can testify abt Raunak's behavior with female employees! And why he was fired from office!
DNA under nails would have been washed off as Mansi had a bath!

CVs are the dumbest ever, its futile to expect logic in this show! But at least after Delhi case, they shd show more sensitivity and knowledge abt such cases! Ekta and CVs shd go to Hell for the garbage they are showing!

Ms.SK thumbnail
Deal or No Deal Thumbnail Screen Detective Participant Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#10
as a silent reader, I have to say you all are correct. 👍🏼 👏
there is an article in rival site about the lawyer from London who is famous and honest laywyer brought in by Naren to defend Raunaq.
Later on this lawyer will have doubts on Raunaq so hopefully he will start questioning Raunaq in his unique ways and raunaq caught out

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".