Second Male Lead is a MUST : Kool Comments - Page 11

Created

Last reply

Replies

565

Views

31.5k

Users

40

Likes

1.2k

Frequent Posters

tarantulla_p thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: Tanyaz

Taran I would just like to add one more thing , that should happen .

Manav should have a big talk with his mother that only to keep herhappy he cannot possibly destroy three lives , his , Archana's and Shravani's ( if he is not married to her then she is living a loveless life and that is pathetic ) .
All this has happened because maanv just never ever says No to savita ...
And Savita is very spoiled ,she wants everything the way she likes it .


Yes, in fact - Damodar should confront Savita that she was one of the causes of the crisis. Savita is very manipulative and never admits to being wrong. She willfully sacrificed her son's happiness for her spite and greed (initially) and then never really did anything about it. I think the ideal scene basically starts at the point where Archana walks away from the marriage place and Manav looks to everyone and says, I cannot marry anyone else. Let the chips fall as they may. Thats what was missing in this guy. He never stood up for their relationship. If he did that, he basically takes a stance and lets Shravani know their relationship has no future. Just because Archana gives a few doomsday scenarios of Shravani's life, doesnt mean those have to happen - heck, what does she know?
Tanyaz thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
yeah exactly what does she know . What about manav's own brains . That man is always busy trying to keep his momma happy . Whoever she says ' go fill her maang' he does that . Tomorrow if she bullies him to fill Lakshmi Kaki's maang , he will do that .
The man has to grow a spine .
This show can only be saved if manav truly emerges as a hero ( and not Archana so much ) and takes the bull by the horn , talks to his mother , come to some mature conclusion between Shravani and himself ... regarding child custody or visits ..
And then get his love back to where she belongs , right next to him ..
can't see TRPs going up any other way ...
Edited by Tanyaz - 15 years ago
tarantulla_p thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
LOL - Lakshmi kaki's maang - ha ha ha....he was literally acting like Savita's pet goat. Cat got his tongue real bad.
saffiyyah thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
Hey KoolDi,yep u can call me Saffy 😊
I think it was a v productive session on the forum today,am feeling happy
KoolDi u stated the problem as is,and Taran spelled out the only sane way to handle the story now and how to save all the characters(especially hero Manav)👏
I am thinking of creating a PR_Fan_Review FB account,and post our conclusions end of the day or week or something to the writers-am sure this will be welcomed(except by that DasGupta lady,will give her a Choo style shouting once😡😡😡)
koolsadhu1000 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: tarantulla_p



KS, I agree he made a lot of mistakes w.r.t her and Shravani..but so did she..towards the end. She never ever asked him how can you do this to me or say, sorry, I dont want to share my relationship. It was a very unhealthy co dependent relationship towards the end and actually both of them crumbled under pressure. Now the pressure is not there and there are no scary circumstances to handle. If he has not married Shravani with a healthy Damodar in the house and an illegitimate child in his lap, there is a compelling reason probably. If the creatives are listening, I would like for them to show that he and Shravani have matured up to their reality and have made this decision that they are just not made for each other. The slate has to be clean there.

As for Archana, it is very likely her parents will start looking for guys for her very soon. Hopefully they show some decent person that she actually has a shot at happiness with and no drama. Once all that is in place, she should learn of Manav's single status and THEN decide. She should be given alternatives for sure. If Manav is married to Shravani, even in the most flimsiest way, then Archana HAS to have an uber goodlooking, rich and decent husband. Forget Pavitra Rishta.

Taran
U say .......If Manav is married to Shravni even in the most flimsiest way , then Archna HAS to have another guy , right ?
Well , didnt he marry her by putting sindoor ? Isnt that a flimsy marraige ? Can that EVER be undone ? Can Shravni EVER be his bhabhi now ?EVER ? She is a perpetual embarassment in ARMAN"s lives .
Today even he has NOT married her , he is living with her in the same house , that very same woman in whose MAANG he once put sindoor , right in front of Archnas eyes . Can that unofficial marraige , done in front of GOD and elders be UNDONE ? Memorywise ?
So Archu going BACK to manav will be ALWAYS a two wife scenario . If Shravni did not marry him now legally still in a way she remains Manavs wife.....an unloved wife , he took on for responsibility , but nevertheless a WIFE . Its too late to be a Kaka now.
And if Shravni Did NOT marry Manav she exercised HER choice . By Throwing Archu over for responsibility Manav exercised HIS choice .Where does this leave Archu ? Did she ever get to exercise her choice ?
Even today people are saying . nono , let Manav apologise then she shud take him back .Or Manav shud have a talk with Savita and become firm like never before and THEN Archu shud go there . That means Archu has only one option in life.......Manav . Manav on the other hand had other options.Shravni , Savita , Sachins child .
Why shud a woman be demeaned this way ?Did u guys see Salma Aghas film Nikaah ? It is based on muslim society . Muslim society is so traditional , orthodox .Yet A new thought was presented before male Muslim viewers at that time . The woman gets divorced by her husband by uttering Talaq TalaQ TalaQ thrice . Then he realises his mistake. Suffers etc . Meanwhile after suffering a lot , the woman remarries , a nice man . Now this first husband wants her back so the nice second hubby decides to divorce her so she can remarry him and she says ..........Where Am I in all this ? That man was indeed my first love and u my compromise , but he threw me over . Today U are being mahaan and are sending me back to him ...........what gave u the idea i want to go back ? I dont want to . Its is NOT MY WISH . I want to exercise MY choice . And I choose this marraige with u that I entered as compromise .
Why are serials made this way ? Archu shud NOT go back to manav is my firm opinion . I knew many wont see it that way , but i decided to post this anyways .😊
Edited by koolsadhu1000 - 15 years ago
sweetbibi thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
totally agree if the male lead can move on why can't they show the female lead moving on also they are very narrow minded people
tarantulla_p thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
KS - couldnt agree with you more on most of what you said. No two thoughts about why Archana does not deserve another guy - much better than Manav in terms of commitment to her. However, my whole argument is based on the premise of love between Archana and Manav. If it has held up, it has held up. Manav putting sindoor on Shravani is bizarre and hollow and yes, it did represent commitment but the act is meaningless both in the Hindu law and also in the eyes of real law. It was just drama..he was legally married to another woman then, so it has no value. Also, he has at several occasions admonished Shravani that they were not married. When I say flimisiest of marriages, I mean anything post divorce. If he has had a court marriage/marriage in a temple/ marriage in front of his chawl buddies - it all holds. It all shows an intent to marry Shravani and have her as his wife and any of this means that Archana is the other woman and I am with you then, she should move on and never look back.

If on the other hand, he refused to marry Shravani after Archana left him, solely because he loved only Archana, he deserves a dekho - because then he has demonstrated what he never has before - love for Archana over all his silly made up responsibilities.

Having said this though, I want Archana to be able to make a choice and not left with only Manav. She should be given a shot at a relationship with a nice, stable decent, goodlooking man who adores her. This would help counter a lot of Manav effect in her life. When she meets such a man and lets herself think about him, only then should Manav's availability come to fore. Else, its no fair fight. Then, Archana can decide if she wants to stay with her great love Manav or this perfectly viable option Man #2. Manav to be her great love has to prove SHE is the only woman in his life come what may. Failing which, Archana should never be tempted with his miseries. Again, I reiterate, during all this, she should be kept away from his family. Its impossible for her to resist all of them at any point.

Tanyaz thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
You have a very valid point Kool but that guy , the first husband in Nikaah was terrible , he used to hit his wife .
manav is not that evil and in this divorce Archana has played a role too ....
salma Agha never had anything to do with her talaak ..
The whole problem ( for me at least ) is the TRPs . What to do Kool.... people are just not acceptin the Maanv Shravani couple .. The show is taking a nose dive and it will have to cose shop if what we are saying is shown.
The show's main USP s is Manav and Archana ... that is why everyone was angry when they divorced . Writers made a mistake .
that couple was just too popular ..
And them splitting for someone like Shravan iwho hardly anybody likes ....
So no matter what we want .. .after reading the article today , I don't think th ewriters will take a chance of showing Manav living this life of compromise with Shravan iforever and Archana going to someone else ...
In real life women like Archana and Shravan ido not exist , neither do men like maanv do ...
So keeping this in mind I guess the track will move towards reunion at some point ...
Or else the show will flop ...
Tanyaz thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
If he put sindooron Shravani , he put sindoor on Archana to after a few days only , with his will then ..
We just have to wait and see if a proper marriage did happen between them or not .
It would have been so good had Archana got a better guy than manav but now I don't think the writers will take this chance ..
Edited by Tanyaz - 15 years ago
--Hope-- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
Kool:

to me, now that divorce is done at manav's insistence and marriage is done at Archu's insistence, there is no value in a reunion. For em the show has gone from "Sad Rishta" to "Absurd Rishta"

we will forever be looking at a cracked glass, no matter no pretty the frame you cannot ignore the self-inflicted crack.

Archana is mostly delusional. not sure how much she has progressed professionally or personally as a result of the leap.

however, if a new lead was introduced for her then the hope would be that this is a relationship that the CVs want to build on. At this point of time, introducing a new lead to cause Manav jealousy is pathetic in my mind.

I think they seem happy with their life choices and should proceed seperately. no need to meet, mingle or reunite.

the divorce was irreparable.

I feel bad for shibani dasgupta. all I can say is that she is young and inexperienced in worldy matters, it seems. I have heard of her comments. All I can say is Shibani evn if this show dies, you have learnt a good lessson to be used in your personal life. IF IT AIN'T BROKE DON'T FIX IT. Definitely not to get some ill founded creativity or excitement. As you will regret the loss of something magical and successful and will be left with failure rather than excitement or creative inspiration you sought

Hope


Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".