Similarity in MJHT and PMMKA - Coincidence or...

rakhiii89 thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#1
I am a huge arjun bijlani fan, not a huge fan of the show, but i manage to catch it up for arjun on youtube! I have also followed MJHT , and some sincere doubts are arising in my mind.

I was in fact catching up with some miley episodes, and realized some similarities btw ChandNi and MN scenes.....maybe its just me...

1st of all, how chandu meets niru is very similar to how mayank meets nupur. He saves her from a bad problem, then they have a trip fall catch.

then when chandu helps niru put a tie is very similar to the miley scene when mayank puts dori for nupur.

when chandu thinks "niru tumse milne se pehle agar koi mujhse yeh kehta ki pehli nazar mein pyar hota hain, to main kehta nahin, par ab keh sakta hun, haan hota hain". this is very similar to a miley dialogue when mayank tells nupur how he never thought that he'd confess his love in front of the whole world.

And in today's episode, the dialogue "acha suno achi lag rahi ho", is a dialogue by mayank at uday's birthday party.....

I don't know whether its just me, but its too much of a coincidence naaa?

And the dances initially are so similar to mayank nupur dances

its just a POV based on observations and facts...
Edited by rakhiii89 - 14 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

32

Views

2.9k

Users

11

Likes

44

Frequent Posters

ROFLOL thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#2
Aww really good observations.

Maybe this is the reason that some mayur fans are likin chandni too.

All of these have been my fav scenes too.- both mayur and chandni ones.
Thanks for sharing.

And i would like to add that even though the scenes are same, the flavour is diff.
Mayur were more passionate, romantic types. Chandni is cute types and more relate-able types- for me atleast.
Edited by Sshikhaa - 14 years ago
andyluvstv thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#3
Wow, i had heard about recycled clothes, but scenes and dialogues being recycled too, amazing.
Wont say about the 1st scene coz thats the most cliche scene, but dialogue bit was interesting. Infact, i was surprised when i heard Chandu saying that coz his character is of a lover boy, someone who can fall in love at first sight, but now it makes sense, it has been taken from Mayank-Nupur confession scene. And i just saw the achi lagti ho scene on yt, my goodness same to same dialogue.

What are these people trying to do, this is a very bad way to try and publicize a couple. Scenes i agree can be a coincidence, but dialogues, hard to digest.

Anyways, thanx for letting us know, this show is loosing all sense of uniqueness now.
Edited by andyluvstv - 14 years ago
ROFLOL thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#4
Haha ppl who are really annoyed with recycling of scenes must watch dmg and mjht lol
Mjht copied dmg scenes too. Nothin was original in mjht too lol.. And these scenes have been shown in many other shows.

We've had an auto scene in some other show. So omg did they copy from PMMKA? Wow.

andyluvstv thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#5
Anyways, scenes can be copied, but dialogues word to word, atleast i havent seen such stuff. Ridiculous

And i think they are just trying desperately to spice up boring and dull Chandu-Niru by copying from a famous couple, and i m not surprised why of all the couples Mayank-Nupur were chosen.

The story of this show has been spoiled by CVs in this quest only, and thats how they have ruined Niru's character too.
Edited by andyluvstv - 14 years ago
ROFLOL thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#6
Maybe TM your intensions werent bad to create this topic, but it would be really nice if you don make such comparision posts in future specially related to mjht and pmmka .
You know how volatile fans are na.
Anyway i liked the observations. good to know that chandni scenes remind us of some famous couple...
rakhiii89 thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#7
@ shikha, DMG/MJHT were out and rip out of movies....infact all the shows are...unfortunate truth.... earlier when niru refused to marry anyone because of her baba, tat seemed similar to Rajo's character in Dabangg...

but the dialogues, esp the once used today are too much of a coincidence 😆

as for relating to chandni, u are a fan, u must have reasons, i see none, characters are weird in this show to related 😆, i just watch it for the sake of as i used to watch MJHT earlier, anyways won't go there and will stick to the topic.

thanks for ur reply

@andyluvstv i agree abt chandu's character and dialogues being mismatched, his has been an inconsistent character, anyways can't do much abt it 😆
ROFLOL thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#8
Yeah i know ;) all shows are a cut copy paste of movies. Even the dialogues.

Yup good , sticking to the topic is wat is needed in the forum for healthy discussions good.
rakhiii89 thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#9
as i wrote in my P.S. tat its just a POV, no intentions of comparing characters actors, its just the scenes/dialogues, volatile fans don't visit this forum, it mostly has nice ppl who always have nice things to say, that is why i thot it wud be safe to post here 😆, no offense intended 😊
andyluvstv thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#10
@ Rakhi, i guess u were misguided my friend, coz in this forum, u are welcome only if u say nice things, else u are termed as MID, had an experience like this, with my first topic here.

Anyways, yes shows are ripped off from movies, but not a dialogue. And in MJHT, todays dialogue, "suno, achi lag rahi ho" was exact same, in same situation, just after confession, and same goes for confession dialogue.

Now same lines in same situations, too much of a coincidence.
Edited by andyluvstv - 14 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".