'Charmar got eliminated because of Star Plus'

Page

Next Last

Sadie.Saxton

@Sadie.Saxton

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

So I've read a couple of topics on the forum, regarding Amar and Charlie's elimination, and most fans blame Sajid and the channel for Amar-Charlie's elimination.

I posted this in another topic, but decided to start a new topic, and see what everyone else feels.

I dont know why everyone's making such an issue over Amar-Charlie's elimination- many have happened before them, and people will be eliminated in the upcoming weeks. Only one jodi will win in the end.

And I'm tired of the "star plus wants their people to win" excuse.
If you guys didnt know, both Amar and Charlie's shows are on Channel V- which is one of Star's shows.
Kushal Tandon works for Star plus- he got eliminated many weeks back.

And of the jodis left:
Suhasi - works for zee tv (competing channel)
Sargun - works for sony (competing channel)

So going by this logic, Jaysheel-Suhasi and Ravi-Sargun should have been kicked out before Kushal-Elena and Amar-Charlie.

And this is coming from a fan of Amar and Charlie. I watch both BFF and D3, and even off screen both seem like sweet, humble people. Just because I am a fan doesn't mean I have to support them in every single thing they do, and I feel at this point of the competition it was their turn to go.

Quote

Frequent Posters

Nitya

@ChanandlerBong

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

Amar did a great job but charlie was a bit weaker ...

But aren't votes counted ???

According to votes , they would have entered the top 5 😕

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Diya_Taarey

@Diya_Taarey

Dazzler

Posted: 12 years ago

Completely agree to this post finally a post that puts across sensible points instead of THEORIES

Quote

Nikki

@Nikki_s

Navigator

Posted: 12 years ago

As per points they are safe. So only 1 option there starplus dirty politics.

And last sunday arvind forget step they got 30 act also not good and charlie forgot step ok terence and shilpa ne according to this 9 marks diye but sajid ne 7 marks not kidding with us.

Hate starplus.

Edited by Avc380 - 12 years ago

Quote

chumchee25

@chumchee25

Explorer

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

It's a contest and someone had to go. It's a pity that it was Amar and Charlie but if it had been Karan and Nisha or someone else their fans would have been upset as well.

Hope Amar and Charlie gain more success elsewhere. Nach Baliye isn't the ideal show to be a part of if Sajid Khan is the judge and no one dares to speak up against him.

Quote

lovehappiness

@lovehappiness

Navigator

Posted: 12 years ago

👏 I too am not understanding all the conspiracy theories. I don't have any favourites here and I don't dislike anyone (except of course Rahul-Dimpy who stayed way too long in the competition with zero dancing skills). So this is purely based on the dancing.

Saturdays Charmar performance was really bad. Sunday's was not good either. So guess elimination is natural. I thought Charmar and Suhasi-Jaysheel should be in bottom 2 based on performance and an y one of them leaving was fine for me. The only issue I had was the 30 points given to Arvind-Neelu when he stopped in between that was unfair as per me/

Quote

Sadie.Saxton

@Sadie.Saxton

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

😆 I was expecting to be bashed left, right and center for going against what majority of Amar, Charlie fans are saying.

Thanks everyone (even those who didnt agree with me) for putting your views forward in a reasonable way.

+ I agree about the partiality and difference of scores that the judges have for Neelu-Arvind and Amar-Charlie. I think the age is a HUGE factor for that, and also it might be that Charlie forgets her steps in every act, and most of their recent acts have been mediocre. With Arvind-Neelu atleast you can see the energy and effort they are putting forward. I'm not saying I think it's fair, but this might be the reasoning behind it.