karan-nisha 32!!!! was it justified?

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

848092

Suspended

Posted: 12 years ago

#21

I agree with you.

I will edit my post later..

Quote

shwetha

@LegolasGondolin

Sparkler

+ 5

Posted: 12 years ago

#22

u made a point here.

according to me suhasi and jaisheel also gave a wunderful performance.. just because they have given good performances and the judges expect a loot from them.. they werre given only 24 marks.

while karan and nisha danced well.it wasn' an over the top performance to get a 32..

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

tasnuva

@tastahnin

Dazzler

Posted: 12 years ago

#23

Originally posted by: gunjanmyjaan
totally agree with u nd sm jodis r given +1 for their dress for their confidence nd blah blah blah but were charmar given a single extra mark for the start no why?? cause the judjes r biased nd also karan is star plus's favourite beta

@bold,absolutely👍🏼...some jodis are being given extra marks when there is actually nothing to praise...in spite of not giving any outstanding performance judges are praising every trivial points of them while some others are not getting good complements in spite of giving good and something different performances...what kind of judgment is this yaar??

Quote

Mohabbateinn

@Mohabbateinn

Sparkler

+ 5

Posted: 12 years ago

#24

🤣

totally agree with TM

to me ..it seems like SP wants to keep on promoting YRKKH and KARAN MEHRA AS NAITIK ... via such cheap gimmicks..

from which angle was that a 32 ????

seriously SP... atleast forge the marks to be a bit realistic .. 😳

Quote

Depalii

@Depalii

Explorer

Posted: 12 years ago

#25

Disagree
Well I felt there performance in totally dance to compare with others Jodi and they both performed really well so totally justyfied the given marks by judge, I dont understand why pointing out there performance ?? Look at charmer performance ek dum thanda and what about Charlie ? She is very weak only amar is a gud dancer so stop comparing with other's

Edited by Depalii - 12 years ago

Quote

preksha

@pree4ru

Stunner

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

#26

well see if karan Nisha took big risk dancing without any prop which sajid pointed out and they preety well handled it and they did deserve it and i think this was one of the best or only amazing act done by Karan Nisha so far , so its not wrong in getting 32 infact if it was so much that SP loved Karan or something wudnt they get 30 inspite of performing not well no this was the first time they got 30 so .

Quote

Shehreen

@Shehreen_27

Voyager

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#27

What was so great? NOTHING! AT ALL!

But having that said ..Considering their other acts , this act was on a much higher level and was pulled of greatly! Their other performances sucked to be honest but this performance was the first performance where I actually felt like yea Karan put some effort!

Quote

rahul009ful

@rahul009ful

Inactive

Posted: 12 years ago

#28

Originally posted by: -Vanshikaa-
🤣

totally agree with TM

to me ..it seems like SP wants to keep on promoting YRKKH and KARAN MEHRA AS NAITIK ... via such cheap gimmicks..

from which angle was that a 32 ????

seriously SP... atleast forge the marks to be a bit realistic .. 😳

🤣 🤣 or watelse dey should do promote ravi sargun or jay mahi
Karan nisha got32 bcoz dey deserve it atleast dey don't tell use false gimmicks to gain votes..

Quote

anwesha rath

@Anurulz

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#29

i have the same issue wid the judges this year..they seem to compare the jodis ONLY wid their previous performances, and not with EACH OTHER..so a mediocre performance by a not-so-great jodi scores the same as a good performance by a great dancing couple..due to the same, rahul-dimpy were scoring high marks previously, and now as u say, is with karan-nisha..but those who dance well are scored low coz the EXPECTATIONS are high..its a wierd logic..

Quote

Alina

@-Alinaa-

Voyager

Posted: 12 years ago

#30

I agree with the topic maker. The level of judgement should be same for everyone.

Karan-Nisha did gr8 compared to their previous acts. I was pleasantly surprised by them. But it was not 32 deserving performance. The energy level was lower than required. 32 would have been OK, if other couples were also judged accordingly. Coz this is not DID, where everything has to be perfect. They are mostly non dancers, so some considerations should be done. But if basis of judgement is unequal, it is not fair for other couples.

I don't understand their judgement marking system, that is why I watch only the performances and Terrence's comments, n skip through other parts,