And the history repeats it! UPMA again gets 25! - Page 3

Originally posted by: Vedika126

despite being a himruta crazy fan I have to agree that upma deserved 28 marks at least for the last act. they were better. Himruta also deserved 28 not 29 for sure. Upma were really good and their lifts were excellent.

As for the judges, they dont have a clue what they are judging the couples. I always thought remo was a tough judge however he was quite leanient this time. Lets see if farah khan will do any wonders and judge jodis properly.

Originally posted by: vibg

valid topic!!!! i said the same in UpMa AT, but will copy and paste parts of my comments here...

I don't care about scores anymore. NB7 has scripted storyline and whosoever comes, will score accordingly... show's main competition are UpMa, Himruta and Rashmi. UpMa following is crazy so, in my opinion, the makers are trying to make the playing field leveled for the voting rounds... by consistently underscoring UpMa... even if their performance was at par with Himruta. Himruta did great, but definitely not a 10 performance.. esp. coming from Remo... appeared too scripted to me. Himruta deserved their score. But the fact remains... UpMa deserved a 28 or 29 too for that mindblowing performance that had the judges, contestants, and audience in WOW👏

you could tell by the judges faces.. how entertaining and mindblowing UpMa was!!!! and the crowd went wild. and the co-contestants were amazed. the camera showed all their faces and how entertained and blown away they all were!!!!!!!!!

I am glad Shradha pointed out... YES... the viewers, the audience... loves UpMa. techinically amazing👏 so cute.. shradha and Varun were both of in awe of these guys and so was Remo. He was smiling the whole time. Unfortunately, I knew his scoring will be along the same lines as directed by PH😡 but his face when watching UpMa dance.. said it all.. how thoroughly he was enjoying it!

i agree.. with his legs feedback though.. it's an issue cause she is taller than Upen.. so that was excellent feedback... but 25.. now way. 28 or 29... but oh well..😡 taking 5 points off for that... way tooo unreal.

as for others... I agree too... Rashmi did all the dancing... I've seen her before and she is awesome. but no expressions for a Madhuri dance and nandish was doing what? all others scored well xpt Mrunal and Sharad. their choreography was great... but theri execution was blah.

I forwarded Sangram Payl part too xpt the scores and then jumped with delight👏

it doesn't matter... in reality shows... it's ultimately the VOTES!

I say replace all judges and start the season all over again...😆...

So now some random viewers know more about dancing than professional dancers and choreographers (especially Remo)?

Dancing isn't all about gymnastics. It isn't all about how entertaining the act was, the amount of difficult lifts present or how many "wow" moments there were. While there was a significant amount of dancing present in Upen and Karishma's performance, I don't think it should have garnered a score more than 25 or 26.

As for the technical deficiencies in their performance, the judges aren't obliged to list out all the flaws they found in their performance. There may have been some other factors which made them give a low score. Speculating off this and thinking that the judges have some prejudice against them is ridiculous.

Originally posted by: HippoSucks

So now some random viewers know more about dancing than professional dancers and choreographers (especially Remo)?

Dancing isn't all about gymnastics. It isn't all about how entertaining the act was, the amount of difficult lifts present or how many "wow" moments there were. While there was a significant amount of dancing present in Upen and Karishma's performance, I don't think it should have garnered a score more than 25 or 26.

As for the technical deficiencies in their performance, the judges aren't obliged to list out all the flaws they found in their performance. There may have been some other factors which made them give a low score. Speculating off this and thinking that the judges have some prejudice against them is ridiculous.

Upen and Karishma's performance was way better than Mrunal and Sharad's who got 27! UpMa was underscored for sure.

Originally posted by: kaur.preet

Disagree...this time,marking is good and every couple got what they deserve

I also felt this time around marking was proper by Marzi & Remo...less speak about chetan its better he has his own weird way of giving marks...

Amrut-Himanshoo performs was the best, 2nd upen-karishma, 3rd sharad-mrunal , it was a toss between rohit-ash & shan-payal

also my marks differ

1) Amruta-himanshu---9/9/9---total 27 marks..it was not a 10 performance

2) Upen-Karishma---9/8/9---total 26 marks---

3) shard-mrunal---8/8/8---total 24 dance is avg...the concept was nice they tried something diff.

4) rashmi-nandish---8/7/8---23 ---only for rashmi she was superb..nandish needs to improve

5) rohit-ash-----6/6/6---total -18--total dis-coordination--one of their worst performance--but they can do better

6) sang-payal--5/5/5---they choose a very diff dance form..2nd payal is a good dancer & sang also tried very hard but they are not good for top 5

--also not happy with wild card--they should have contest between eliminated jodis & give 2 jodis wildcard ..why bring this new couples..as rohit said injustice on existing couples

I am himanshoo amruta fan but I really think karishma upen were not given proper scores this week :( there were a few mistakes but I think they deserved 27 ! I definitely agree it was better then Sharad n mrunal ! Anyways I just watch this show for timepass !

Yes! I totally agree. Even my mum said that they are very unfair with karishma upen 😭 I love those two and they are very talented <3

Originally posted by: rafalover4rever

I am himanshoo amruta fan but I really think karishma upen were not given proper scores this week :( there were a few mistakes but I think they deserved 27 ! I definitely agree it was better then Sharad n mrunal ! Anyways I just watch this show for timepass !

an important advice to everyone whoever you support this show is an ekta kapoor show , most of the show is scripted so don't loose your heart enjoy good performance clap for them n don't feel that good performances didn't get good scores bcx the judging is useless!

Originally posted by: -Shina-93

Yes! I totally agree. Even my mum said that they are very unfair with karishma upen 😭 I love those two and they are very talented <3