One judge said Gurbina's performance Accha tha!

purethought thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#1
yesterday after Gurmeet and Debina's performance

after Shilpa and Terrence had their say--


One judge (not naming -- you know who) looked at Gurmeet and Debina

apka performance accha tha... but saari galti choreos ki hai!!

🤣

Such comments never come forth for ASHVIK, if their choreos goof up. It is always ASHVIK's fault. 😆
I just hope that the winners aren't declared prior to the show. 😆

Having said this, Ashvik's choreos are awesome, and no one is flawless in this world. Everyone only gets better with time and effort. Even Gurbina's choreo have their strengths and weaknesses.

Let the best man and woman win on the day, including their dancing skills and popularity, because, both are interdependent. No fan is going to make any jodi popular, if they weren't strong dancers😆
ASHVIK have had to earn their popularity. 😳

(I do like Gurmeet and Debina as dancers, they are quite good, but don't want anyone to not give credit where it is due, and to demoralise other worthy contestants)

(Note: This is not to bash any judge, in fact, I consider him to be a creative and intelligent person, but favoritism, should not colour anyone's judgements, and I think that is what is happening.)

Edited by purethought - 11 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

9

Views

2.7k

Users

7

Likes

106

Frequent Posters

-stylediva- thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
yes hypocracy at the peak 🤣 first of all dance selection & the costume all were OTT, nobody knows why they were on bed & suddenly started dancing crazy with no sync & continuity . regarding steps they were ok but it was a south indian cheap street dance which need clear action & foot work, in two places they didn't complete the steps, expression wise debina was better but gc seen uncomfortable, steps though simple could be performed with more into the form like ashwik their steps were not gr8 but they worked on the style & the teasing technique which was too good. & they could maintain continuity between acts like after climbing on to the roof etc, but debina after climbing on the prop it was like a different type of dance she is doing. i think gurbinas know this time no voting so casually did it. Mr. sajid though choreography was simple they shd have done each step with that poise & form. they did a good job but our Hulk sajid had ego issues in accepting gurbina were not up to the mark.😆
vasu_2013 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
Exactly Trish! The same thoughts that crossed my mind.
When Gurbina's performance wasn't so good, the same judge sounds almost apologetic in his comments and while giving the scores . It wasn't just yesterday's act, the act couple of weeks back, he just told them not to break his heart and sounded quite sad about it. 😲
I do not mind this attitude towards Gurbina but he should adopt the same stand with everyone. He is either tough and straight in dishing out critical comments or he is nasty with everyone. Why does it have to be just one couple to bear the brunt all the time? I don't know if it is just me but he seems more caustic towards Asha.
I just caught up with Ashvik's performance today morning and was not online for 3 days. My euphoria after watching Ashvik's performance was brought down in a second after hearing the last comment. First the judge cannot insult Janta's votes but saying even after 'karrab' performances, Ashvik are on #1 by popularity. Second, he cannot openly comment that another couple are better in dancing. REALLY?
I can understand other contestants if they feel jealous. That's more natural but it is not accepted from a judge. His job is to judge the performance and he should focus on just doing a good job at it.
As I have just come off watching the episode, my heart goes to Ashvik right now. I sincerely hope that they win the competition as they are a perfect mix of merit and humility and worthy of every bit of love from their fans. This is the FACT.
piya4u thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
Remember Ashvik's MJ act..that act was way better than Gurbina's yesterday's act..But he gave them a 6? In that act also dancing was good, especially Rithvik was flawless in MJ but their choreographer messed it up..But then Sajid bashed Rithvik like hell...Didnt say i am sorry, your choreos didnt well choreograph it!In that performance shilpa terence gave 9 n sajid 6, so total 24
they came 2nd 4 that performance.
And remember their stilts act? Shilpa and terence gave 10 and sajid 7..total=27..They came 1st..rest all acts were 31+.
If Sajid says that always they give " Kharab" performance, then why do the judges give them 31+ marks? Give them 6/6/6..they will never come to top position..And most importantly 50% judges marks are counted..

From all these things only 1 thing can be concluded---" Audience doesnt give a damn about Sajid's marks and considers him to be a dumb sick mental person"..Viewers dont even consider is existence on this show..He is actually the Stupid BigBoss of NB6 who keeps on doing roten politics!!!!😡😡
If NB thinks of coming back with another season, they must change the judges panel..But honestly i dont think any dignified couple will be interested to participate in this classless show espcially after seeing how the big stars of TV like Rithvik n Gurmeet are insulted in front of the whole world 😡
purethought thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: vasu_2013

Exactly Trish! The same thoughts that crossed my mind.

When Gurbina's performance wasn't so good, the same judge sounds almost apologetic in his comments and while giving the scores . It wasn't just yesterday's act, the act couple of weeks back, he just told them not to break his heart and sounded quite sad about it. 😲
I do not mind this attitude towards Gurbina but he should adopt the same stand with everyone. He is either tough and straight in dishing out critical comments or he is nasty with everyone. Why does it have to be just one couple to bear the brunt all the time? I don't know if it is just me but he seems more caustic towards Asha.
I just caught up with Ashvik's performance today morning and was not online for 3 days. My euphoria after watching Ashvik's performance was brought down in a second after hearing the last comment. First the judge cannot insult Janta's votes but saying even after 'karrab' performances, Ashvik are on #1 by popularity. Second, he cannot openly comment that another couple are better in dancing. REALLY?
I can understand other contestants if they feel jealous. That's more natural but it is not accepted from a judge. His job is to judge the performance and he should focus on just doing a good job at it.
As I have just come off watching the episode, my heart goes to Ashvik right now. I sincerely hope that they win the competition as they are a perfect mix of merit and humility and worthy of every bit of love from their fans. This is the FACT.



Yes Vasu :)

I too hope they win the show, because they are popular and worthy dancers!

Asha is a sweet person, and has grown into an amazing dancer
Terrence has already complimented her, but running to the stage to her😳

Terrence is the real dance judge here. 😃 He is a trained dancer😛 and I accept all his comments always. He is completely impartial. More power to Terrence.



purethought thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: only4ashvik

Remember Ashvik's MJ act..that act was way better than Gurbina's yesterday's act..But he gave them a 6? In that act also dancing was good, especially Rithvik was flawless in MJ but their choreographer messed it up..But then Sajid bashed Rithvik like hell...Didnt say i am sorry, your choreos didnt well choreograph it!In that performance shilpa terence gave 9 n sajid 6, so total 24

they came 2nd 4 that performance.
And remember their stilts act? Shilpa and terence gave 10 and sajid 7..total=27..They came 1st..rest all acts were 31+.
If Sajid says that always they give " Kharab" performance, then why do the judges give them 31+ marks? Give them 6/6/6..they will never come to top position..And most importantly 50% judges marks are counted..

From all these things only 1 thing can be concluded---" Audience doesnt give a damn about Sajid's marks and considers him to be a dumb sick mental person"..Viewers dont even consider is existence on this show..He is actually the Stupid BigBoss of NB6 who keeps on doing roten politics!!!!😡😡
If NB thinks of coming back with another season, they must change the judges panel..But honestly i dont think any dignified couple will be interested to participate in this classless show espcially after seeing how the big stars of TV like Rithvik n Gurmeet are insulted in front of the whole world 😡



👏 applause for what you have said in bold

Cinema people don't have the right to put down TV stars...

no one is more or less ... God has made everyone equal.
TV is as good as Big Screen..

also agree with your point about how one Judge in particular was responsible for ASHVIK getting those low scores. 😕 --- when the other two judges gave good scores.

Let us not bash Sajid calling him mentally sick. He has a certain position in the industry and has brains and intelligence of course, but then, he has his favorites, which is probably coloring his responses, and not allowing any wisdom to shine through as of now. Let us not bash him, but let's vote and allow ASHVIK to shine through and through with our love😳



Edited by purethought - 11 years ago
-LiveLaughLove- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#7
That was impartiality right of the bat!
As a dancer that made me want to laugh! A dancer has the capability to make bad choreo into a good performance with their dancing. It was not a good performance to me at all.

When AshVik did the MJ dance their dance was really good! It wasn't perfect but it was not worth a 6!

So RD and Asha who actually put in so much work and actually DANCED get a 6 because Sajid didn't like their concept whereas Gurmeet and Debina get a 7 but they basically get a free pass as Sajid but 100% blame on the choreographers?

Bias to the next level!

...Jes... thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: -stylediva-

yes hypocracy at the peak 🤣 first of all dance selection & the costume all were OTT, nobody knows why they were on bed & suddenly started dancing crazy with no sync & continuity . regarding steps they were ok but it was a south indian cheap street dance which need clear action & foot work, in two places they didn't complete the steps, expression wise debina was better but gc seen uncomfortable, steps though simple could be performed with more into the form like ashwik their steps were not gr8 but they worked on the style & the teasing technique which was too good. & they could maintain continuity between acts like after climbing on to the roof etc, but debina after climbing on the prop it was like a different type of dance she is doing. i think gurbinas know this time no voting so casually did it. Mr. sajid though choreography was simple they shd have done each step with that poise & form. they did a good job but our Hulk sajid had ego issues in accepting gurbina were not up to the mark.😆


i so agree with ur words dear 👏
...Jes... thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: only4ashvik

Remember Ashvik's MJ act..that act was way better than Gurbina's yesterday's act..But he gave them a 6? In that act also dancing was good, especially Rithvik was flawless in MJ but their choreographer messed it up..But then Sajid bashed Rithvik like hell...Didnt say i am sorry, your choreos didnt well choreograph it!In that performance shilpa terence gave 9 n sajid 6, so total 24

they came 2nd 4 that performance.
And remember their stilts act? Shilpa and terence gave 10 and sajid 7..total=27..They came 1st..rest all acts were 31+.
If Sajid says that always they give " Kharab" performance, then why do the judges give them 31+ marks? Give them 6/6/6..they will never come to top position..And most importantly 50% judges marks are counted..

From all these things only 1 thing can be concluded---" Audience doesnt give a damn about Sajid's marks and considers him to be a dumb sick mental person"..Viewers dont even consider is existence on this show..He is actually the Stupid BigBoss of NB6 who keeps on doing roten politics!!!!😡😡
If NB thinks of coming back with another season, they must change the judges panel..But honestly i dont think any dignified couple will be interested to participate in this classless show espcially after seeing how the big stars of TV like Rithvik n Gurmeet are insulted in front of the whole world 😡


@BOLD : oh plz .. don't even compare .. their act was flawless .. i still don't get d point .. what was missing in the act so much? 😕 it had everything ... it just is abt some ppl's favoritism so other can't have good marks 🥱
illuminated. thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 11 years ago
#10
Please do not compare what kind of comments are given to GurMina to those given to AshVik because those two couples are individuals and comparison is strictly not allowed in the NB6 forum.

Had this discussion been a discussion about the comments given to the jodis, the DT would have left this open. But this is a post instigating and looking for fights.



Regards,
NB6 DT.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".