Judges were partial today

gemini_srk thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#1

2nd Jan's episode began with a bang, and with the promo's expectations were rocket high. The good news is, they were all met, but only from the contestant's side. I feel judges were very partial with their decisions and score.

The show began with a Anushka's entry on Tujhme Rab Dikhta hai. She said she has come her to see Rab kis jodi main dikhta hai, Whichever she feels has the best chemistry that jodi will get a chance to learn 'Dance pe chance' with her.

The first dance performance was of Yash and Gauri with the retro 80's 'Oh haseena zulfon waali'. Their performance was flawless, only a little problem with Gauri's moves. Farah said dance moves were same old. Please someone remind our dance teacher, she too had used the same steps in OSO. Judges marked them 25. I think they deserved at least a 27. There were many other things that were to be appreciated and not to forget, it was just there first performance in the Nach Baliye 4 as a competing jodi. No doubt they hv performed earlier, bt thr has been a gap of 2yrs.

Moving on, the next were Chetan and Lavinia. I have really started appreciating them for the hard work they have put in. From the day they did Nach for Life, I personally feel they should now get more time to stay in the show. They could hv got 24-25 as judges know they don't get votes and they are strong. Definitely dance steps were not hard and other flaws were there too.

Reshmi and Amit for a change danced well and scored 27. There song was Show me ur Jalwa from Aaja Nachle. This has been their highest score yet n the only good performance. Here I found a mistake which judges didn't. Amit was not lip synching where as only reshmi was to be dumb. Then whr were our judges looking?? 😆😆😆Waise hi Ekta ma ki kripa hai itni inpe, wohi toh saare votes bhejti hai inke liye!!

Sudeep and Anantika came next with Disco 82. They too scored 27. They should have scored again 25-26. Apart from the mistakes that judges pointed out, i think the music was very slow. it required to be more hep and groovy, specially for the 2009 part. Coz these days disco songs are really fast. still I accept them getting 27.

Last 3 performances were the ones that were judged mst partially.

Shaleen and Daljeet perform well each time, but it doesn't mean that you do not mark them down when they have not performed well. Shaleen was unwell, still he managed to perform, daljeet did many mistakes. Thr were no expressions on her face, co-ordination, and mismatch of original and artificial faces. Moreover concept was not clear. Similar performance was done by Raakhi Sawant and Abhishek in NB3. There concept was completely clear and in sync. This one was confusing. Still they got 26. They didn't deserve more than 24. Extra 2 point can't be for sympathy because shaleen was not well but he performed as he had to. Daljeet had the problems. Shilpa and Abhijeet too had the same issue but bcoz of shilpa he didn't spoil his dance, then why being partial to them??

I feel that they are not real life jodi. Shaleen when asked if they are seeing each other said the place we come from waha gf-bf nahi hota, then why does Daljeet throws herself on his during the show. she hugs him, holds him tightly, puts her head over his shoulder and frequently kisses him. Come-on ppl grow up, if you love you dont need to show off.

Coming on next, Naman and Megha are really working hard and within no time they will take over shajit as they hv votes as well. They performed fantastically on Saawariyan and did alot more than just a dance. They deserved 29 coz thr dance was very well executed. Farah Pointed out so many mistakes for co-ordination for which they lost 3 marks. Pls judges ko last week ka show dikhao when Arjun said that shajit's dola re performance had co-ordination problems but still got 30?? Please tell me guys why there marks were not cut??

Kapil and Anjali were at the top with 28 where as they deserved a 30. They had created an ambiance of Rajasthan with their dance on Holiya main ude re gulal. there was a lil problem with their co-ordination and step which was avoidable. Arjun's reason was silly of not giving them 10 as he expects more out of them, Common refer to the above para Mr. Charming. The act of anjali standing on kapil's shoulder, i m sure Farah won't be able to do then why not one bonus point for that. Karishma had no reason to cut their marks and therefore was the only1 to gv them a perfect 10. Anushka chose kanjali and Namegha for the dance pe chance, but they were not able to do it properly.

Last but not the least, our Hosts. Hiten is always a pleasure but her wife's attitude is torture. She was Talking to Anushka, with her face towards the camera!! Also there is no smile on her face, she literally shouts on the mike and calls her husband with wrds like iska, isko, iski.. common, this looks so cheap. Hiten on other hand respects her so much by using word like 'aap'. Gauri ke liye 1 line-" Maa baap ne kuch nahi sikhaya bus bhej diya". please hiten, Aap hi kuch sikhado apni gauri ko.

Farah, Arjun, I respect you both alot. please stop being partial, or be strict to every1 equally!! otherwise publi ki sunogi n chilloge, toh abhi time hai, sambhal jao..

Moderator's Note:
Edited to remove inappropriate lines.You have rights to put your views but see to it what you say doesn't end up hurting other feelings or offend anyone. Uisng words/sentences like cheap, maa baap ne kuch nahi sikhaya bus bhej diya, please hiten, Aap hi kuch sikhado apni gauri ko is offending for the actor as well as their fans. This is against IF COC. It may create unnecessary arguments & disrupt the peace of the section.



Edited by *Shruti* - 16 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

36

Views

4k

Users

24

Likes

5

Frequent Posters

evonora thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#2

I totally agree with ur comment about Judges are partial.. I too think that they are favorable towards their jodi's that they like'

They even ask audience to vote for certain Jodi's 'wat ever the reason maybe for this'I don't think its fair for any of the other Jodi's'

It's a competition'.Judges shouldn't not be doing certain things ..they should be fair towards all'I don't care how many movies they have done in the past and how many of their movies were blockbusters'...but Judges are mostly dispointing this year....(at times I Krishma..but she also has her days...)

Next time around I would like to see pervious seasons judges back..a least they were fair most of the time'

Edited by waterlilly - 16 years ago
darshana23 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
#3
wow, the way u have did post mortem of every performance is just awesome!!!!!!!
I agree with you for Naman-Megha and Sudeep-Anantika performance...........
SecretKhabri420 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 16 years ago
#4
I agree with u, plz do write for every week, I like the way u pointed out every jodi with the judges comments!...........
SecretKhabri420 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 16 years ago
#5
By the way, is Reshmi good friend with Ekta?.........
scorpio8990 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#6
😲 the way you have analysed the performances.... its just mind blowing!
I too think that in some cases Judges do become partial!
And I fail to get the idea Arjun is judging the show!?
When did he give a dance hit last time?
dumbledore1 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#7
I think now that the competition is getting closer the judges are being less lenient with scoring. They also have to keep in mind the fact that 50% weightage of the total votes is held by their scores which might render the stronger jodis to land in bottom zone. There is a reason why they like a particular jodi, its not the jodi's fault that others are worse than them. So its only fair for the judges to appeal to vote for the best dancing jodi in a dance based competion.

And don't judge their personal conduct and lives, they are in a dance competition. I personally find many jodis fake but its better to judge what they are here to be judged on for.
pinguunique thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#8
i agree with your analysis on the jodi performances and the fact that judges were partial.
But I can't agree with you about hiten-gauri.The only reason gauri is using "cheap" words because they are trying to show the nok-jhoks between couples and trying to bring some comedy.I don't think gauri looks down on hiten, they are a very loveable jodi!!
krutiv100 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: gemini_srk

2nd Jan's episode began with a bang, and with the promo's expectations were rocket high. The good news is, they were all met, but only from the contestant's side. I feel judges were very partial with their decisions and score.

The show began with a Anushka's entry on Tujhme Rab Dikhta hai. She said she has come her to see Rab kis jodi main dikhta hai, Whichever she feels has the best chemistry that jodi will get a chance to learn 'Dance pe chance' with her.

The first dance performance was of Yash and Gauri with the retro 80's 'Oh haseena zulfon waali'. Their performance was flawless, only a little problem with Gauri's moves. Farah said dance moves were same old. Please someone remind our dance teacher, she too had used the same steps in OSO. Judges marked them 25. I think they deserved at least a 27. There were many other things that were to be appreciated and not to forget, it was just there first performance in the Nach Baliye 4 as a competing jodi. No doubt they hv performed earlier, bt thr has been a gap of 2yrs.

Moving on, the next were Chetan and Lavinia. I have really started appreciating them for the hard work they have put in. From the day they did Nach for Life, I personally feel they should now get more time to stay in the show. They could hv got 24-25 as judges know they don't get votes and they are strong. Definitely dance steps were not hard and other flaws were there too.

Reshmi and Amit for a change danced well and scored 27. There song was Show me ur Jalwa from Aaja Nachle. This has been their highest score yet n the only good performance. Here I found a mistake which judges didn't. Amit was not lip synching where as only reshmi was to be dumb. Then whr were our judges looking?? 😆😆😆Waise hi Ekta ma ki kripa hai itni inpe, wohi toh saare votes bhejti hai inke liye!!

Sudeep and Anantika came next with Disco 82. They too scored 27. They should have scored again 25-26. Apart from the mistakes that judges pointed out, i think the music was very slow. it required to be more hep and groovy, specially for the 2009 part. Coz these days disco songs are really fast. still I accept them getting 27.

Last 3 performances were the ones that were judged mst partially.

Shaleen and Daljeet perform well each time, but it doesn't mean that you do not mark them down when they have not performed well. Shaleen was unwell, still he managed to perform, daljeet did many mistakes. Thr were no expressions on her face, co-ordination, and mismatch of original and artificial faces. Moreover concept was not clear. Similar performance was done by Raakhi Sawant and Abhishek in NB3. There concept was completely clear and in sync. This one was confusing. Still they got 26. They didn't deserve more than 24. Extra 2 point can't be for sympathy because shaleen was not well but he performed as he had to. Daljeet had the problems. Shilpa and Abhijeet too had the same issue but bcoz of shilpa he didn't spoil his dance, then why being partial to them??

I feel that they are not real life jodi. Shaleen when asked if they are seeing each other said the place we come from waha gf-bf nahi hota, then why does Daljeet throws herself on his during the show. she hugs him, holds him tightly, puts her head over his shoulder and frequently kisses him. Come-on ppl grow up, if you love you dont need to show off.

Coming on next, Naman and Megha are really working hard and within no time they will take over shajit as they hv votes as well. They performed fantastically on Saawariyan and did alot more than just a dance. They deserved 29 coz thr dance was very well executed. Farah Pointed out so many mistakes for co-ordination for which they lost 3 marks. Pls judges ko last week ka show dikhao when Arjun said that shajit's dola re performance had co-ordination problems but still got 30?? Please tell me guys why there marks were not cut??

Kapil and Anjali were at the top with 28 where as they deserved a 30. They had created an ambiance of Rajasthan with their dance on Holiya main ude re gulal. there was a lil problem with their co-ordination and step which was avoidable. Arjun's reason was silly of not giving them 10 as he expects more out of them, Common refer to the above para Mr. Charming. The act of anjali standing on kapil's shoulder, i m sure Farah won't be able to do then why not one bonus point for that. Karishma had no reason to cut their marks and therefore was the only1 to gv them a perfect 10. Anushka chose kanjali and Namegha for the dance pe chance, but they were not able to do it properly.

Last but not the least, our Hosts. Hiten is always a pleasure but her wife's attitude is torture. She was Talking to Anushka, with her face towards the camera!! Also there is no smile on her face, she literally shouts on the mike and calls her husband with wrds like iska, isko, iski.. common, this looks so cheap. Hiten on other hand respects her so much by using word like 'aap'. Gauri ke liye 1 line-" Maa baap ne kuch nahi sikhaya bus bhej diya😆". please hiten, Aap hi kuch sikhado apni gauri ko.

Farah, Arjun, I respect you both alot. please stop being partial, or be strict to every1 equally!! otherwise publi ki sunogi n chilloge, toh abhi time hai, sambhal jao..



I totally agree
... naman and megha always get told the same thing and marks get cut off.. coordination problems..... but it is actually quite hard to do mirror images of each other....and maybe the stick was heavy megha is a girl so maybe it was a bit more difficult for her to use the stick... if they got a 28 this time then last time when they did classical they should have got 30 because farah said that there were not mistakes and gave them a 9😕.... and arjun always gives the same points as farah!

and what you said about shaleen daljeet ( which i have highlighted) is also true....
and i also agree with the hiten and gauri thing ... she never smiles and always has the same expression i said the samething last week.

and dance pe chance the four of them didn't do sucha gud job.. but out of the four of them i thought naman was the best.

just my opnion no offence to anyone

Edited by krutiv100 - 16 years ago
desicrowd thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#10

Teen Taaliyan for your analysis 👏👏👏. Excellent. You said some of the words that were exactly what I wanted to say for long. Judges have been favoring Shaleen and Daljit for long. No doubt they perform very well, but their marks are never cut for any mistakes. For Dola re apart from their coordination problems cudn't Arjun see that Daljit was not lip synching whereas Shaleen was. Didn't they point this out to other jodis that either both do it or both don't lip synch. C'mon Judges be fair. Naman and Megha are definitely improving. Also for the last elimination no doubt Chetan and Lavinias dance seemed better but it didn't have any dance steps for godsake whereas whatever lil Abhi and Shilpa did it atleast had some steps. what are these judges looking at. I like Kapil and Anjali too, atleast they don't butter the audience and judges with their words. Even they are from a conservative family but they didn't have to tell the sudience ki hamare yahan girfriend ka funda nahi hota. I felt that was uncalled for, and I agree how Shaleen and Daljit said they are not fast and don't like the girl friend boy friend funda, but don't behave the same. Its hypocrisy. And yeah others agree or not Shaleen does have attitude problem. As for Hiten Gauri, c'mon dude this girl is from Mumbai and Mumbai mein aisaich Hindi bolte hai.

Would also like to add that this season why are the choreographers not given enough footage. When the jodi is eliminated they don't even bother to tell the name or call their choreographer on stage. Very bad....
Edited by desicrowd - 16 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".