Naagin 5 - Take 10 - Page 12

Created

Last reply

Replies

131

Views

6.9k

Users

17

Likes

244

Frequent Posters

Manoshono thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 5 years ago

Originally posted by: forest_foliage

How does Jay know that Naageshwari killed herself for him ? It seems that Jay is neither Hriday nor Aakesh. You're right, when Jay recalled his past life it looked as if it is a third person watching everything from a distance. Was it actually Hriday who died or was it someone else ? Did Aakesh really die after being bitten by Naageshwari ? Sara jhol Satyug mein hi hua hai, makers have to show a lot of flashback scenes to lend logic to the present lifetime equations of Jay, Veer & Bani.

Either way, this is the story of Veer & Bani, of the Cheel & the Naagin.

Omg! This actually crossed my mind couple days back. Akesh toh I don’t know, but I felt Jay isn’t even Hiriday. All those flashbacks that Jay and Bani saw when they were together. They reminisced about their past together & hugged. Maybe later they might show that it was only Bani who saw it and Jay just played along.


Experienced with an Ekta show. She loves to torture fans by keeping the leads separate. Hope this isn’t too much of the case with Veer and Bani. I love separation and misunderstanding if it makes sense & only let the characters & couple grow with their nuances, making the leads come even stronger with their relationship.

forest_foliage thumbnail
5th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago

Originally posted by: Manoshono

Omg! This actually crossed my mind couple days back. Akesh toh I don’t know, but I felt Jay isn’t even Hiriday. All those flashbacks that Jay and Bani saw when they were together. They reminisced about their past together & hugged. Maybe later they might show that it was only Bani who saw it and Jay just played along.


Experienced with an Ekta show. She loves to torture fans by keeping the leads separate. Hope this isn’t too much of the case with Veer and Bani. I love separation and misunderstanding if it makes sense & only let the characters & couple grow with their nuances, making the leads come even stronger with their relationship.

Ekta uses very predictable motifs in order to indicate the lead couple - the bridal dupatta which Bani threw away landed on Veer, so yeah ! That was a more than obvious hint.

I've thought about it - what if both Hriday & Aakesh have reincarnated as a single person in Kalyug..!? Could be. Makers didn't explore Hriday's character much in the Satyug track, there are high chances that we haven't even seen the real Hriday.

Midnightsorrow thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 5 years ago

I would be glad if Jay isn't the real Hriday and the real Hriday is someone else.


Jay could be someone who's after Naamani and been playing Bani along. He's alot cleverer than we think he is, He cooked up this story to get close to Bani because he's aware of her being Adi Naagin, Also the mandir sequence only Bani was having flashbacks Jay wasn't, and he screamed Naageshwari was kinda fishy like all of this seems pre-planned.

libran90 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 5 years ago

Originally posted by: Rein123

He said that just to irritate her.

I think so too!

libran90 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 5 years ago

Originally posted by: Rakhi0796

Gautam is too cute to be single or a side kick 🙃

I am not too sure whether Gautam will have a gf or not. Kyunki jodiyan to Cheelo se ban chuki hai, and uska sign sangeet me mil chuka hai.

libran90 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 5 years ago

Originally posted by: Rakhi0796


Yes shivanya was bad ass naagin no wonder it was on top


But naagin 2 main usse bhi bevkoof dikhya and so she he got killed but being the bad ass she was she out witted the enemy and made the believe she is shivangi

Nahi lekin ek galti to maaf hoti hai bhai. Throughout the season Shivanya was a badass naagin being a positive one. So, yes to me Shivanya was the most badass. And 2nd season she rectified herself, to protect her daughter. After that season, all Naagins went downhill, they were duped or manipulated or killed and took rebirth. Adi Naagin is also a victim of something similar. But I guess this life is her time to show some badassery to all the Naagins, just like "Naam hai mera Shahenshah" types.

libran90 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 5 years ago

Originally posted by: forest_foliage

Yeh Satyug ki wajah se sab raita faila hua hai, itna confirmed hai at least that Bani is Adi Naagin's reincarnation. Bas. Baki kuch nahi keh sakte. And I don't take TC spoilers lightly because they always post correct details, for instance, that one spoiler which said that Bani & Jay will join hands to kill Veer, and it did turn out to be right. Even if makers show that Veer is Hriday's reincarnation, I want to see how they justify it.

Raita Satyug me nahi faila hai, raita to Kalyug ka hai. Satyug jitna simple tha, Kalyug utna hi complicated hai, jalebi ki tarah gol gol.

If I think about Aakesh, then I have to rewatch his scenes, to understand ki Kalyug me Veer ki tarah, iska bhi to koi twin nahi? Aur agar nahi hai then, Aakesh ko twin me split to nahi kar diya in Kalyug? And Aakesh ki achai ko justify karne ke liye, was it so necessary to show an evil twin in Kalyug. And if they want to show Veer as Hriday, then how will they justify all those moments when he appeared shady and dishonest.

Coming to Jai, if he is Aakesh, then why is he Aakesh? Aakesh was a straightforward lunatic barbarian, who fell for Naageshwari. He was not a complex character and his villainy was also suiting the personality of a cheel. Manipulation and playing games wasn't his thing. How can they show that with Jai?

So Jai can only be Hriday and Veer can only be Aakesh. Only there is a lot of mystery surrounding both characters which needs to unfold to understand who is what.

Edited by libran90 - 5 years ago
forest_foliage thumbnail
5th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago

Originally posted by: libran90

Raita Satyug me nahi faila hai, raita to Kalyug ka hai. Satyug jitna simple tha, Kalyug utna hi complicated hai, jalebi ki tarah gol gol.

If I think about Aakesh, then I have to rewatch his scenes, to understand ki Kalyug me Veer ki tarah, iska bhi to koi twin nahi? Aur agar nahi hai then, Aakesh ko twin me split to nahi kar diya in Kalyug? And Aakesh ki achai ko justify karne ke liye, was it so necessary to show an evil twin in Kalyug. And if they want to show Veer as Hriday, then how will they justify all those moments when he appeared shady and dishonest.

Coming to Jai, if he is Aakesh, then why is he Aakesh? Aakesh was a straightforward lunatic barbarian, who fell for Naageshwari. He was not a complex character and his villainy was also suiting the personality of a cheel. Manipulation and playing games wasn't his thing. How can they show that with Jai?

So Jai can only be Hriday and Veer can only be Aakesh. Only there is a lot of mystery surrounding both characters which needs to unfold to understand who is what.

Yes you're right in your analysis. The makers have very clearly established Veer as the reincarnation of Aakesh, they have also given him the same dialogues, there's no coming back from it now. Jay has also been shown as the clueless Hriday but here lies the mystery, whether he was actually Hriday or if there's another twin theory in Satyug as well. I'm game for any sort of twist only on one crucial condition - that VAni should be together.
Sowmya_SMfan thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago

First of all, I really appreciate your effort in posting the review. Your way of explaining every minute detail and your pov on each scene is appreciable. Bravo and keep it up. This is first time I am commenting on your post as it is I am newbie

Here is my pov on the show

I have not seen naagin series before, so I don't know any Ekta kapoor background story about naagins and cheels. I am just watching this because of Sharad. I am big fan of Sharad Malhotra.

The story is little confusing for me as I am newbie to naagin series also. They are dragging the story so fast which is making viewers confused. Just in few episodes veer wanted to marry Meera, bani and Jay remembering their past , bani proposed Jay, Roka , Sangeet, veer or teer killing Jay and bani killing teer the twin. So it is getting hard to digest. Logically there is no death for naagins and cheels as they are immortals. No knife or something can kill them. They will be reborn in kaliyug only if they get curse. One more blooper during flash back scene is nageshwari has "Nail polish" on her hand. How on earth can satyug have nail polish🤔.

From my pov there was no twin before , it was veer who was obsessed with bani, involved with Noor etc . I think in the last minute they introduced twin to make an exit to Jay and to increase TRPs. I really hated flash back scenes during Vani scenes. I just want to see Vani whole time but flash back interrupts them.

I don't understand why Jay character is so dumb and weak. He is a naag, can't he fight for himself? Everytime he needs naagin to save him or support him? In satyug too he didn't save himself and in kaliyug too. The whole Mathur family is dumb and over acting ki dukaans. Sister and brother reaction to his naag Roop is funny. Why the hell he has to use his naag Roop to drag his sister to save her from falling fan. He can drag her directly. His Dadi coughs only during veer and bani interaction as if it sarcastic cough.

I saw so many of you irritated with veers obsessive. But what about bani? She is more obsessive in killing veer. I don't understand why? She already took revenge by killing aakesh in satyug. Why she is still inclined towards killing veer without any reason. There was a dialog in the end of the episode "sirf itnise baat kaliye tumne Jay ko mardiya" when veer says he angered me. Isn't she doing the same. Even during the Sangeet her eyes were only on veer than Jay. Her love towards Jay is less compared to her hatred towards veer. I feel eventually she will love veer.

I love veer character , he doesn't hide anything whether it is love or hatred. I love the dialog where he says after touching poisonous mehendi."Jo BHI Karta hun pura Karta Agar nafrat ho yaa Pyar" he is exactly right. From the beginning he is obsessive and spoiler brat. I saw some were saying veer crossed limits during Sangeet. And said he is groping. He was not groping ,his way of touching her was little indecent. First of all he is not human,second the way he was brought was bad, third he was the villain and every villain acts like that. He will change after marrying bani. Everyone knows including tapish about their human trafficking business except veer. Why because he is a nice person and doesn't like such activities. So we should forget what happened in the Sangeet and be happy veer will be nice after marriage. I feel tapish is the one who released teer.

I also feel veer marrying bani is to save her from his father. If father gets to know that bani killed teer than he will kill her. Maybe but I can't Ekta Kapoor mind.

Coming to cast, everyone is doing excellent job. First my rockstar Mr handsome Sharad . Ekta has given him the right name in Kasam Mr handsome. All in one ,handsome with enormous talent. His eyes are magic. He is a multi talented. He is doing tremendous job as veer. If Sharad wouldn't have played this character with perfection then the show would have seen more criticism and hatred from all viewers. He is the soul of the show.

Then comes Surbhi she is very beautiful. I have never seen her shows before. But she is also doing great job as bani. Initially I didn't like her acting especially when she emotes angerness. But in the last episode especially during fight with twin, she did full justice to the emotion. Her acting is getting better as the show progresses. I like Vani as couple and looking forward for their Shaadi .But I don't like the costumes of bani and also Meera during Roka and Sangeet. They are little bit exposing.

Mohit is good and looking handsome in the show. He just have to gain some weight , I hope he does during his break. And coming to his acting, he is good in his own way. Because on the other side it's Sharad who is synonymous for perfect acting, people are not liking Mohit. For me all television actors are the best than the so called Bollywood actors.

A part from the trio, I like chachi, she is doing excellent job. Her character is extension to the character she played in kasam. Hamari "sexsphere"😉. Background music is very good. But direction , screenplay and VFX are little bit out of hand.

The low TRPs are not because of cast of storyline as promoted by haters because last episode on Sunday I saw even people from India are watching live on YouTube instead of tv. When asked they were saying it is fun to watch online in YouTube. That's why online TRP is good. If we can ban live YouTube only for Indian viewers than the TRP will be good. Live YouTube is for audience out of India who want to watch show but couldn't.

That's is long post . Hope you all accept it forgive me if they are any mistakes or wrong pov.

Thanks

Edited by Sowmya_SMfan - 5 years ago
libran90 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 5 years ago

Originally posted by: forest_foliage

How does Jay know that Naageshwari killed herself for him ? It seems that Jay is neither Hriday nor Aakesh. You're right, when Jay recalled his past life it looked as if it is a third person watching everything from a distance. Was it actually Hriday who died or was it someone else ? Did Aakesh really die after being bitten by Naageshwari ? Sara jhol Satyug mein hi hua hai, makers have to show a lot of flashback scenes to lend logic to the present lifetime equations of Jay, Veer & Bani.

Either way, this is the story of Veer & Bani, of the Cheel & the Naagin.

Exactly, Maine bhi mere take me bola tha, ki ye kaise iske memory flashes aa rahe hai.Tu to tapak gaya tha be, to tujhko kaise pata ki ladki ne there liye jaan li. The flashes were coming in tandem and were not even first -person POV. So were they Hriday's memories? Was there another important character in Satyug who was not highlighted? Bani and Veer still got flashbacks of their respective lives, but Jai. Kahin ye Hriday do-muha Nag to nahi like Vishakha was?? Like in 2 places at once or something like that.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".