The Most Uncalled for Separation - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

31

Views

2.3k

Users

15

Likes

93

Frequent Posters

devilsadvocate thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#21

It was extremely painful to watch...actually any time Mohan is in pain, its difficult for me to watch For some reason Mohan is so real to me (I know I am Wacky like that)...but Since I am a Masochist like Monu I did watch the whole thing 😃

I love Mohan (kudos to Kunal and the writers ā­ļø) But here I want to say something from Nanhis Perspective... She was only Ten, She had heard the horror story of a step father from Renu Via Addu. She tried and tried to make Addu understand that Mohan cares, That Mohan Loves Addu as much as he loves Nanhi and Megha. But Children are so Impressionable, their perspective changes from one Incident to another. A Ten yr Old can hardly be expected to have the Maturity and Faith of an older person. The Doubt and fear within her obliterated all the trust she had for Mohan. Addu Kept Pleading with her that Mohan doesnt Love him. And Look at the Facts, did Mohan expressed to Addu ever that He (Mohan) loves Addu?? Did he Tried to become friends with Addu?? Did he tried to even take the Kid seriously?? Addu's fear of having a step father multiplied and kept building up just because no one reassured him. For Mohan its all about actions, but in Addus case he needed to be more Verbal, more malleable. I am not saying that Mohan never tried...I am only saying that Mohan didnt give his 100% and Nanhi witnessed that. So did Megha...There is Guilt in Nanhi that how did she not believe her Brother?? Is she responsible for him leaving? How can she still love Mohan, inspite of everything that happened?? (Nanhi Loves Mohan, Still does...she is just very hurt and has to keep reassuring herself that she hates him by reiterating it over and over again) Her personal Guilt made her Lash out at Mohan...It was her way of releasing that agony within her...afterall who else could she have unloaded on, but her best and most trusted friend...
About Megha, I dont think it was anything to do with Trust. I dont think it is an issue of her not trusting Mohan, She did. Otherwise she would have Intervened long before for Addu and Mohan to behave cordially with each other. Instead She put her trust in Mohan, She put her Trust in her son to find their way to each other. Just Like Nanhi and Mohan did. She saw how Mohan behaved with Addu and Vise Versa. She didnt like it, But she never said a word to either of them. Because, IMO, she didnt wanted Mohan to feel like he is Addus stepfather. Neither did she wanted Addu to bring up the Stepdad thing to her. Because it is quiet a painful issue for a Mother to deal with. The fear that what if my kids dont accept the man in my life? what if I am responsible for the unhappiness of my child? and Most importantly, did I chose my Happiness over my own child?? She was in pain, she was drowning in Guilt...She couldnt bring herself to be happy with a man who her child left her for...because with or without Addu she would have been happy with Mohan. She knew that, she drove him away coz she was punishing herself...Its a lot of self loathing involved with her.


Mohan: Oh Mohan *sigh* he is so much in pain and he blames himself for Addu leaving too. even though he knows the truth. The guilt of never finding him, and futility of his own failure drove him away from the people he loves...Just like Megha, he is punishing himself in this self inflicted exile. He remembers his own behavior with Addu. He remembers how he never took Addu seriously. How he kept getting hurt by Addus Sautela baap reminders...but the truth is Mohan was Addus stepfather! A relationship between a step-parent and a stepchild has to be treated with care and caution. you have to Woo the child to your side...give him even more attention and care then your own, because this relationship is extremely delicate...you have to build it brick by brick. The relationship between a parent and a child is about faith...its beyond trust...when a dad throws his kid in the air the kid shrieks with delight, rather then be afraid of falling, because he has complete faith that his father will catch him. Mohan did try to win Addu, but he never gained that faith...It was largely Manipulated by Renu, but Mohan didnt try all that much to dispel Addus fear either.. In his defense, it never even occured to Mohan, that it would be so difficult to win over Addu, Since it was so easy with Nanhi, he thought he will win over Addu as well...and maybe his personality is such that he never actively tries to win people over... dunno...but circumstances were such that a little bit of thoughtfulness was required on his part.
His mistake, like you said, was leaving Megha and Nanhi. He left Megha and Nanhi...they feel abandoned by him. He meant well, and he is still on his mission, but he left them No matter the guilt and the Pain that came with the Tag of being a Sautela Baap, it was his responsibilty to bear it. Because the Truth is that He Married Megha and Became a dad to these kids. His responsibility wasnt just Addu but Megha and Nanhi also, in his pain and promise he forgot one thing that he is a man with responsibilties. A man provides and cares for his family, even if they hate him for it. That was his job and he didnt do it. Of course, he was in pain and I cant even blame him for leaving, coz like you said, he couldnt see the hatred and mistrust in Nanhi and Meghas eyes. But 12 yrs is a long time...

"I don't know who to blame more but one thing is sure what can be blamed the MOST is "Tag of Being a stepfather" 😭"
I concur!!! Poor Mohan Cry šŸ’”
Edited by devilsadvocate - 12 years ago
smittu thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#22
yes, the storyline of NBT2 is not at all good-- god knows how the channel gave a nod for this storyline :( and even NBT1 was at 1030, I used to make it a point to watch but now its at a perfect primetime and yet am so disinterestd...somehow, unable to digest all thats being shown. 12 yr leap was a blunder --- In NBT2, I wanted to see Megha-Mohan as a happily married couple, nanhi's extended affection as he is her spiderman cum papa, addu's nakhre and ofcourse a junior mohan. The could have brought in a 5 yr leap may be and started by showing a happily couple and the 3 childeren and then gone into the "drama" mode but yahan the start itself is so so wrong.
and Im sure I am not interested in the nanhi lovestory. NBT is megha-mohan ki kahani and now thats been buried and so for me, NBT2 is irrelevant.
Meera_Ka_Mohan thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: adoremevirgo


very nice meera...loved wat u said...nanhi who always understood mohan's perspective where addu is concerned it became difficult for us to accept her sudden outburst that day...

i understand that as heat of the moment...she herself said that she always scolded addu for talking against him...i actually dont blame nanhi for wat she said that day because it was moment of shock for all 3 of them...
but the reason y i cant forgive her is that she even now questions mohan's love for addu...there is no heat of the moment now...

nywys...i think we hv to live with all that has been shown so far and hope to hv lighter moments from now on...



@bold... very true Aditi... Nanhi was a kid then, but now she is a grown up girl... why can't she think wisely?😔

Did you read the RM article... Ashnoor also rightly asked why Nanhi has to hate Spiderman? how can he be responsible for addu's disappearance? She misses being in NBT.😳
whitepearl thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#24
Hi!...Neha, Meera and others ...Long time but your post and discussion forced me to join in again... frankly I also did not like this 12 year separation concept ...first and foremost because it took away all the beauty of NBT 1 which was hopeful and a very positive concept-
A widow can fall in love again;
a heartbroken, wayward man can embrace the bonds of relationships again and,
everything that a child's pure heart prayed for is answered.
I am utterly disappointed that all the beauty of NBT 1 is destroyed and this separation...which is as you have said Neha, is so uncalled for.
Just by bringing another little girl in mohan's life will not make him Nanhi's 'spider man' again.
This Mohan Batnagar can never be the person we all loved.
And what to say about Megha!...Is she really the female protagonist in this show? The show was supposed to be projecting the strength of a widow but sadly she is the weakest character. Does every couple separates who suffers such unfortunate incidences ? What if it had happened in Amar's life time?...So I am not at all happy with this so called logical separation..

And yes not at all happy about the actor choice for Nanhi. ...She is no match to Little nanhi's sweetness, her naughtiness not her anger.

Edited by whitepearl - 12 years ago
Meera_Ka_Mohan thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: whitepearl

Hi!...Neha, Meera and others ...Long time but your post and discussion forced me to join in again... frankly I also did not like this 12 year separation concept ...first and foremost because it took away all the beauty of NBT 1 which was hopeful and a very positive concept-

A widow can fall in love again;
a heartbroken, wayward man can embrace the bonds of relationships again and,
everything that a child's pure heart prayed for is answered.
I am utterly disappointed that all the beauty of NBT 1 is destroyed and this separation...which is as you have said Neha, is so uncalled for.
Just by bringing another little girl in mohan's life will not make him Nanhi's 'spider man' again.
This Mohan Batnagar can never be the person we all loved.
And what to say about Megha!...Is she really the female protagonist in this show? The show was supposed to be projecting the strength of a widow but sadly she is the weakest character. Does every couple separates who suffers such unfortunate incidences ? What if it had happened in Amar's life time?...So I am not at all happy with this so called logical separation..

And yes not at all happy about the actor choice for Nanhi. ...She is no match to Little nanhi's sweetness, her naughtiness not her anger.


Varsha..!!! its really you??? 😲 You r back in the forum? Welcome back dear...šŸ¤— was missing your poems very badly.😳

@bold... same with me... I can't tolerate this actor playing grown up Nanhi😔... but have no choice.

Jabse promos aana shuru huva... from that time we are saying the same as you have said. But whatever may be the story, my concern is only Mohan and I can't see him in pain, and that is what is happening in ssn 2 as well. Why always Mohan has to suffer??😭
whitepearl thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: mohan-sun-na


Varsha..!!! its really you??? 😲 You r back in the forum? Welcome back dear...šŸ¤— was missing your poems very badly.😳

@bold... same with me... I can't tolerate this actor playing grown up Nanhi😔... but have no choice.

Jabse promos aana shuru huva... from that time we are saying the same as you have said. But whatever may be the story, my concern is only Mohan and I can't see him in pain, and that is what is happening in ssn 2 as well. Why always Mohan has to suffer??😭


Love you too dear šŸ¤— Aana hi pada jab likne waale tum jaise hon ho how long can I resist!šŸ˜‰...I was only waiting for NBR 2 to start but yes I am back now...and my poems too. It was really refreshing to see Mohan's reciting one in his thoughts...a beautiful poem.
And about the story, It will only be watchable once Mohan and Megha comes face to face...the sooner the better. Another point is Addu by mow must be 20 years old...Both Nanhi and Adhu will have there story now...Where is the screen space left for Megha and Mohan? What is the scope except reunion of middle aged couple where being together is more important than romancing with each other. I'll miss Mohan's sometimes cute and sometimes intense romantic expressions. And about his sufferings...well CV's have planned to make 'suffering' his perpetual expressions now...😔


Meera_Ka_Mohan thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: whitepearl

Love you too dear šŸ¤— Aana hi pada jab likne waale tum jaise hon ho how long can I resist!šŸ˜‰...I was only waiting for NBR 2 to start but yes I am back now...and my poems too. It was really refreshing to see Mohan's reciting one in his thoughts...a beautiful poem.
And about the story, It will only be watchable once Mohan and Megha comes face to face...the sooner the better. Another point is Addu by mow must be 20 years old...Both Nanhi and Adhu will have there story now...Where is the screen space left for Megha and Mohan? What is the scope except reunion of middle aged couple where being together is more important than romancing with each other. I'll miss Mohan's sometimes cute and sometimes intense romantic expressions. And about his sufferings...well CV's have planned to make 'suffering' his perpetual expressions now...😔



@bold... so true...

Exactly yaar, I so, so wanted to see MM new married life and their cute romance.
😳 But we are not that lucky, Mohan spent in exile for 12 yrs without any of his loved ones with him. Mohan is one unlucky guy in his married life, who with all his good nature is still suffering.😭😭
whitepearl thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: mohan-sun-na


@bold... so true...

Exactly yaar, I so, so wanted to see MM new married life and their cute romance.
😳 But we are not that lucky, Mohan spent in exile for 12 yrs without any of his loved ones with him. Mohan is one unlucky guy in his married life, who with all his good nature is still suffering.😭😭


@ bold...So true...This confuses me too...why did they snatched away the prime of his youth? First he 6 yrs...for rashmi and now 12 yrs for Megha...what an irony! the most lovable and loving person had to spend 18 years of his youth in loneliness and despair...
nb.neha thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#29
@all:
Actually the matter with us is NOT the step father track but MORE related to Mohan's pain. Any reason causing him pain would anger mohan fans. Thats the main reason why we are aggitated.
its a request please dont dislike the show. By liking it we will be passing on positive vibes to the show
nb.neha thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#30
@meera:
Dont be disapointed yaar. Its just a trp gimick. We all should wish thsy it works fr the show so that we can watch fr a much longer period. I to sara dim keep telin ppl i know to watch it... Aap sab yehi karo. I m really liking kunal's look in ssn 2. AS looks so elegant.. Nanhi-- we l hv to accept her jo ki time ke saath ho jayega. I still admire jiji n her faith. Rimjhim id ultra cute. Jus love her scenes with mohan n the way they are bonded.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".