Congratulate Shankar HERE ONLY: Congrats shankar!!! - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

76

Views

15.2k

Users

41

Likes

170

Frequent Posters

musicdad thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#41
Congrats to Shankar. He single handedly took his team to victory. His team while being individualy talented, didnt do enough to garner praise in this event. Their Medleys were always innovative and interesting. Shankar's Sapno se Bhare Naina was the best ever performance I have seen.
I wonder if Shaan's fans can be little more polite and acknowledge that Shankars team won. If Shaan won I would have been very happy too as they as a team did very wonderfully, even though my opinion of Shaan went down a little during this program.
I wonder if Mods will continue to allow so many comments against Shankar and his team members continue like this. Some of the comments are so very rude, I wonder why they arent warned/banned for the personal animosity they are showing.
Every one should remember this is only a contest with ever changing rules and probably fixed too. But in the end what you say and what you do will remain with you only. I hope all these negative posters remember this.
361344 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#42
congratzz cheater.................................................................😉
sudhirm_2007 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#43

Originally posted by: musicdad

Congrats to Shankar. He single handedly took his team to victory. His team while being individualy talented, didnt do enough to garner praise in this event. Their Medleys were always innovative and interesting. Shankar's Sapno se Bhare Naina was the best ever performance I have seen.

I wonder if Shaan's fans can be little more polite and acknowledge that Shankars team won. If Shaan won I would have been very happy too as they as a team did very wonderfully, even though my opinion of Shaan went down a little during this program.
I wonder if Mods will continue to allow so many comments against Shankar and his team members continue like this. Some of the comments are so very rude, I wonder why they arent warned/banned for the personal animosity they are showing.
Every one should remember this is only a contest with ever changing rules and probably fixed too. But in the end what you say and what you do will remain with you only. I hope all these negative posters remember this.

How can we congratulate shankar and his team?? At the begining of this contest the organiser told us It will be decided by public votes.. Shaan was continuously getting highest votes.. and at the end in the final day he got maximum votes acc to the rule he is the winner but when we ; sent our opinion our votes to our fav contestant they have changed the rule and declared Shankar is the winner they will take only that days performances and studio audience will decide who is the winner even no judges were there...totally ignored us. ignored public opinion . This is clearly they cheated us.. so we cant congratulate such person who won the trophy by this way.. shame shame Gajendra singh and Star plus..
Edited by sudhirm_2007 - 15 years ago
archie76 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#44

Originally posted by: somone999



Everybody seems angry that why did Shankar had to win..had Shaan won the match, people's opinion would have been a lot different i think..

I think the basic thing was to win this PARTICULAR match, because the scores were leveled, Shaan's team got leveled with Shankar's team because of audience vote.. the entire scene depended on this particular match which was a fair and square one, there was no judge, it was just the audience. So, it was a fair win according to me.

I am a huge fan of both Shaan and Shankar, for me both were already winners, but since Shankar ji and his team have won! so i wish him a hearty congratulations! and best of luck to his team members for the future! 😊

Congrats to both Shankar and Shaan for giving us such good performances....
somone999 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#45

Originally posted by: sudhirm_2007

How can we congratulate shankar and his team?? At the begining of this contest the organiser told us It will be decided by public votes.. Shaan was continuously getting highest votes.. and at the end in the final day he got maximum votes acc to the rule he is the winner but when we ; sent our opinion our votes to our fav contestant they have changed the rule and declared Shankar is the winner they will take only that days performances and studio audience will decide who is the winner even no judges were there...totally ignored us. ignored public opinion . This is clearly they cheated us.. so we cant congratulate such person who won the trophy by this way.. shame shame Gajendra singh and Star plus..



If this was a show where they had to just give the prize to the most POPULAR singer, Shaan would have won it no doubt about it.. but Unfortunately the matter depended upon which team won the heart of the audience on that particular GRAND FINALE night..
if votes would have been the ONLY deciding factor, then what is the point of doing the muqabla?.. It was a fair and square win, just have to show a little sportsmanship to accept the fact that Another team can win! 😊 Cheers!
sudhirm_2007 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#46

Originally posted by: somone999



If this was a show where they had to just give the prize to the most POPULAR singer, Shaan would have won it no doubt about it.. but Unfortunately the matter depended upon which team won the heart of the audience on that particular GRAND FINALE night..
if votes would have been the ONLY deciding factor, then what is the point of doing the muqabla?.. It was a fair and square win, just have to show a little sportsmanship to accept the fact that Another team can win! 😊 Cheers!

Then Why they requested us to send sms? and give votes through E-Mail's..If they have already decided that they will only take Studio audiences votes then why everyone was saying plz send sms.. and Srry to say Shankar is genius and talented singer But his team was weak than Shaan's team.. Shaan's team was more powerful...
usama19 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#47
congracts alot to shankar.bt its nt an honest decision..i knw its prescripetd already..bt frm now onwards i wont be watching any shows.....shaan strikers were deserving..what can v sya..
musicdad thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#48

Originally posted by: sudhirm_2007

Then Why they requested us to send sms? and give votes through E-Mail's..If they have already decided that they will only take Studio audiences votes then why everyone was saying plz send sms.. and Srry to say Shankar is genius and talented singer But his team was weak than Shaan's team.. Shaan's team was more powerful...

Congratulating Shankar has nothing to do with what went on. It is called sportsman ship. A true sportsman will wish the winner no matter how bad the things went against him and look forward to the next event to get even. Shaan and Shankar would never be part of any fixing. If it is done. If at all any fixing is done, it would be done by the shows producers and channel for SMS. That is why I never SMS
It is also called making peace with yourself. You believe you are wronged, but trying to keep this in your heart and continue will only make you less than what you were. Try to be a better person than the other one and that will make you feel better than trying to keep it in your heart festering. Hope you get my message
Never in realty shows all the people are satisfied, not even majority of the people.
Not going into their capacity. I think the winners here benifited by having more fanatical voters than the other side. If 100 people voted 100 times for winner and 1000 people voted 1 time for the runner up, who is the winner? The winner for you is whoever is in your heart.
Challenge 2005: Debo got lot more votes from people in Bengal/Assam. Less people voted more and hence isnt true majority
II 2: Rajasthan voted like crazy for Sandeep Acharya. Minority winning over Majority with more determination.
II3: Nepali people voted a lot for Prashant Tamang. Minority winning over Majority with more determination
Edited by musicdad - 15 years ago
sudhirm_2007 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#49
Never in realty shows all the people are satisfied, not even majority of the people.
Not going into their capacity. I think the winners here benifited by having more fanatical voters than the other side. If 100 people voted 100 times for winner and 1000 people voted 1 time for the runner up, who is the winner? The winner for you is whoever is in your heart.
Challenge 2005: Debo got lot more votes from people in Bengal/Assam. Less people voted more and hence isnt true majority
II 2: Rajasthan voted like crazy for Sandeep Acharya. Minority winning over Majority with more determination.
II3: Nepali people voted a lot for Prashant Tamang. Minority winning over Majority with more determination
Look you are talking about normal reality show where one contestant got less votes than other and other is thinking he has manipulated But here situation is completely different.. Here the winner got less votes .. But he won the trophy.. They have requested us to send sms for the grand finale night raat ko 8 baje tak khula hai .. Ayusmaan was announcing the sms result But finally they didnt grant it , they decided the winner by studio audience viotes.. This is plain cheating and iss se zyada cheating mai kabhi dekha hi nehi..If 100 studio audiences are every thing why did they tell us to send SMS? I am not upset for my money But they clearly cheated us thats why I am upset.. otherwise it doesnt matter Shankar is a great singer musician he can be the winner.. But he won this trophy not fairly.. No doubt Shaan is the real winner ...
Edited by sudhirm_2007 - 15 years ago
somone999 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#50

Originally posted by: sudhirm_2007

Look you are talking about normal reality show where one contestant got less votes than other and other is thinking he has manipulated But here situation is completely different.. Here the winner got less votes .. But he won the trophy.. They have requested us to send sms for the grand finale night raat ko 8 baje tak khula hai .. Ayusmaan was announcing the sms result But finally they didnt grant it , they decided the winner by studio audience viotes.. This is plain cheating and iss se zyada cheating mai kabhi dekha hi nehi..If 100 studio audiences are every thing why did they tell us to send SMS? I am not upset for my money But they clearly cheated us thats why I am upset.. otherwise it doesnt matter Shankar is a great singer musician he can be the winner.. But he won this trophy not fairly.. No doubt Shaan is the real winner ...



would like to paste one of my previous posts to clarify your argument.

As Ayushmann clearly clarified that the finale had three portions..

1. The Pre-finale Match
2. Audience Voting
3. The Grand Finale Match

Shankar's Rockstars won the Pre-finale so They got 2 points.

Shaan's Strikers won the Audience Voting, so They got 2 points.

So, it was a tie.. Now the deciding factor was the result of the Grand Finale Match, which Shankar's Rockstars won.. So, that is how it was concluded..

I don't think the votes were wasted, as the votes made Shaan's team formulate a tie with Shankar's team.

Anyways, this is entirely my opinion. Others can agree or disagree as they like. Thanks.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".