javed akhtar has lost it!

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

kingofdevil1

@kingofdevil1

Explorer

Posted: 15 years ago

#21

Javed saab is always biased as judge. And he is very close to shankar ji. he thought that he can only save Shankar ji in the final. LOL 5 marks.. I hope he soon leaves Hiindi fiml industry where he gave entertaining scripts and now he is talking against entertainment. How hypocrite ...

Medley may not have the most difficult songs, bt if it has a message told in a simple way, thats wht matters. JA missed that point. wht an uselss opinion.. He kept his mouth shut whn Shankar came against Anwesha.. ISn't that unfair?

Shaan you rock for giving us teh best songs, and today again proved that on a team basis and singing basis. SHankar team cannot perform or compete against shaan's team... 3 points deficit thats too Shankar ji came for them.. 😆

I am sure if any of Shankar team wud have come against Anwesha, then different wud be bigger.. may be 4- 5.- 6. who knows.

Jeetenge Shaan se..

Quote

redapple1

@redapple1

Voyager

Posted: 15 years ago

#22

Originally posted by: navaneeta

Nopes ... Javed A has a attitude to humiliate bengalis .... I saw it earlier so many times .... Shaan being a bengali fas gaya ....

I don't think it has something to do with from which part of country you come from. Shaan's medley was good. Even I was surprised by JavedJi's comment that is was desperate attempt to entertain. Also I noticed Javedji gave bad marks to Rahul and Neeti's performance. He wasn't impressed with it at all. May be some people will like that performance. For me that song was ruined with the improvisation. I prefer the original one.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

greygoose

@greygoose

Beginner

Posted: 15 years ago

#23

Originally posted by: rocky25
I think Javed akhtar looked jaded on the show and was ready to pick up a fight and ended up hurting Shaan and his team!

Me thinks javed akhtar has really lost it!😍

tata,

rocky25😃

In USA we get this very late, am watching Guru's episod aka post semi

Can wait to watch it next week

Javed ....hmmmm wat can i say otherwise I will be called racist and modretor may delete my comment....but he is not very nice human being. Have seen this all in Indian Idol

so what Javed did would not bother me but i heard on blog that ShankarJi again sang opposite Anwesha....... is this true? pls someone say NO coz wat lil respect i have for him will be gone.

I feel sorry for Shankar's team coz he doesnt trust them or not think they are good enough to compete agaisnt Anwesha? Before this show started i had big respect for ShankarJi which is far less now and also Shreya... cute, sweet and best singer but after show my impression of her is of Shankar's pet.. still love her though

Being honest i think Shan's team has much better singers including Shaan than Shankar's team and I truly hope people in India vote for SHAAN and show JavedMiya that people know more than him abt Music

Quote

Orpita

@^orpita^

Voyager

Posted: 15 years ago

#24

this guy was always like that when he was in other musical show he used to judge but he used to rather insult them for nothing .. this old man has lost it completely a long ago , thats why gajj called him so that me can create more drama and for nothing issues and fights 😡 🥱

Quote

Orpita

@^orpita^

Voyager

Posted: 15 years ago

#25

Originally posted by: greygoose

In USA we get this very late, am watching Guru's episod aka post semi

Can wait to watch it next week

Javed ....hmmmm wat can i say otherwise I will be called racist and modretor may delete my comment....but he is not very nice human being. Have seen this all in Indian Idol

so what Javed did would not bother me but i heard on blog that ShankarJi again sang opposite Anwesha....... is this true? pls someone say NO coz wat lil respect i have for him will be gone.

I feel sorry for Shankar's team coz he doesnt trust them or not think they are good enough to compete agaisnt Anwesha? Before this show started i had big respect for ShankarJi which is far less now and also Shreya... cute, sweet and best singer but after show my impression of her is of Shankar's pet.. still love her though

Being honest i think Shan's team has much better singers including Shaan than Shankar's team and I truly hope people in India vote for SHAAN and show JavedMiya that people know more than him abt Music

Yes dear, for ur red marked line the ans is "yes" 😛 he again sang opp of Anwesha 😆 and i think in future epi we will see him singing alllllllllll the songs by himself 😆😆😆 donno why he has a team though 😆😆😆 he doesnt need it u know and also he doesnt have much faith in them 😆 😉 btw Shankar really sings well and his non happening team members cant sing, so its better if he will sing allllllllllll the songs 😉😆😆😆

Edited by ^orpita^ - 15 years ago

Quote

seema

@mumbai80

Voyager

Posted: 15 years ago

#26

I have lost complete respect for Mr. Javed Akhtar......he should be banned from any competition as he's lost his credibility for good! His behaviour was disgusting and distasteful....he misbehaves with most people these days...needs to see a shrink ASAP!!!!!

Edited by mumbai80 - 15 years ago

Quote

hikamosa

@hikamosa

Inactive

Posted: 15 years ago

#27

I lost respect for all four judges . Javed for giving less mark deserved and other for giving more than marks deserved.

Quote

ashok

@laugh6666

Inactive

Posted: 15 years ago

#28

I guess last nite Pre finale & my Comments as follows:-

1) Javed akthar just wasn't rite on his judgements atall.

2) He just wanted his presence to be felt on the show

3 He is forgetting that he is just a writer/lyrcist and not a singer or musician.

4 He was just taking undue advantage of his seniourity being an old man.

5) Other judges were not oposing him only out of respect.

6) In my view he shudn't hv been cald in the first place.

7) Hope he is not present in the finals, & if yes, then not as a Judge.

8) My suggestion to JA is that he shud restrict himself to wat is gud at ( I.E. Writing)

And Lastly i Guess, I have better ears than him as an artist/amatuer semi classical singer.

LITTLE ANGEL ANWESHA ROCKS!!!!!!!!!!!!

Edited by laugh6666 - 15 years ago

Quote

somone999

@somone999

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 15 years ago

#29

I am shocked and amazed to see people condemning the great Javed Saab in such bad words. shows out a lot of things to me about things. well done people, you all are great than him, outstanding. 👏

Whatever Javed Saab said is valid for me and i do not consider myself even a little bit great to say anything against his decision. because he is one of the most learned, experienced person in the industry. I have great respect for Javed Saab and his critical outlook on the things definitely made me appreciate him more.

It was definitely right to have a critical analyser among this jury.
Because You know in American Idol people always boo Simon Cowell because he is too critical about the performances. But eventually, everyone waits for his comment only and people prefer to listen just to his judgement instead of the other jury members. WHY? because they know that he is fair in his comments and analysis. He will be valid and will bring out points for his justification.

Anyways, Javed Saab is so above all the people in terms of his experience in music judging. He is not just a Lyricist, he is a music critic as well. Please have some respect for the legends of your country. Thanks.

Quote

-swati-

@-swati-

Navigator

Posted: 15 years ago

#30

Originally posted by: navaneeta

Nopes ... Javed A has a attitude to humiliate bengalis .... I saw it earlier so many times .... Shaan being a bengali fas gaya ....

This is not true, In indian idol 4 he was supporting torsha an average bengali singer for I don't know what reasons..so cannot genneralise about bengalis

Quote

1 2 3 4 5 ... 7

Javed Akhtar

javed akhtar has lost it! - Page 3

Related Topics

Explore Topics