Aamir says lyrics are not important

Raghuraj thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#1
Recently there was a heated argument in a meeting of a committee to look into amendments to copywright act for music.Aamir was of the opinion that a song becomes popular becoz it is filmied on famous hereos and Javed Akhtar gave him a fitting reply that "Papa Kahte hai ne aapka carrier banaya kya aap us time pe aap famous the kya". Finally the conversation got heated.
Here is the full story:
After a direct confrontation with veteran lyricist Javed Akhtar over the importance of actors in making a song popular, actor Aamir Khan has decided to resign from the 10-member committee looking into proposed amendments to the Copyright Act.

In his resignation letter sent to HRD minister Kapil Sibal (a copy of which is with NDTV), Aamir has made it clear that he's hurt by recent developments. "Sir, I take great pride in my honesty and integrity, and attach an enormous amount of value to my sense of justice and fair play. Monetary achievements have never excited me. If they had, I would have acted in many more than one film a year, thereby being financially much richer than I currently am. Had I been driven by monetary achievements I would not have produced films that challenge the mainstream and break new ground, films like Lagaan, Taare Zameen Par and Peepli Live, that most producers would hesitate to produce. I believe that what I have earned is the love and respect of my colleagues and my audience. And this I have done through my work and through the manner in which I work. This is why such public attacks are most damaging to me emotionally and leave me crippled," he writes.

A war of words had reportedly erupted between Khan and Akhtar at a meeting between producers and writers over the issue of royalties. Taking the side of the producers, the actor is believed to have downplayed the role of lyricists in making any song popular. According to him, the star on whom the song gets picturised is what really matters. It was a stance that didn't go down well with Akhtar, who hit back by labelling Aamir's 'contribution' as 'interference'.

There have been serious differences of opinion in Bollywood after the Union Cabinet on December 24 last year decided to approve the proposal to introduce a bill to amend the Copyright Act, 1957 according to which writers, musicians and lyricists are entitled to royalty for commercial use of their work in films. Producers had objected to the move, saying it violated the way in which the film industry worked. According to them, it was a practice to pay composers lyricists on a contractual basis, regardless of how their compositions performed. They would consider paying royalty only if those demanding it also shared in the commercial risks of filmmaking.

Faced with stiff opposition from certain quarters of the film fraternity, the Government had set up a panel of experts to examine the issue and submit a report. Besides Aamir, others on the panel include producer Mukesh Bhatt, lyricists Javed Akhtar and Prasoon Joshi, music director Vishal Dadlani, script writer Anjum Rajabali, director Vishal Bharadwaj and music companies T-Series and Sa Re Ga Ma.

Insisting in his letter that he had been prevented from making a 'meaningful contribution' to the panel, Khan said he had no option but to ask for his name to be removed from the panel. "I feel I have a lot to contribute to the ongoing debate but I cannot make any meaningful contribution in this atmosphere. Aggression of this type leaves me feeling very disillusioned and sad and I am unable to function. Therefore I request you to accept my resignation from this committee and please appoint another person in my place. I believe that amendments to the Copyright Act are long overdue and I am so happy that a person like you is spearheading this movement," the actor concluded.

Created

Last reply

Replies

23

Views

3.3k

Users

15

Likes

21

Frequent Posters

xobile thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#2
What is the big deal in giving lyricists a fair royalty, Aamir? Even you claimed royalties for 3 Idiots, even though you weren't the producer.

And writing DOES contribute to the success of a film. If stars could carry off any script and make it a hit, then Kambakkht Ishq, Main aur Mrs Khanna and Kurbaan would not have flopped. The fact is, a well written script cannot make money without sufficient star power, and a star cannot give a hit film without a well written script.

It is very arrogant of Aamir Khan to think that a star's contribution to a film deserves royalties AND high fees, when lyricists and writers deserve neither. He says he doesn't look out for monetary gain, then why is he so stingy when it comes to paying the artists because of whom his films do well? Would Rang De Basanti have been a hit with a different script? Were the songs of Jaane Tu Ya Jaane Na a hit because of Genelia and Imraan Khan and not the music+ lyrics? How did Amitabh Bachchan's Boom flop-was he not a big enough star?

Aamir must be embarassed that his moneygrabbing nature has come out for all to see. If your argument was strong, Aamir, you shouldn't have run away from the panel like this!
Edited by xobile - 15 years ago
luvmusic thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#3
I am also quite disheartened to read reports of Aamir saying writer's contribution is minimal!! For God's sake....you can make a person understand either if he is totally ignorant or totally knowledgable, one cannot make him/her understand if he/she is acting ignorant!!!
I am totally with Javed saab's anger....he had done it in closed walls which came out in public, but he denied saying anything publicly....itna toh izzat Javed saab ne rakkha....
How can Aamir say that?just look back at your own career and songs Aamir....
Raghuraj thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#4
Javed Akhtar's anger is justified and it seems Javed Akhtar feels that Aamir is doing it intentionally.
brahmabul thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#5
What on world has gone wrong with Aamir? One of the most absurd comments I have heard from him. If he thinks lyricists are not important then why does he needs someone like Prasoon Joshi to write songs for his film. And there are plenty examples of songs which are big hits despite being picturised on debutants.
simi_1 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#6
Hmmm, wonder why they do Music release of the movie songs months before the movie is released
musickimasti thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#7
Very disappointed by Aamir. Brilliant actor but two mega success has gone into his head.


vasamv thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#8
Take the example of Aamir's own film Tare Zamin Par.The song Ma was picturized on a debutant child star,yet it was a hit.Did lyrics not play any part?Why did music directors of old times got to Shahir,Majruh,Shailendra,Anad Baxi,Gulzaar and other great poets if lyrics were not important?
Javed Akhtar wrote lyrics of Lagan,anothet Aamir movie.
(Sorry for previous blank posting)





7
desicrowd thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#9
highly disappointed with Aamir, love him as an actor, but this is not correct. A song is a hit cos of the music direction and the lyrics. A flop movie with an unknown starcast can also have a hit song.
kingofdevil1 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#10
Amir is a great actor and film maker, but during these days he is talking lot of rubbish.

1st it was Chetan Bhagat issue, now with lyrics issue. I dnt knw whts wrong with him. he is my fav actor but his opinions about other things are worthless for me now. Earlier I was interested about his stands on like Narmada issue and etc.. but now, i think he is over estimating his judgements.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".