New rule of tie ??? forcing Shaan to loose 1 point - Page 2

Originally posted by: navaneeta

Not exactly .. Shreya and Shankar's match diff was .05 and it was told that it is less that 1, hence round off and tie ....

In case of Shankar and Himesh, difference was .35, still they announced Shankar as winner ..... and today when the difference was .20, it was told any diff < .5 would be round off ... yeh naya rule kaha se aa gaya .... pehele se kiyu nahin bole the .... Shaan ke against me jaane ke time naya rule .....

Not justified

Originally posted by: navaneeta

Don't worry ... Harshit will be back with a bang ... 10, 10, 10, 10 ... and 10 ....

I remember similar situation with Harshit in JWWS ... where he was once given a 7, and from the next day he was getting full 10 from everyone .....

Harshit Rocks ....

And also another thought that keeps coming to my mind: Why do you think Shaan would lie low and take any injustice against him and his team? He is not a new comer who needs to establish himself in the industry, on the contrary he is one of the most successful singers of the last decade. He also has a VERY close association with Gajji- going back to the 1990's since when he has been hosting saregama to amul VOI. If all of you think that he is doing that out of his pleasant nature- think twice? Nobody at the kind of professional stature he is at would like to loose- forget out of charity! Have you all forgotten how sharp Shaan was with his displeasure when Shahid sang with Mohit's team? He isnt the kind of person who would lie low and not say a word if he thinks something wrong is happening- unless ofcourse he is doing that for a reason.

Originally posted by: navaneeta

Don't worry ... Harshit will be back with a bang ... 10, 10, 10, 10 ... and 10 ....

I remember similar situation with Harshit in JWWS ... where he was once given a 7, and from the next day he was getting full 10 from everyone .....

Harshit Rocks ....

Originally posted by: snehsharma24

I appreciate everyone's anger incase of the injustice against Shaan's team and I too feel that Star Plus has been changing rules or introducing new ones as and when they want..but there is something I def want to clarify..some of the users have mentioned how the diff between Shankar and Himesh's team was different than in case of Shreya vs Shankar - btu guys the diff between shreya and shankar was 0.5 -which ended ip in a roundoff by the computer whereas that between Himesh adn shankar was 0.05 and still there was no tie- u can look up the results in youtube and u would know why I brought this to light?

Originally posted by: snehsharma24

And also another thought that keeps coming to my mind: Why do you think Shaan would lie low and take any injustice against him and his team? He is not a new comer who needs to establish himself in the industry, on the contrary he is one of the most successful singers of the last decade. He also has a VERY close association with Gajji- going back to the 1990's since when he has been hosting saregama to amul VOI. If all of you think that he is doing that out of his pleasant nature- think twice? Nobody at the kind of professional stature he is at would like to loose- forget out of charity! Have you all forgotten how sharp Shaan was with his displeasure when Shahid sang with Mohit's team? He isnt the kind of person who would lie low and not say a word if he thinks something wrong is happening- unless ofcourse he is doing that for a reason.

Nobody here is ignorant or naive - they all know what they are doing and have years of exp behind them to be manipulated by Gajji. Again, these are entirely my views - i appreciate all the judges and all the contestants cause each one of them has a quality and have worked hard to be where they are today in life, so no hard feelings Shaan fans :)

Originally posted by: navaneeta

Even if Shaan told anything (which we saw .. Shaan telling" Haad hein") ... rest must have been edited .....