This track-effective widout character deviation???

The polls taken on this forum indicate that the majority love this track regardless if it at the cost of the characterisations.

Does this mean that if 'push comes to shove' people will take Rati, Arjun, Mohit, Sanaya over Nupur, Mayank, Samrat and Gunjan?

i agree.....cosidering the fcat the last two tracks have been very glum,they have tried to make everything funny....they manage to do that....but in turn ruin the true essence of the charcter!

Hey naya! thanks for the topic.........

I agree...this same baby track if done without character deviation or without nonsense or forceful comedy....would hv been loved by allof us........
simply think like this.....they found the baby on the road.as a gang who recently deal with eve teasing issue..what was the best thing they can do? they can easily take the baby to police..may be police can give the baby to MN for the time being to take care as the try to find out her parents...now the same fun scene can be shown as the whole gang has no idea how to take care of a baby.& ria.well for me that character was not needed at all...coz none of the gang members is suspected to be the father.rather the gang can be shown trying to search the parents.& finally when they all emotionally bonded with baby,they find out the parents & give her back.some emotional scene....bass done....
this same track..could be loved by all the mjht fans...
i m sorry.for the name of fun, i can't take my fav characters act weirdly & way out of their original self........ then there is no point of loving a characters if the whole characteristics for which they r my fav change for a particular track.......
thanks again for the topic naya.

i agree with u ..if they putted little sense in dialgues little changes keeping in mind the original characters they would behaved ....or will had there dialgues than all would have enjoyed it .......

Well the show has become track centric not character or even story centric....they have been playing with the characters for long....just the recent development in Mayank's character slaying was the last straw...

Somehow the extremely funny Cvs failed to understand that the dignity of a character, its truthfulness, integrity is more important than any "fun" in this world. When it comes to MN the Cvs have always loved to experiment but this time the experimentation has gone a bit too far.

Tthey have a basic lack for understanding human emotions and character and that is how they expected us to accept so much defamation in the name of entertainment. If I was indeed a sadist I would watch WWF or some crappy Reality Show where conscience and ideals are at a toss. Why MJHT?

The makers have got new writers and have submerged themselves in deeper puddles of misery from where they cant extract themselves. As for staying true to the character and implementing the track? Oh Well... they dont know the characters so how will they be true to it?

I have no hopes left on this serial...I have given up.

Anyway thanx Naya for starting this topic, i hardly write in the forum anymore these days.

Regards
Rinky

Firstly thank you for this post if only because I got to read your and Rinky's wonderful thoughts and opinions. How can I grow if I am only ever lost in my own thoughts?

Two issues arise in my mind.

ONE. If you hold to be true, what I stated in my last post, that ultimately people will choose the actors over the characters, then

Will these character deviations ever reach a point whereby those actors will become tainted in these people's eyes?

TWO. My most important point, in my opinion.

If the tracks pull the characterisations along, are the means of their growth and thereby the advancement of both, then viewers are readily able to accept 'new' deviations in character even if they seem to push the boundaries. However only if they stem from an original form, proof or principal already witnessed in an earlier manifestation of that character.

Case and point. Mayank Sharma as a husband. Most Mayurians were against the wedding track, and feared how this would firstly affect the 'youth' spirit of the show but secondly and more importantly how it would impact upon the characterisations of MN and their burgeoning relationship.

However to the surprise of many a Mayurian, Mayank Sharma the husband was a pleasant surprise. The way he handled Nupur's anxieties and troubles, were quite unlike Mayank Sharma the boyfriend. He was more relaxed, straightforward, and very much less volatile.

This 'sudden' change was easily acceptable to us because its roots could be found in Mayank Sharma the good son. The manner he talked matters/troubles over with his mother not unlike the manner he talked to his new wife. The manner he played with his mom (eg New year's party, when he 'ran' home to surprise her) not unlike the manner he surprised Nupur with a TV)

The manner he indulged his mother's noks jhoks/filmy allusions, the manner he entertained Nupur's request for pre nuptial agreement.

The roots and proofs make plausible the new character of Mayank Sharma the husband from his different personification displayed as a boyfriend. My only criticism would be that I would have enjoyed seeing the character of Mayank Sharma 'angry young man' boyfriend for a little more time before he blossomed into this destined role of husband.

However with this baby track we have been given Mayank Sharma the clown, court jester, the Lothario which have no roots in Mayank Sharma history. No roots means no conceivable growth or base for development.

In conclusion I agree with you Naya, a ludicrous track can be forgiven if the characterisations hold true but not vice versa.

Case in point, the ending to the eve teasing track. No embodiment of Mayank Sharma would ignore Nupur in such a horrid state.

i luv ur post!well said!!!!

RESERVED

(hi friends thanks everyone for your reply...
I have read all your comments but i m just a bit busy so i ll come back later and post a reply here)