Created

Last reply

Replies

75

Views

7.6k

Users

30

Likes

242

Frequent Posters

JennyPenny thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Elite Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 15 years ago
#41

Originally posted by: mads



jen...thats a question even I wud like an answer for .. anybody who wants to giv us any answers ?? 😳😳

I kno sum members here had opened a post sum days back saying tht they wanted the track to end and tht they shud message the MJHT CVs n stuff .. I remember coming across such a post a few days back ..



This was a track which people could have identified with as well this ws a track where Actors could have shined.

Sanaya will now go back to being a prop kept at a table and why show her recovery? Don't handicap people live lives normally??
JennyPenny thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Elite Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 15 years ago
#42
What's not to like about this track??
xaviara thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#43

Originally posted by: DiyaS



Rinky, last week I did feel they were developing the track well, by showing Nupur's way of handling JD by using brains rather than temper, and Gunjan getting so scared for Nupur ... and I felt the way this track would go would be by showing BOTH the sisters taking the lead - Nupur using her intelligence and wit to outwit JD and gang, and Gunjan standing up and speaking out - both essentially developing the strong points of the other -

but the quick finish has totally put paid to those hopes and now I'm pretty sure we'll just see a fairly filmy dramatic end to the track, with the "bad guys" going to jail or and the main issue - eve teasing relegated completely to the background.

And I agree with mads, what I would have liked was an all woman show - Nupur, Gunjan, Suhani, Dia leading the girls, even facing lathi charge and the police standing there helpless saying we can't attack girls, and JD fuming impotently ...

And my objection is not because Gunjan is my favourite. It's because there WAS a message to be got across - that victims of eve-teasing can also stand up and fight back, even if they are are weak or timid as Gunjan - and I think cv's have lost a golden opportunity in delivering this message. At the least, Gunjan could talk to the media and give her statement - along with some questions - if Valentines' day celebrations are against Indian culture, are eve-teasing, acid attacks and rape a part of Indian culture? Are we to passively accept them and not fight back? Is this the message being passed to the youth of today - that to celebrate friendship and love is uncultured and 'ashleel' while to accept rude and vulgar remarks from strangers, to accept that girls today are unsafe travelling to work and study, is acceptable and is a celebration of the supreme self-sacrificing nature of Indian womanhood? I would really have liked to see some punchy hard-hitting dialogues especially from Gunjan, and some strong messages being sent on such an important issue.




Diya thank you so much !!! U said everything I wanted to in this post of yours !! I was among the few people who wrote to CV's in the past week regarding this track, asking them to show this track from the POV of a girl who has been a victim of such a huge crime like eve teasing. And it didnt matter to me that the victim was Gunjan, had it been Nupur, Diya or Suhaani, i still would have asked the same thing.

To be honest I lost all hopes once I read the article about the political track and i knew the eve teasing track was doomed already !!! In the end the political track didnt work and the social message which was shown in the show was that the girls who are victims of eve teasing, are helpless, cannot fight for themselves, should be subjected to pity, and are burden to their familes if they want justice for themselves !!!! Wow what a beautiful message to the youth today !!! Gunjan has been through so much, so we didnt ecpect her to go and fight, but all they had to do was make her strong enough to atleast testify against yash and get adhi out of jail. Nups could have outwitted JD and Yash later on !!

But making one character do everything, they have made a mockery of the entire issue !! Because like mads said, not everyone has a elder sister, or a boyfriend to support nher or fight her battles !! Is thatthe message they wanted to show ?? That you cant get justice if you dont have a sister like Nupur Bhushan ??

It really saddens me that all this was done because some of us wanted the college masti and the romance back. This could have been a beautiful track, but it has been mad into a complete joke !!

mads thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#44

Originally posted by: jenny1000



This was a track which people could have identified with as well this ws a track where Actors could have shined.

Sanaya will now go back to being a prop kept at a table and why show her recovery? Don't handicap people live lives normally??



totally they do jen .. and thats why I was soo glad they showed gunjan's character and strength inherent when she learnt abt her paralysis ... but since gunjan is the heroine, she wil eventually recover .. I m keeping my fingers crossed for tht track ..
mads thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#45

Originally posted by: jenny1000

What's not to like about this track??



I guess all the politics got a bit heavy for everyone .. but they failed to look at the essence behind all of tht ..
awsumgirl thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#46

Today's epi was going like a jet speed it's just because of majority of the ppl were not liking the track but I think that this track had a potential..I have been enjoying this track..

I was exited about this track but the whole track is ending so soon.After watching today's epi, It seems CVs are really in a hurry to end it soon.Even Rati mentioned in TB article she has also been enjoying the track and she liked the track alot..During this whole track the trps are so high and MJHT once again became no.1 on star one channel..

*Reemz* thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#47
Well I hope people don't start complaining if there is no growth in the characters. If they all go back to acting as if nothing happened and start playing holi in a carefree way then what was the point??

I've learnt my lesson. Sirf romance se kuch nahi hota...! But this is what the majority amount wanted apparently so.....

And Rati fans, this was her favourite track so far!!
Edited by *Reemz* - 15 years ago
mads thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#48

Originally posted by: *Reemz*

Well I hope people don't start complaining if there is no growth in the characters. If they all go back to acting as if nothing happened and start playing holi in a carefree way then what was the point??

I've learnt my lesson. Sirf romance se kuch nahi hota...! But this is what the majority amount wanted apparently so.....

And Rati fans, this was her favourite track so far!!




@ bold : but that is whats gonna happen now reemz ... I mean, majority of them wanted to hav the college "masti" back .. so thats what they are getting in the name of the holi party ... and this serious issue is again made a mockery of ...


Edited by mads - 15 years ago
aj_observer thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#49
@ all who are wondering why the show is ending..here is the article link that explains...
And I know...this forum specifically reacted very severely and bashed the executive producer of the show left right and center and actually took pride in it....There were celebrations on this forum that this track got ended...people self represented as the voice of MJHT and asked the CVs to end the stupid mindless non-masti track...
I am stating the obvious....everyone knows this and people rejoiced...
I have no qualms with the CVs...I said this many times...in the given time , with epis already shot...there is little they could do to end it sensibly.... let alone characters grow and change....
I guess Holi celebrations are important than a track that has some real life bearing....Go figure...
I will never understand this forum....
we never raised our voice not to end the track but we are objecting that they ending the way they are.... is it not quite impossible to satisfy everyone's desires because they have their obligations to meet as well....
before we pounce on them....please think about it...WE ended it actively or passively.... now we have to see what is being shown...
I am not trying hurt anyone or instigate...this is the truth and we all have seen it...I am just saying it out loud....
Mods...please Pm me if this is a problem post...I will edit it...I am not trying to cause trouble...I am tired of the fact in this particular scenario the CVs are being held responsible not the viewers...
@Rinky...reagarding speed...how else would they proceed....Holi is coming up....very important for another musical dance number with full on masti and tali gang.... who cares Gunjan is in wheel chair.. sajan are going through the issues.... Nupur gets near killed and mayank is never respected....hey hey...Holi cures all problems...
I wish I had holi every week in my house...
viggy123 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#50
And the sad part is that whoever bombarded the creatives with negative feedback about this track claimed to represent all of IF.

I'm sorry, but I don't need representation. I can speak for myself, thank you very much! And shoddy editing aside, I loved this track. It's been the most realistic track in MJHT so far.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".