Warnings Being Issused - RULES BROKEN. READ NOW! - Page 2

Originally posted by: drsamita

u r missing the point again.😳.majority was not with the fact that everything is always perfect majority was with the fact that one doesnt need to loose the grace n use harsh terminology to get a point thru.msg can be conveyed in a soft manner too..n this is not restricted to forum i thinks it applies every where one doesnt need to shout n bang to get a point thru...

yah i read.. only few posts of appreciations in the early pages😊

I think you're the one missing the point😳😳.....All I saw in those posts were claims that 'true MN/MJHT fans' are the ones who are always only saying how much they love and appreciate PD.....and how there were ppl spreading 'negativity' in the forum just by happening to point out VALID points about the nonsensical things being shown in the show. This is a FORUM not a FANCLUB😳

And I guess appreciation doesn't count if it's in a few posts only then?😆

I can see this is the end of this discussion then. Nice talking to you😊

Originally posted by: nureat01

I think you're the one missing the point😳😳.....All I saw in those posts were claims that 'true MN/MJHT fans' are the ones who are always only saying how much they love and appreciate PD.....and how there were ppl spreading 'negativity' in the forum just by happening to point out VALID points about the nonsensical things being shown in the show. This is a FORUM not a FANCLUB😳

And I guess appreciation doesn't count if it's in a few posts only then?😆

I can see this is the end of this discussion then. Nice talking to you😊

yes it was an appreciation thread whts wrong with appreciation n showing some love😊...yes appreciations get washed away if u fill hundred pages of strong words n only few posts of love. there were words n slang used in FS which is sad n will remain if it continues in the future too ...

nice talking to u too
regards.stay blessed😳

Originally posted by: nureat01

And didn't PD herself ask for HONEST feedback? If that happens to be criticism, it's not welcome?? Only glowing praise is welcome all the time? If this is indeed a forum where everyone is free to voice their opinions, constructive criticism is part of that and PD HERSELF asked us to be honest with her I believe....and that is all that was being done.

Originally posted by: SidraLuvMayurBL

exactly! we are asked to give honest feedback - that is wht we did..she herself accepted that criticim is justified!😕and the creatives are not some oversenstive kids who need pacifying with positive threads every time a criticism is made😕

sorry for wtiting this here creatives, but i haven't said anythign abtthis issue till now, so i just had to say this point once!😊

Well said, Sidra👏👏👏 Especially agree with the part in blue👍🏼

Originally posted by: drsamita

yes it was an appreciation thread whts wrong with appreciation n showing some love😊...yes appreciations get washed away if u fill hundred pages of strong words n only few posts of love. there were words n slang used in FS which is sad n will remain if it continues in the future too ...

Originally posted by: SidraLuvMayurBL

FS is for showing appreciation and love for the creatives drsamita..we have done that many times n the past..as for them getting washed away - i think that only shows what the majority thought at the time...eh?? when epi's are nice, when things are hopeful, then appreciations never get washed away...🤔

when a track is going beyond hope, when ppl r so frustrated..i think it makes sense to point out flaws in the track rather then JUST appreciation...and creatives are professional enough not to take our criticisms personally😊

abt harsh criticisms..i think anu exlained it all..so im gonna leave that point😉

well every one saw wht happened that day n y pd had to leave the FS thread n answer in the other one

..about using slang n filling pages n pages of strong words ..i think development team should themselves read the previous FS threads themselves thoroughly n decide........everyone has their own way of expressing views i guess some chose to use slang n angry words which left her hurt ..anyway..i'll still stick by my words criticism doesnt need to be packaged with harsh language.. n that too with so many pgs😊.
..
have a good day all😳

Originally posted by: drsamita

yes it was an appreciation thread whts wrong with appreciation n showing some love😊...yes appreciations get washed away if u fill hundred pages of strong words n only few posts of love. there were words n slang used in FS which is sad n will remain if it continues in the future too ...

Originally posted by: nureat01

And didn't PD herself ask for HONEST feedback? If that happens to be criticism, it's not welcome?? Only glowing praise is welcome all the time? If this is indeed a forum where everyone is free to voice their opinions, constructive criticism is part of that and PD HERSELF asked us to be honest with her I believe....and that is all that was being done.

@Kanika: Well said yaar! I totally agree!


@Soneha: Exactly! When PD herself is admitting to having gone wrong with the MN track, then how is it wrong for us to raise this point in the forum?? :S We are giving HONEST feedback as we were asked to, that's all.

I can't believe HONEST Criticism is being termed Bashing.. Watching the show and praising is not what she wanted.. She wanted honest feedback so we give it to her.. and she appericate it when she wrote her big post for us.. and even in my PM, she told me that she was a bit hurt as she did not expect so much negative reaction from us but she realized their mistakes and are working on it.

Maybe you guys might want to read PD's answer to it.. She was a bit hurt, but not offended.. She heard us out completely and we heard her completely.

PD never mentioned us as BASHING, She said she will work on our demands. If we were bashing, why did she come back to FS thread??

We give her honest feedback, we demanded and those T-shirts are coming back on popular demand, the vest is being brought back, etc.. WHY?? Because we had the courage to sit there and give honest opinions and not budge.. The TRP's are low... But if they fix the track, they will be up in no time.

We didn't criticize just and forget to thank her or appericate her... We appericated many times, but sometimes you have to harsh to get the best out of something.. Sugar Cotting might have made her feel better for a short time but eventually, PD came to FS thread and She posted there again, so that should tell people what the reality is..