lovely_lady thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#1
So firstly, I'm not an avid follower of this show. As such, my opinions may be completely off base and I apologize LOL. If so, please let me know I'm off base and correct me! Onto my post

I've seen a lot of posts being angry with the way Shivam and his sisters treat Riya, the way Kaushalya treats Riya, etc. And while I do agree with them, I also kind of disagree with them? I think Shivam is 100% wrong in the way he treats Riya when it comes to his mother/ her adjusting. But at the same time, I was wondering, with the environment he's grown up in, does he even know how normal couples function? All he's ever seen is his dad blindly following his mom and his dad getting angry at his mom for the littlest things and his mom taking it. As kids, we imitate what we see. He grew up in this environment. So naturally, he's emulating it. He blindly supports his mother and gets angry at his wife for the littlest things. It's kinda like how when kids witness domestic abuse growing up, they tend to emulate that abuse when they get older, despite knowing that it's wrong. And so while his actions are completely wrong, are they completely his fault? Or was he failed by his parents/ family growing up? Of course I don't mean to say that he isn't at fault for her incessant shouting on Riya, lying to her, etc. But that expecting him to be a supportive husband would be a little unrealistic as he hasn't seen that I think.

Riya has grown up in a liberal family who has self-respect and isn't belittled all the time. She's confident, she's educated, she's loved and has support.

Contrast this to Kaushalya. She apparently married Raghav when she was a teenager and for over 20 yrs, has had to put up with Shanti. From her current behaviour, it's very clear that she clearly believes that Shanti does care for her in her own way and that she isn't being mistreated. Or rather, she doesn't see anything inherently wrong with the mistreatment. She's grown used to the abuse she's been subjected to. She doesn't see anything wrong with it. And so when Riya tries to pull back the blinds Kaushalya has worn and tries to show Kaushalya the truth of how Shanti mistreats her/ is evil, it's painful and she doesn't want to take off the blinds. It would mean that her entire existence would be gone. She only knows how to serve Shanti (or at least that's what she thinks). Not to mention, just like Shivam, I don't think Kaushalya knows a different life? She's obviously a very meek person and isn't as confident as Riya. So standing up for herself is not even something that exists. Isn't she also a by-product of her background? So expecting her to change in a few days/ weeks is unrealistic. The change should take at least a few months.

So I think while the characters are annoying and frustrating to watch, I also think that they are somewhat understandable in their actions?

Created

Last reply

Replies

1

Views

691

Users

2

Likes

3

Frequent Posters

DollBeans thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
Agreed but you need to see the marriage episode
Shivam stands for Riya against his family & Amit-Riya's marrriage,

Riya rejected Amit & declare that she loves Shivam,,,Though Shivam never proposed her, but still she expressed her feelings that incident is enough for Shivam to realize that Riya always speaks what she fell with her own opinion. & Shivam support her at that time as even he loves her.

Riya said she will adjust with Dadi but Shivam never said she need to adjust that way his mom is adjusting by putting self-respect aside.

Shivam being unreasonable,,
He said dont inform me anything from next time during nimmi's loan time & now he is questioning Riya why she dont inform him about Sarla's cancer drama,,,😕


Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".