~| Whatever you want to argue about |~ - Page 99

Originally posted by: FlauntPessimism

I have written the same in my last post about 4 Krishnas

Arjun is hardly referred to as Krishna so why is his son called Krishna's son? If they wanted to highlight relations between Abhimanyu n Krishnaji it could be Krishna's nephew, beloved, student why Krishna's son?

Why was Abhimanyu called the heir by Satyaki even in front of Pandavas and no one objected to it? Why not Prativindhya?

Why was Parikshit made the king and not Prativindhya's son?

The things are not as simple even here

I could make out of it , I read somewhere Yadavs were planning 2 win indraprastha in absence of Yudi & Pandavas , they would had wanted someone from Yadavs to be d acting heir thou prativindhya was crowned prince but as Yudi & draupadi were in exile , I don't think he was supposed to sit on throne .

Originally posted by: HearMeRoar

If there was doubt Abhimanyu being called Son of Krishna was not about Arjuna:

When he of Vrishni's race said so and presented such a cheerful countenance, Draupadi, repairing thither with great speed, addressed the daughter of Virata, saying,--'O blessed lady, here comes to thee thy father-in-law, the slayer of Madhu, that ancient Rishi of inconceivable soul, that unvanquished one.

https://www.sacred-texts.com/hin/m14/m14068.htm

No my point was isn't the Sanskrit word for father in law Shwasur? Even Uncle in law would be called Shwasur right?

Originally posted by: deepikagupta9

I could make out of it , I read somewhere Yadavs were planning 2 win indraprastha in absence of Yudi & Pandavas , they would had wanted someone from Yadavs to be d acting heir thou prativindhya was crowned prince but as Yudi & draupadi were in exile , I don't think he was supposed to sit on throne .

Why can't Prativindhya sit on the throne? His parents were in exile not him.

Nothing says that a person whose parents are in exile can't reach the throne.

Prativindhya wasn't the crown prince. Bheem was the Yuvaraj. But still being Yudhishtir's son, he should have been the next in line to the throne, why Abhimanyu n not him

Originally posted by: FlauntPessimism

No my point was isn't the Sanskrit word for father in law Shwasur? Even Uncle in law would be called Shwasur right?

Not only sanskrit in general also uncle in law r refer as sasur only . I remember when after marriage I was introduced to my extended family members in muh dikhayi ceremony , my paternal or maternal FIL were introduced as FIL only to me by MIL

If abhimanyu is Krishna's son then who is the mother

Originally posted by: Lazybird_Silpa

If abhimanyu is Krishna's son then who is the mother

Yehi to sawaal hai.

Originally posted by: FlauntPessimism

No my point was isn't the Sanskrit word for father in law Shwasur? Even Uncle in law would be called Shwasur right?

I think maternal uncle by marriage was simply called maternal uncle. Matula. Mamashree might be a modern invention.

Husband wouldn't call his father's brother as father (pita). It would be pitrvyah

Svasuro is husband's father, not husband's uncle.

https://www.2indya.com/2009/02/10/sanskrit-names-of-relations/

Originally posted by: deepikagupta9

Not only sanskrit in general also uncle in law r refer as sasur only . I remember when after marriage I was introduced to my extended family members in muh dikhayi ceremony , my paternal or maternal FIL were introduced as FIL only to me by MIL

Yes in Hindi Sanskrit Indian languages I meant

This point therefore isn't a big support to the claim. But why is he called Krishna's son no just once but multiple times

No where in entire mahabharat it's mentioned draupadi or subhadra were not able to give birth to children

Abhimanyu birth is already clear his paternity regarding upandavas I don't know why vedvyas dint mentioned their birth in detail but still draupadi was capable in giving birth why will she go 4 adoption .

Abhimanyu's one name is saubhadra also .

Please take note:

Subhadra is portrayed with open lotus, a symbol of fertility, while Panchali is portrayed with closed lotus. Draw your own conclusions.

Another point: the name Karna calls in dice hall is "bandhaki." We assume it means courtesan, but it can also mean barren woman.