Mahabharat Episode Discussion Thread # 16

First Previous

Page

118

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Srishti

@srishtisingh

Voyager

Posted: 11 years ago

#531

Originally posted by: AnuMP
One more thing- did Shakuni really say victors decide history and dharma?

Now am not certain who CVs are with 😕

yeah this thing kind of surprised me that from starmb cvs

Quote

Diala D

@...Diala...

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

#532

Originally posted by: bheegi
Shalya is being true to his character from the epic- demoralizing Karna although they haven't shown that Krishna instigated him to use that as a tactic to unnerve Karna from his goal

Please.. 😭 Krishna has enough glory.. This glory belongs to my Yudi.. 😭

Originally posted by: AnuMP

PS- wasn't Karna decapitated? How did he end up in Mata Kuntis lap then? Did the twins somehow reattach his head? 😕 😆 Definitely need negative Patiyogita points then 😆

Real Arjun had nothing for Karna so he beheaded him.. but our ⭐️Ju inspite of being bhai do anjanae has that special purv janm bandhan feeling so his arrow just wounds him with a 30 mins timer set for death..

Originally posted by: amritat
By the way, where is Bhima?
Was he taking rest, after killing Dushasen? Or did he have indigestion after drinking his blood, and so remained at the camp?

He dint drink the blood.. may be he got a day off with ladoos after reaching 99% of his target 👏

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Diala D

@...Diala...

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

#533

Originally posted by: AnuMP
One more thing- did Shakuni really say victors decide history and dharma?
Now am not certain who CVs are with 😕

seems you missed the Lakshagriha planning.. he said the same.. but the CVs expect us to understand that, had adharmi Dury won the war, he would have written his own history.. but not dharmi pandavas..

Quote

AnuMP

@AnuMP

Rocker

Posted: 11 years ago

#534

Originally posted by: ...Diala...

<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif" color="#006600">seems you missed the Lakshagriha planning.. he said the same.. but the CVs expect us to understand that, had adharmi Dury won the war, he would have written his own history.. but not dharmi pandavas..</font>

I thought the implication here was that Pandav side did this 😕 . This statement along with the reminders about Ghato vadh and KK daan

Quote

luv_sakshi

@luv_sakshi

Rocker

Posted: 11 years ago

#535

There was one bit that was intense between Karna and Kunti today..the bit where he takes the dagger off her hands and says "Mata"..that came off well between Aham and Shafaq! The rest of it was Melodrama..but i must applaud Shafaq for pulling off even OTT "Rona Dhona" scenes so well..she even manages to look convincing in emotional blackmail scenes! So here's to her emoting!

Must say Aham has done a great job with his bits as well..the intensity, the emotion all there in those eyes and expression...really liked the bit where Karna lashes out at Kunti and in the end pleads her to allow him to do his duty..bound by "Vachan" or otherwise..

I expected a lot more in action between Karna and Arjun on the battlefield..The face-off was great! There's no denying that..the scripts were crisp and both Shaheer and Aham delivered it just as convincingly! But this is war..the biggest Maha Yudh at that! Shouldn't there be more to offer in showing arrows and cannon balls fly around, than just sparks of words all thru'...especially since the CVs intend to wrap up the KaJu war bits in such hurry!

And what is Dury's role in the war? I fail to understand here..ever since the war has commenced, i have only seen him stand, give commands, swear, throw sparks of words, spit vengeance, give grave looks, smirk, express shock..should i even go on?? When do we see him fight? He didn't bother to even try putting up one when Bhim kept killing each of his brothers..i only saw Dury have a go at some poor n battered soldiers and none other..is he only waiting for Day 18?? Even today he was monitoring Karna's fight skills wondering why he wasn't using the Nagaastra and planning to "guide" Karna on that front?!

That the CVs decided to make this Epic and recreate it again is a big task and responsibility in itself! Considering that quite a few who tried their hands at this show failed miserably! This team was definetly one of the best in terms of the Creative content and depiction..yes, we understand they aren't making a remake of the Epic so we will accept their liberty in terms of a few Distortions. yet they have given us some of the most Marvellous scenes and memories to remember from the show! They did do a lot of research on the show and the Epic too..but what happened now??

Why such Major Distortions...such Hurry to wrap up on the most crucial aspects? Why such Character Assassinations? I can't think of any other show on Indian TV that has such a Fantabulous Star Cast!! I mean each and every actor is so Amazing...playing even Distortions to such Conviction...this is by far the Best Team of Actors that has come under one roof..if only they had depicted so many of their scenes in line with the Superb Actors they had...this show would have hit a different peak altogether...a peak that would go unmatched by any other show in the history of Indian TV..so Hat's off to the Awesome Actors of this Epic show!! They Rock it Completely!

Edited by luv_sakshi - 11 years ago

Quote

Srishti

@srishtisingh

Voyager

Posted: 11 years ago

#536

nah diala I can never forget an interview I read before start of mb from either our director or someone related to show that in mb noone is wrong. there is a reason for everything. whether that is big or small that's different. so.our fav cvs despite severely blackwashing dury have given dury a reason for everything done to him.he is a scared boy elwho loves his bros but chides everyone who gives him better advice

Quote

Rehanism

@Rehanism

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

#537

I never expected ⭐️bharat to decapitate Karna. I always knew they would exploit the moment fully to make it as filmy and melodramatic as possible. Also, ⭐️Shalya is cheap and OTT, like most of the things in the show. There's no way this jackass could be appointed CoS. For all we know, he would happily surrender his forces and Duryodhan to his nephews - is it believable that his guy would be prepared to give up his life for Duryodhan's sake in about an hour?

But showing Karna knowingly use the snake weapon and later on threaten to destroy everything with Brahmastra is simply indigestible. Brahmastra was used by both Karna and Arjun simultaneously. And Karna did fight and fend off Arjun from the ground. He was killed much later when he was off guard and unaware.

Few pages back people were debating on Krishna saving Arjun being un/ethical - well it was a part of charioteer's job description to protect the warrior. In real wars often charioteer carried a shield to guard the archer against enemy fire while the archer's hands remained free to shoot. Even Shalya once saved Karna from Bhima's sudden blow. Bhima was able to harass and immobilize Drona and Karna for long hours on 14th day, largely because of an efficient charioteer (most probably one of Krishna's sons), and the same is true for Satyaki. So I don't see anything unethical about a charioteer saving the warrior's life. Personally I imagine Krishna making a sharp turn so as to give his chariot a quick violent jerk, saving Arjun's head by inches (instead of the popular pressing it down with feet).

Edited by Rehanism - 11 years ago

Quote

luv_sakshi

@luv_sakshi

Rocker

Posted: 11 years ago

#538

Originally posted by: -Shani-
How much faith should we have on SBS??

As per SBS, Karna dies on Kunti's lap...

And guess who performs his final rites?? 🤣

Seriously??😲..How did Karna end up on her lap?😆...Nooo!...Don't tell me Arjun performs his Last Rites?!😕😲..On what grounds?🤔

Quote

Diala D

@...Diala...

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

#539

Originally posted by: AnuMP

I thought the implication here was that Pandav side did this 😕 . This statement along with the reminders about Ghato vadh and KK daan

but this part I can vouch for the CVs.. their Pandavas wont do that..

Srish.. I think that interview was given when they had some idea of giving us real MB.. and later they changed mind.. I cant believe they are giving us 'this' message

Quote

Srishti

@srishtisingh

Voyager

Posted: 11 years ago

#540

mayb I am give cvs much credit for than they deserve. I have this doubt because they say this statement so many times that it feels like they are made to not say something wrong abt victors hence try to show their displeasure in this way

Quote

1 ... 52 53 54 55 56 ... 118

Mahabharat Episode Discussion Thread # 16 - Page 54

Related Topics

Explore Topics