-{| SATYASTHA Karna: AHAM Sharma AT#17 |}- - Page 109

Poll

Which kingdom should Karna have inherited?

Login To Vote

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

80.9k

Users

36

Likes

3.2k

Frequent Posters

Vr15h thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail IPL 2024 Participants Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: ...Diala...

glitter text for next AT






Thanks, dears. Next AT is staged & ready!!!



Also, they showed Nakul & Sahadev challenge Karna for a battle. So at least the last 10 pages of this AT can live up to its name 😆
Edited by .Vrish. - 11 years ago
Sabhayata thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: .Vrish.



Actually, there is something else here. While Karna may have always been a danveer, the obsessive aspect of it - not refusing anything asked of him after his evening prayers - wasn't a lifelong deal of his. After the Gandharva debacle, he took an Asura vrath, which included all this. The reason he took that vrath was to redeem his reputation, which had taken a nose dive when he couldn't get Dury freed, but Arjun, on Yudi's instructions, did (the fact that the Gandharvas fought Karna as an enemy and Arjun as a friend is true, but is tangential to this point, since it was pointed out that the bottom line was that Arjun succeeded where Karna failed). Had this vrath been successful, he'd have been successful in killing Arjun. Observance of this vrath included giving up meat & alcohol, never washing his feet, and not refusing anything asked of him after his evening prayers.

However, this vrath was a double-edged sword in that his enemies could use it against him, since he couldn't refuse even them. That's what happened w/ Indra & Kunti. With Indra, he lost the 2 things that ensured that he couldn't be slain, and w/ Kunti, he was forced to give away his right to kill her sons.

The reason he refused to give up on Arjun was that that was the reason that he was doing this vrath in the first place. Were he to give that up, continuing to follow that vrath would have been meaningless. OTOH, were he to bluntly send Kunti away w/ a flea in her ear, then the success that the vrath would have guaranteed him just wouldn't have been there.

So even if Karna may have let Dury down, he may not have had a choice, since Dury did want Arjun's death from him over everything else. Had Dury bound him to a looser contract - "Hey, just kill any of the Pandavas that you can, no strings attached", Karna could have kept his kavach kundala, killed Yudisthir, never have been defeated by Arjun and probably taken his revenge on Kunti by sending Sahadev to Yamalok. Although he would have had to kill Bhima as well to make Duryodhan the eldest of the Kuru princes (not counting Karna himself as one), and given that Bhima had defeated him in the Rajasuya yagna, that may not have been possible.



hmm no the vrat was not after gandharva incident it was after his digvijay yatra

after the karna's digvijay yatra kaurvas perform a yajna which is next to rajasuya since rjasuya couldn't be performed till yudhishtir is alive

then karna says that he will kill all panadavs so that one day dury can preform rajyasuya yajna

then he he says that till he doesn't slay arjuna he will not wash his feet and will never say no to any one

this was more like an oath than a tapsaya i mean it wasn't something he was dong to gain more power to kill arjuna

if that would have been the case then his successful vrat should have ensured his success in the actual battle but it didnt

it was just an oath similar to panchali's to keep her hair open till dushy dies or bhima's to not accept death till he kills kaurvas

similarly karna vowed never to say no till he killed arjuna

the only thing is since he had vowed to kill arjuna he couldn't really spare him when he came to know the truth
Sabhayata thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: TheWatcher

Krishna already planned his death and he told Arjuna about how to kill Karna on the 14th night itself. Krishna already knew that Karna cannot be killed in a fair fight, even when he had donated his Kavach and Kundal.

Here is what Krishna tells Arjuna after Ghatotkatch was slain.

"..The man does not exist in this world that could not stay before Karna armed with that dart and looking like Kartikeya in battle. By good luck, his (natural) armour had been taken away. By good luck, his earrings also had been taken away. By good luck, his infallible dart also is now baffled, through Ghatotkacha. Clad in (natural) coat of mail and decked with his (natural) ear-rings, Karna, who had his senses under control, could singly vanquish the three worlds with the very gods. Neither Vasava, nor Varuna the lord of the waters, nor Yama, could venture to approach him. Indeed, if that bull among men had his armour and ear-rings, neither thyself, bending the Gandiva, nor myself, uplifting my discus, called Sudarsana, could vanquish him in battle. For thy good, Karna was divested of his ear-rings by Sakra with the help of an illusion. Similarly was that subjugator of hostile towns deprived of his (natural) armour. Indeed, because Karna, cutting off his (natural) armour and his brilliant car-rings, gave them unto Sakra, it is for that he came to be called Vaikartana. Karna now seems to me to be like an angry snake of virulent poison stupefied by power of incantation, or like a fire of mild flames.."

Here is what Krishna tells Arjuna to do when Karna's wheel will get sunk. Krishna planned out everything.

"..There win occur one opportunity for his slaughter. When his car-wheels will sink in the earth, availing thyself of that opportunity, thou shouldst slay him in that distressful situation. I will make thee a sign beforehand. Warned by it, thou shouldst act. The vanquisher of Vala himself, that foremost of heroes, wielding his thunder, is incapable of slaying the invincible Karna while the latter stands weapon in hand.."






even during the final battle when karna is taking out his chariot wheel krishna ji tells arjuna to kill karna soon before he gets on his chariot
KHUSHI-99 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
Yesterday they had shown Karna-Nakul-Sahadev fight,I just love the way he looks at his younger brothers [leaving Arjun and Yudi(till now)],Just imagining that if everything would have been normal after war then he would have been a very loving brother to the four.Btw my main point of this post-Karna fought with all his brothers??
NandiniRaizadaa thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: KHUSHI-99

Yesterday they had shown Karna-Nakul-Sahadev fight,I just love the way he looks at his younger brothers [leaving Arjun and Yudi(till now)],Just imagining that if everything would have been normal after war then he would have been a very loving brother to the four.Btw my main point of this post-Karna fought with all his brothers??


yes he would have been a fantastic brother.

yes he fought with all but left them alive

lol yesterday when Sehdev said Mata Kunti yahan nahi hai Kara (Amham's) expression was as if he was half expecting her to appear 😆
lika63 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: Nandiniraizaada


yes he would have been a fantastic brother.

yes he fought with all but left them alive

lol yesterday when Sehdev said Mata Kunti yahan nahi hai Kara (Amham's) expression was as if he was half expecting her to appear 😆

i heard he fought with nakul,sahadev,yudi and won but due to promise dint killed them.he won over bhim also?

some ppl were saying in someother yudh arjun won over karna.karna has same warrior skills that time also na but how he lost to arjun dat time?
Quantum-Dot thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
Gud noon Karnalis...Have a karnalecious Sunday...
Quantum-Dot thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
In yesterday's epi...baby bros want to daand with jhestest...oh wow luv jhestest expressions to his baby twin bros...aham u r truly awesome
Quantum-Dot thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: KHUSHI-99


Yesterday they had shown Karna-Nakul-Sahadev fight,I just love the way he looks at his younger brothers [leaving Arjun and Yudi(till now)],Just imagining that if everything would have been normal after war then he would have been a very loving brother to the four.Btw my main point of this post-Karna fought with all his brothers??

Yupz agree with u Muskan...karn wl be an awesome brother to da 5...
Quantum-Dot thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
where are everyone?? Let's burn this at before evng...it seems im da only one here nw...
Edited by Simantini_M - 11 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".