Ati Maharathi Danver Karna update 1st post/ DT nt pg 14

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

sravanthi vangala

@sravss

Voyager

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

#121

I know when will want to discuss some thing or about someone we don't need a AT we can just discuss in any thread it is after discussing about our fav character.

Quote

-Srushti-

@-Srushti-

Sparkler

+ 7

Posted: 11 years ago

#122

Originally posted by: sravss
I know when will want to discuss some thing or about someone we don't need a AT we can just discuss in any thread it is after discussing about our fav character.

Exactly!! And you guys can help the Two main AT admins in keeping the ATs active!! There are so many character to discuss and we have hardly reached half of the total capacity!!!
Thanks a lot for understanding :)

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

koolsadhu1000

@koolsadhu1000

Stunner

+ 3

Posted: 11 years ago

#123

Originally posted by: sravss
I know when will want to discuss some thing or about someone we don't need a AT we can just discuss in any thread it is after discussing about our fav character.

ok , just label the thread Danveer thread or something and exclusive facts of Karna can be discussed here , no need for AT . 😊

Quote

413226

Suspended

Posted: 11 years ago

#124

Originally posted by: koolsadhu1000

ok , just label the thread Danveer thread or something and exclusive facts of Karna can be discussed here , no need for AT . 😊

Actually I find ATs quite boring . It is better to discuss with a particular incident or theme related to any character .In case of karna there would be many episodes which would call for discussions. Eg - Drona's refusal to teach him, parshuram's curse, disqualification in the competition or swayamwara, and many more. So I agre that people like karna dont actually need to have a single AT 😃

Quote

sravanthi vangala

@sravss

Voyager

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

#125

I updated the name as per few suggestions give to me.Hope its fine.

Quote

Vrish

@Vr15h

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 11 years ago

#126

Originally posted by: mnx12
I have a long list of demand for ATs.
1) Drupad's family AT

2) Krishna's family AT

3) Arjun-Subhadra

4) Arjun- Draupadi

5) Karna

6) Bheem

7) Krishna- Arjun etc.

We can't allow just one, have allow all, which is not possible.

So it's my request to all of you to please understand & start posting about Karna in Kaurava's AT. Even to make K & P's AT a lot of planning & hard work of various member's efforts are included.

Any pics or matter of Karna you want to add, just pm me, I'll add it.

Of the above list, (1) would be meaningless if it would end up being mainly about Draupadi - there ain't too many fans of Drupada, Drishtadyumna or Shikhandi. Krishna's family - Krishna has his AT, and his family hardly plays a role. The jodi ATs - A-S or A-D or even K-A should be instantly dismissed.

But I disagree w/ the decision to allow an individual Arjun AT - it throws up the question that if Arjun can have it, why not Bhima? It's a misjudgement to state that Arjun is the lead of this serial - he's a very important character, but by no means the 'lead'. He could easily be adequately covered in the Pandava AT, and there's no need for a separate AT for him.

Quote

-Srushti-

@-Srushti-

Sparkler

+ 7

Posted: 11 years ago

#127

Vrish, now denying Arjun an AT would open a Pandora box. And that is why the suggestion thread was put. So that everyone can come to an amicable solution.
And we have. So let us just do with whatever we have😆
And the misjugment lies with the makers, we can't help it...
The ATs are made according to the show and not the original MB...because of that had been the truth, Ved Vyaas ji was the true hero...but in here there is no Ved vyasji😆

Edited by -Srushti- - 11 years ago

Quote

Vrish

@Vr15h

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 11 years ago

#128

Originally posted by: candidfrisky

Hopefully it should because Karna is neither mentioned in Kauravas AT nor in Pandavas AT so we are planning to name this thread as Ati Maharathi KARNA AT #1 😊

I have added Karna, as well as Kripacharya, Vidura, Balarama & Krishna to the Kaurava thread. However, if Krishna belongs in all the ATs, Karna certainly belongs in both the Kaurava & Pandava ATs. For plotting w/ Duryodhan & fighting alongside him, he certainly belongs to the Kaurava thread. However, certain things he did - like asking Krishna to keep his secret so that he doesn't have to give away Yudisthir's kingdom to Duryodhan, expressing regret over insulting Draupadi, his encounter w/ Kunti & his promise to her, his sparing the lives of Nakul & Yudisthir, and finally, his funeral, which was an all Pandava affair - those things ought to be covered in the Pandava AT.

Aside from that, it's okay to cover him separately. Note that there are 2 criteria for putting someone in an AT:

His family relationships e.g. Ambalika was listed in the Pandava AT due to being the mother of Pandu. Similarly, Abhimanyu, Ghatotkacha, would appear there afterwards
Which side they fought in the war. So people not related to them, such as Satyaki, would be covered there

Most characters, such as Drupada, Virata fall under both, and would easily go into the Pandava AT. There are 3 characters who would fall in one AT under one rule, but the other under another rule. Karna & Shalya were 2 characters related to the Pandavas, but fought for the Kauravas, whereas Yuyutsu, despite being Dritarashtra's son, fought on the Pandava side. IMO, these 3 could be covered in either AT depending on the context.

The kid Karna was not covered in the Kaurava AT - Karna's coverage in the Kaurava AT starts now, since now is when his alliance w/ Duryodhan has started.

Quote

-Srushti-

@-Srushti-

Sparkler

+ 7

Posted: 11 years ago

#129

Vrish...Karna can be discussed in Both ATs...but as a character he was to go in Kaurava AT...But I guess we can add him in Pandava since we are adding all everywhere😆