Why does Madhubala (Season 2) fail?

soapbubble thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago
#1
Ok, first I know I'm going to upset many people with my comments but I wanted to think this through for myself.
I used to watch MEIEJ religiously. I started leaving it around the time they brought Pabho in - and though I wanted to watch Madhu's rise to stardom, I couldn't BEAR those idiotic conspiracies.

I came back when I heard buzz that this story was going to end - and was quite heartbroken when RK and Madhu died. But I was willing to give their daughter and the new story a chance. I was willing to see Gunjan Utreja play a new hero. I was willing to see the same story told differently. But sadly the whole thing flops badly.

Why?

The creatives.
Apart from the fact that they laid the ground for the handover - they didn't do it neatly enough. They didn't grieve properly over RK Madhu - they didn't let us say goodbye properly.

The new cast is overweighed with villains and negative characters. There is nothing POSITIVE to look forward to. As for Leelavati's torture of Madhu 🤢 who's going to hang around for THAT?

The plotline doesn't have too much tension between the leads. The dialogues sound boring, the situations are blah, the villains are not amusing or engaging.

Gunjan Utreja/AK
He looks ok
He acts not great but there is room for improvement.
His character has NOT been outlined well.
Apart from grieving over old wounds, there is no spark to AK. He's not heroic, he's not funny, he's not attitude-y... he's boring. Apart from loving his Bebe and falling for every emotional trick known to TV villains, there is NOTHING to the character. He simply doesn't come across as a hero.

Vivian took over the character of RK and made it larger than life. He was nasty, menacing, loving, shrewd, manipulative, emotional - a range of delicious shades.

GU has not managed that with AK. The character is underwritten and the actor doesn't have the confidence to make it his own.


Drashti/Madhu

But the single most important factor for the Second Season not working, IMO, is frankly, Drashti.

Ok, Madhu Jr is not glamorous but must she be quite so foolish?!! The look was ok, but they are overdoing the deglam thing! Drashti is hunched up all the time and it's grating on my nerves.

The character doesn't have the wit or edge of her father, or the spunk and loveliness of her mother.
And although Drashti is a tragedienne par excellence, her skill at comedy is ABYSMAL. No timing, no genuine amusement and those spectacles!!!😡

And Drashti is so bent upon doing this new role well, she forgets to look into the eyes of her hero and has forgotten how to generate chemistry!! I can't believe how THANDA they are together. I had to switch off my TV in embarassment yesterday at the holi 'so called' romance.

So, now added to all this, the production house has split. Whither now, Madhubala?

Bubble

VB note: The disclaimer has been edited. Please check the forum rules for further clarification.
Edited by -Misek- - 11 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

56

Views

13.3k

Users

27

Likes

119

Frequent Posters

sangeet6690 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
completely agree vd u..IMO its not just GU its DD as well..her character instead of being funny its irritating..she was great as geet n muskan but here her character is too dumb..stating that she is a small town girl doesn't justify her clumsiness..small town girls are much smart n worldly wise
soapbubble thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: sangeet6690

completely agree vd u..IMO its not just GU its DD as well..her character instead of being funny its irritating..she was great as geet n muskan but here her character is too dumb..stating that she is a small town girl doesn't justify her clumsiness..small town girls are much smart n worldly wise


Yeah, that's what. GU is not great but many actors improve as the shows go on - they become more comfortable.

But this Madhu is too irritating. Agree that it's the writing and direction at fault.
kajal99 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: soapbubble

Ok, first I know I'm going to upset many people with my comments but I wanted to think this through for myself.

I used to watch MEIEJ religiously. I started leaving it around the time they brought Pabho in - and though I wanted to watch Madhu's rise to stardom, I couldn't BEAR those idiotic conspiracies.

I came back when I heard buzz that this story was going to end - and was quite heartbroken when RK and Madhu died. But I was willing to give their daughter and the new story a chance. I was willing to see Gunjan Utreja play a new hero. I was willing to see the same story told differently. But sadly the whole thing flops badly.

Why?

The creatives.
Apart from the fact that they laid the ground for the handover - they didn't do it neatly enough. They didn't grieve properly over RK Madhu - they didn't let us say goodbye properly.

The new cast is overweighed with villains and negative characters. There is nothing POSITIVE to look forward to. As for Leelavati's torture of Madhu 🤢 who's going to hang around for THAT?

The plotline doesn't have too much tension between the leads. The dialogues sound boring, the situations are blah, the villains are not amusing or engaging.

Gunjan Utreja/AK
He looks ok
He acts not great but there is room for improvement.
His character has NOT been outlined well.
Apart from grieving over old wounds, there is no spark to AK. He's not heroic, he's not funny, he's not attitude-y... he's boring. Apart from loving his Bebe and falling for every emotional trick known to TV villains, there is NOTHING to the character. He simply doesn't come across as a hero.

Vivian took over the character of RK and made it larger than life. He was nasty, menacing, loving, shrewd, manipulative, emotional - a range of delicious shades.

GU has not managed that with AK. The character is underwritten and the actor doesn't have the confidence to make it his own.


Drashti/Madhu

But the single most important factor for the Second Season not working, IMO, is frankly, Drashti.

Ok, Madhu Jr is not glamorous but must she be quite so foolish?!! The look was ok, but they are overdoing the deglam thing! Drashti is hunched up all the time and it's grating on my nerves.

The character doesn't have the wit or edge of her father, or the spunk and loveliness of her mother.
And although Drashti is a tragedienne par excellence, her skill at comedy is ABYSMAL. No timing, no genuine amusement and those spectacles!!!😡

And Drashti is so bent upon doing this new role well, she forgets to look into the eyes of her hero and has forgotten how to generate chemistry!! I can't believe how THANDA they are together. I had to switch off my TV in embarassment yesterday at the holi 'so called' romance... I'm not seeing the show. but feel very happy after reading these lines.

So, now added to all this, the production house has split. Whither now, Madhubala?

Bubble

PS. I'm not from any camp, so this is not meant to be bashing, ok? Just a fan's puzzlement over a serial gone wrong.



very well written 👏
Snehal23 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#5
about dd exactly my moms word deglam avatar is good for sometime but ab toh haadhe hogaye hai leap ko almost 1n half month hogaya hai n still cvs continuing her look😡n that specs jisse dd ke beautiful n magical eyes jisske tareef srk jaise star ne god gifted eyes aise ke the unhe eyes ko cvs yeh specs ke peeche hide kar rahe hai n what happen with story leap se pehele show filled with negativety n after leap story negative se comedy circus ban gaye hai. bas dd ke acting👏yeh ek he aache cheez bache hai show main have to say shes giving her 100% n she deserve better phs i liked dd in bubbly roles but geet is better than this jr.madhu
silverfire thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#6
very well written. Fully agreed with u. madhu jr. just irritates us nowadays. To show her clumsy n dumb in every epi is disgusting. stopped watching the show of late. DD certainly deserves something better than this.
Wahyas thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#7
what a well written post agree wid all ur points n yah jr mb character is evn more irritating then gujjuz...n pliz dont evn towk about chemistry between gujju n dd coz chemistry just happens n not created n now its one n half month but stil the magic doesnt happen then it can never happen in near future as well!!!
k.atrina75 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#8
I completely agree.. i did watch a few epis and few at the repeats... but nothing seems to engage... u domt even feell interested in any scene leave alone why wud u switch the channel the next day... i remember those days when we used to wait the whole day for 8:30 anxiously but now its just u can yawn and sleep during the epi and still u woudlnt have lost track between the segments because its the same since a month.
The only thing who they tried to build up AK's character as Angry is through JM jittering over small things like he would scold or blah blah.. i found him anything but angry or ruthless... ..
He is one hell of mama's boy... jisko jo mann aata hai suna k chala jata hai usey and he just listens to them with painful eyes... and then goes away... i mean.. we are not here to watch the stoy of a stupid any other guy... After RK and even Sultan we get this man... i hate to say but still Sultan used to be much more interesting than AK
Edited by katrina75 - 11 years ago
dash_aryan thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#9

I never use to Miss any episodes...now nothing to hold u...to watch madhu hv to bear the rest which is UPHILL TASK...

bokul thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Master Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#10
mind bowing post
u said it all
u told it so beautifully

Related Topics

Madhubala - Ek Ishq Ek Junoon thumbnail

Posted by: Heja · 29 days ago

Madhubala's character in the series was portrayed as a character who showed mercy even to her well-intentioned enemy. But when I watched the...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".