Its not just abt Sultaan-AR you cant act;[DT Nt Pg7] - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

134

Views

10.9k

Users

58

Likes

355

Frequent Posters

StayStrong thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
#31

Originally posted by: Hi2life

Finally someone said it loud, the one thing most of us already knew, I totally agree


We have dipali as the vamp, we hate her for what she is, the feeling doesn't extend to seema who is a fab actress, both sulthan and AR are total failure,
Completely agree with u



I am not com\paring him with any character or actor here just talking about AR,the role he's playing he had many chances to prove himself as an actor,ofcourse its kinda annoying when a person keep switching to different faces but when finally one comes to know the reality the impact is quite shocking but here the viewers most of them weren't shocked or amazed they were even more annoyed to see the same expressions again and no life atleast to make the scene interesting and worth watching.
StayStrong thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
#32

Originally posted by: rishbalalover

He can't act at all!! I'm tired of seeing his same old expression over and over again... even when he smiles it looks artificial... as if " I have to smile so I'm smiling" 🥱

There is not even a single shade in this character(Sultan) and even that is not being delivered properly by him...
He's just a burden for this show🤢



he wouldn't be a burden atleast if AR could act and the character was making any sense.

Mallu
Edited by swethasyam08 - 12 years ago
Ananya05 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#33
Fabulous post..Agree with every word..👏

Avinesh can't act...😛 . Its a fact. 😛
Edited by swethasyam08 - 12 years ago
DushtDanaf. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#34
nicely said 👍🏼
agreed with your every word
i dont know anything about his last show, but maybe if he would have put some effort behind the role i wouldn't feel so disdainful of his performance, but i guess its too late for that now. there's only so many chances you get, before you've expended all your luck. i no longer have any interest in either Sultan or the actor playing him
Sophronia thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#35

Originally posted by: M.Hurr

its an actor's job to fill life in the character but in Madhubala AR has failed to do this job again, your opinion. ,even the character itself is not making any sense,even TOI said in of their articles that he's always having one single expression oh and these articles are the gospel truth now are they? cant say when's he's happy or sad,and when he smile again I would say the same thing that he's no mood to smile wait wait HE'S in no mood to smile??🤪 but cvs are making him smile by force,usually I skipped his scenes but his confrontation with madhu in 12th and 13th July were the highpoints of the show so I have to watch it,when he held madhu's arms I see no glimpse of passion nor any kind of solid expression nor his eyes had any volume which speaks of a true love which he claimed he has for madhu. my comment for this is where i put an Asterix below


We rishabala fans do not like sultaan's character because he has done nothing but have spoiled MB, actually MB was spoilt and his entry made so many who had quit the show after the unwedding track return, including myself😊. the way cvs are giving him the limelight is of no use,fans are only getting annoyed the whole beginning of the track just you and ur lot. you dont represent all fans of the show. and he and madhu becoming friends was a chaos and still its nothing but a chaos to the show yeah you would obvz say that as a r-bala fan but again you lot dont represent everyone now 😛,I wished that instead of introducing a gangster as a third angle theCreative Team would have introduced someone else in a different kind of character, for the first time i have to agree with what youve said. if a new character was to be introduced i wanted it to be a rival director or something who madhu went to and became friends with after the unwedding track and i wanted the heroine track to start. Hat Ke show they still claimed but for the viewers its no more a hatke serial,its rather a destroyed one.

I strongly believe that AR has failed to fill the life in the show,he cant act,nor he cant emote with his eyes even in his silence as sultaan he's irritating not impressive. i cba with this comment


After seeing Friday and Saturday's episode I am even more annoyed with him because he wasn't at all looking like a man in love and sultaan hardly knows the meaning of love that's a different issue. *actually friday and saturdays episodes for us was different in the sense that we saw a completely different side of the character sultan and he DID portray a crazay-in-love guy (still havent digested that but thats not the issue) ...he expressed himself very well and you could tell from the shock of having revealed his feelings to suddenly admitting and accepting them to fondly remembering all those flashback scenes his eyes turned softer and he was smiling and then his pain when madhu told him what she thought of him was clearly evident and spoken through his eyes and expressions. and finally when he threw that stuff from the shelf thing he was enraged and no he didnt have a face like 😳

Think what you like those who disagree ,I explain myself only to those who understand.
kdot.


Mallu



Edited by swethasyam08 - 12 years ago
Posted: 12 years ago
#36
Have not seen AR in any other show previously so cannot comment. But unfortunately he just didnt click as Sultan. MEIEJ has set high standards. We have been used to brilliant power-packed performances by all the lead as well as the supporting actors. Even though his character went through a wide range of emotions, it is still not liked by the majority of viewers. The character was flawed big time too.
Valar.Morghulis thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#37
i don't know about his first show as MEIEJ is the first Indian show I am watching regularly, so can't comment on that.
I always tried to avoid talking about his acting skills openly, because I was always immensely annoyed with the clunks embedded in his characterization and character development but on Saturday's episode I, for the first time, had expectations from him and he disappointed me.

Playing negative and grey shaded characters is not his forte and I feel that's why CVs let him be white for so long.

ETA: And I agree with you, I never understood the need of the entry of an international don in a bollywood themed show. I have said it in my other posts as well CVs made the biggest mistake by creating a golden hearted don, as it is too far-fetched and senseless.
Edited by mm990 - 12 years ago
..Aliya.. thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#38
Agree with every word you said.
But we aren't even allowed to criticize.. If we do some will find excuses and say we "bashed" 🥱
I don't know since when telling your POV is bashing.
But what is going right in this crazy forum?
nicegirl_good thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#39
I wish AR worked harder
Edited by swethasyam08 - 12 years ago
swethasyam08 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#40
Hello All!!

Few things to mention and remind you all!!

Criticizing is fine and that too with in limits and it will be good if members stick to the current show of AR. But members are getting into comparing AR's previous show as well which isn't acceptable at all.

Secondly, Few comments have gone off topic after certain point of time which isn't acceptable as well. Please stick to the topic and do NOT go off track from the main topic.

Only constructive criticism allowed but any sort of mock or bashing is strictly prohibited. And if we see any member violating the rules, will see severe action from Dev Team. so please refrain from going off topic.

Few comments will be edited as its not related to show in any case.

The topic will remain open in the hope that members will stick to the above mentioned things, keeping in mind. But if we see mocking n bashing in any case, they the thread will be closed n the members will be warned without any further questions.


Thank you all for your co-operation.


Regards
MB Dev Team

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".