Originally posted by: practicecalm
While I agree with most of your thought process as to the bad handling of the character, I have some questions for you, "how did Sultan ruin RK's wedding?" " asking her to take revenge" when did he do that? Did he really do that or was he asking Madhu to be more clear and have clarity in her thought process as a friend who care? If a friend wants to have clarity on a 360 degree turn in our change of views, don't they question us twice over or thrice over or a 100 times over, till we ourselves are clear in our head and are firm in our resolve.
The same Madhu who was firm in her resolve to avenge her insults by RK and told her sister Trishna, her mom and Sultan and convinced everyone to believe that she is burning with the rage of vengeance, the moment she is dog-chained and manipulated turns all gooey-eyed, if a concerned mother pleads with her daughter's friend to see that her daughter is NOT doing a foolish thing and to ensure her daughter's safety, what would that friend do??? Not try to protect her? Not to try to understand her reasons for changing her perspective? Not see that she is not manipulated and falling into a trap??? Oh, yeah a friend is supposed to leave her to die, just because today RK has turned genuinely remorseful, you all are bashing Sultan for trying to reiterate Madhu's decision, safety and well being...what if he turns out to be a cad, an abuser and someone who keeps on dog-chaining Madhu. Just because today RK has been redeemed, RK has become spotlessly clean and Sultan's attempt to protect his friend has become an interference, otherwise?
Okay, firstly, thanks for agreeing with me on some points.
Secondly, when did I bash Sultan? I am actually a disappointed viewer. Where in my comment I bash Sultan? If you are talking about others, I am no one's spokesperson, as I said I speak only for myself, anyone can agree or disagree with me.
Now, coming to your question, well I was talking from RK's perspective. If you read the whole sentence again, I said it clearly that these are feelings of RK. So, he cannot keep on having patience for Sultan just because he helped him once.
And friends get concerned. But I still think it was not wise for him to go like this, on the wedding day. If he wanted to take her away any ways, he should have waited. I mean jab bhaga ke le hi jana tha, toh why not wait and see what she is doing. RK was not going to sacrifice her soul in the altar or anything. He should have seen, like a Saviour, if she needs his help, the moment he must have felt that she is in trouble, he should have taken her away. He is a don, it wouldn't have been difficult for him.
I don't know, man, seriously! I just didn't like him sneaking into her bedroom when she was all alone on her wedding day, maybe because I would never want any of my male friends to do that, even if they are trying to convince me to save my life or something. It puts my reputation on jeopardy. And then the way, he took the stairs rather than going from the backdoor like she told him to! Like, seriously? Showing his face to the entire family. Maybe another clunk, but you see my point here, clunks everywhere! It just pisses me off!
But you may disagree, I understand, it's just my point of view.
Edited by mm990 - 12 years ago
Hindi TV Shows
