If someone did that to your mother.. how would you - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

97

Views

6.9k

Users

30

Likes

206

Frequent Posters

..Sujith1001.. thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#11
Glad to see a neutral member in this forum, generally I only hear 'Sadakchap hate u' all d time!

I hope all neutral members return and bring back the glory of the forum!

Thanks for this unbiased and interesting post, Zephy!
enigmatic_zephy thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: _charu_

EZ, I'm only replying to you, otherwise i'm not bothered which way the story goes, nor am i extra sympathetic for any character bec. life is harsh for everyone, not just for a set of people we like...lets not blame MK and his family for Meera and Sultan's tragedy before the track unfolds...from the look of it, MK did pay of his mistake (i'm talking about cheating 2 women and NOT giving away Sultan..we dun know who did it ) and ended his life in guilt, not just that, his own family and child was ruined and never had a normal family life for 17 odd years...


MK may have left a good fortune for them but at the end of the day, it's RK who carried the burden of his mother and his step family on his shoulders, otherwise , their family was finished financially too...Sultan at least had kaka with him who brought him up...if he was forced into being a criminal and if he doesn't like his profession, it's never too late to give it up all and live a respectable life...


ah!.. haan.. dono ka hi pain hai.. one had to become a gangster.. I am guessing kaka must have come in life later... once sultan was all grown up.. otherwise.. kaka doesn't seem like a person who would let sultan continue on the wrong path had sultan been of an impressionable age and kaka had been the guide..

But you are right!.. RK has his share of woes too..

I just feel cheated.. suicide looks like an easy way out.. 😔

But, yeah all I was saying is.. Like RK didn't know the truth behind sultan and madhu and reacted.. and i never could NOT relate with his reactions.. i think they were justified..

similarly, if CVs chose to show revenge drama.. sultan doesn't know depth of RK's childhood miseries.. actually he knows nothing.. so if he does take revenge.. I would not be shocked by that.. from sultan's POV i can see why it would make sense..

Thanks Charu!.appreciate your response 😊
Edited by enigmatic_zephy - 12 years ago
enigmatic_zephy thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: ..Sujith1001..

Glad to see a neutral member in this forum, generally I only hear 'Sadakchap hate u' all d time!

I hope all neutral members return and bring back the glory of the forum!

Thanks for this unbiased and interesting post, Zephy!


He he.. I am not a neutral one.. I hate every character.. 😆

ah!.. no to answer your question.. i think I like to see all character's POV in a story... the actors are meaningless...watching the 'actor' them.. not 'offscreen personality' them.. so its always the story..and story can be boring or exciting..
Taniya20 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: enigmatic_zephy


😊 .. I wonder.. but if CVs decide to show that such a man as sultan.. is so full of hatred that he wants to destroy the other family.. I wouldn't have a disconnect.. quite acceptable..and believable..



I am adding my points by keeping my hate for sultan and love for RK aside... 😊

What ever happened with meera is very bad... i agree... but culprit is died... and he is solely responsible...Taking revenge on his family for something which he has done 30 years ago doesn't make much sense to me (i am talking solely from show concept perspective)... how his family is responsible???... its equally shocking to them and earth shattering news for them... Infact they will be in more pain because the person whom they idolize is not actually the person who deserves to be idolized... obviously sultan will be having hatred towards MK and his family... but at least if CV's go with the revenge track it looks forced to me... 🥱
enigmatic_zephy thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: taraka2005

m agree with u

but i will not punished other family who are not at fault they are also equally betray by Man.

Yes I feel bad for Sultan and his mother...

acc. to me RK is the one who is at actual lost we know for RK what his father meant for him and it is not any kind of show -off or drama...it will be equal blow for RK to...so the one who will lost is RK...For RK his Dad is like god and he cherished his memory..that will get tainted not just tainted it is going to broke him inside...

So i think this revelation will hv same impact on both...rather RK can never idealize his father in future..whereas Sultan can have his mother once she gets better and create good memories...

IF MK is alive i would like to c him get punishment for what he did..he is real culprit here..


MK is the real culprit I agree..

RK and sultan both will get hurt.. agree.. and probably doesn't make sense to put one's grief over other..

But ya.. what I am saying is.. like without knowing sultan and MB's equation, RK used to behave with Sultan.. I could understand that.. from RK's POV..

similarly if sultan chooses to take revenge, I can understand him and won't be able to point fingers at him.. not that he is right..right and wrong , a 3rd person can decide because he is clearly not suffering the pain first hand..and can have an objective view.. but sultan as a character won't..


armummy thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#16
Assuming too much I guess before the story has even started unfolding , what if at the end MK turns out innocent and not responsible for most of things he is being accused of .

The spoilers look too obvious , I am sure there will twist within this twist
..Sujith1001.. thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: enigmatic_zephy



He he.. I am not a neutral one.. I hate every character..😆

ah!.. no to answer your question.. i think I like to see all character's POV in a story... the actors are meaningless...watching the 'actor' them.. not 'offscreen personality' them.. so its always the story..and story can be boring or exciting..

@Bold - That s a neutral trait 😊

@Red - That is good too, u hate all not just one character without a valid reason! 😆
Taniya20 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: armummy

Assuming too much I guess before the story has even started unfolding , what if at the end MK turns out innocent and not responsible for most of things he is being accused of .

The spoilers look too obvious , I am sure there will twist within this twist




👍🏼 agree... what looks straight in MB can never be straight...some hidden twists and turns will be there...
enigmatic_zephy thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: Taniya20

.
I am adding my points by keeping my hate for sultan and love for RK aside... 😊

What ever happened with meera is very bad... i agree... but culprit is died... and he is solely responsible...Taking revenge on his family for something which he has done 30 years ago doesn't make much sense to me (i am talking solely from show concept perspective)... how his family is responsible???... its equally shocking to them and earth shattering news for them... Infact they will be in more pain because the person whom they idolize is not actually the person who deserves to be idolized... obviously sultan will be having hatred towards MK and his family... but at least if CV's go with the revenge track it looks forced to me... 🥱



Hmm.. maybe.. wat you say is a perspective..

I am trying to think from sultan's perspective...an angry man who killed the man who killed his mother... and he already doesn't feel so good about RK because as far as he knows.. he did wrong to MB with all the wedding drama.. irrespective of the fact whether he loves her or not.. from principle stand point, let's just say RK as a personality sultan will never approve of.. ( this has nothing to do with RK.. just trying to analyze Sultan's psyche)...

So, here he sees.. how everything has been taken away.. and his mother has suffered for 30 yrs.. if he doesn't take revenge.. that would just show how mature he is as a person..

But on the other hand, if he does.. I somehow fail to see a disconnect.. he is not angry. he will be in a rage...where your mind doesn't work and emotions overpower... so i can understand his POV.. and like me, i think even he will feel that suicide is not a good enough punishment..


Perosnally, I would give up any other serial .. all my tv time.. to just watch Balraj choudhary beat the hell out of MK in hell... 😆😆😆.. no track's better that that!

taraka2005 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: enigmatic_zephy


MK is the real culprit I agree..

RK and sultan both will get hurt.. agree.. and probably doesn't make sense to put one's grief over other..

But ya.. what I am saying is.. like without knowing sultan and MB's equation, RK used to behave with Sultan.. I could understand that.. from RK's POV..

similarly if sultan chooses to take revenge, I can understand him and won't be able to point fingers at him.. not that he is right..right and wrong , a 3rd person can decide because he is clearly not suffering the pain first hand..and can have an objective view.. but sultan as a character won't..




m also not blaming Sultan here...i just put RKs POV as chara...and whatever i said in my last reply is what dey can have and not once this emotional turmoil gets over of course not so soon... and it will remain with them for life...
Rk is not able to get over his fathers suicide till date... this blow will take another time... may be MBs presence in his life will make difference this time and hope so...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".