Butchering of characters to glorify GHG - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

57

Views

5.4k

Users

27

Likes

157

Frequent Posters

Shazzie thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#31

Originally posted by: genger



As a matter of fact i was expecting Sultan to be negative character too but the serial name is ek eishq and ek junoon of course it is Madu's ishq and junoon is RKs just to show the RK's junoon part they used sultan character and made him good be cause if they don't it would look too negative now that they changed RK's character or at least they show that he is redeemed i have a feeling they are going to show sultan gray that is my feeling let see it just strategy of the show every thinking is ok so for for some sense i just did not like the part they make sultan character fall for Madhu and made love triangle(typical hindi soap) they made his character week idid not like that part



Agree with you. Sultan was used to speed up RK's realisation phase & to show his junoon. Actually, I hv been waiting for Sultan to be gray. I had thought that a normal reaction of a gangster after being punched will be anger & was waiting for sultan to show that. But he just got silent by one look and went away. And now also, after madhu shouted at him & told him to leave, I was expecting him to be angry. But he had plans to leave the city, until they got derailed. This doesnot go well with a gangster character.

Love triangle - uff!! ! That was very unbelievable. From anger & irritation over madhu's interference to falling in love in couple of days. Love realization, going to dargah to ask for her, then going to confess to her & then heartbreak - all in a span of one hour!! Love triangle was just a clunk...
armummy thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#32
They tried stupid triangle that is what cvs mistake was , in that they ruined rk showing him excessively obsessed, if the TRPs would have been good it would have continues and triangle would have gone for some more months , mAdhu comparing sultan to pregnant padmini is utter joke , mAdhu Calling herself pagal as an explanation to save sultan is uttencrap this was not mbeiej we know , when trps did not work they had to get rk mAdhu married and then made a big joke of padmini asking a gangster to kidnap her own daughter. Now to retain sultan in the show they have got a mother sob story , lets see if it work.


They should have stuck with their initial negative characterization of sultan with scores to settle with rk , people would have accepted it.

We all know it is not only leads story and it needs more characters but not the cost of the show itself. Trps decide the future if the show and story , they do not have years worth of story written at the outset , I heard in many interviews that they go on biweekly tracks and they change according to what is working and what not.

Pushing sultan in between marriage scenes was limit , this is the time they are trying to regain some of their lost viewers. If they use rishbala to trick users to watch sultan , soon viewers won't fall into that trick too .

They should have executed the episode well not like sat episode


Edited by armummy - 12 years ago
Lucky1123 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#33

Originally posted by: Shazzie



Agree with you. Sultan was used to speed up RK's realisation phase & to show his junoon. Actually, I hv been waiting for Sultan to be gray. I had thought that a normal reaction of a gangster after being punched will be anger & was waiting for sultan to show that. But he just got silent by one look and went away. And now also, after madhu shouted at him & told him to leave, I was expecting him to be angry. But he had plans to leave the city, until they got derailed. This doesnot go well with a gangster character.

Love triangle - uff!! ! That was very unbelievable. From anger & irritation over madhu's interference to falling in love in couple of days. Love realization, going to dargah to ask for her, then going to confess to her & then heartbreak - all in a span of one hour!! Love triangle was just a clunk...


Exactly his love realization part is very week in the story because as long as RK is in the show it is always RK=Madu so why bother showing that hopefully they do the damage control by changing the track
Shazzie thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#34

Originally posted by: paljay

As you all or most of the RK fan says all the time it is fiction, it is a reel world not real world, then why you are cribbing about Sultan's character, that is what I don't get it. It is a fictional story RkK and Sultan both are fictional character so which one is good and which is bad doesn't matter.

Hai na.



Dear, I m discussing about the show & how characters are developed in the show. In my opinion, every characters had a strong baseline in the show but somehow that was lacking in sultan's case. Its my opinion & not forcing everyone to agree.
Shazzie thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#35

Originally posted by: armummy

They tried stupid triangle that is what cvs mistake was , in that they ruined rk showing him excessively obsessed, if the TRPs would have been good it would have continues and triangle would have gone for some more months , mAdhu comparing sultan to pregnant padmini is utter joke , mAdhu Calling herself pagal as an explanation to save sultan is uttencrap this was not mbeiej we know , when trps did not work they had to get rk mAdhu married and then made a big joke of padmini asking a gangster to kidnap her own daughter. Now to retain sultan in the show they have got a mother sob story , lets see if it work.


They should have stuck with their initial negative characterization of sultan with scores to settle with rk , people would have accepted it.

We all know it is not only leads story and it needs more characters but not the cost of the show itself. Trps decide the future if the show and story , they do not have years worth of story written at the outset , I heard in many interviews that they go on biweekly tracks and they change according to what is working and what not.

Pushing sultan in between marriage scenes was limit , this is the time they are trying to regain some of their lost viewers. If they use rishbala to trick users to watch sultan , soon viewers won't fall into that trick too .

They should have executed the episode well not like sat episode



Superb post. Agree with what you wrote.

Exactly, comparing Sultan with a pregnant, lone & helpless woman was the height of stupidty. A show can not just run by 2 main leads. Story always needs credible, strong side characters who create hurdles, or drive the story forwards by their actions. What was missing was the credibility. A gangster on the run kills so many people in broad daylight on a festival day in chawl, but there is no police. He is , saved by a girl who defends her actions by saying that she was saving a helpless man,and the mother says to gangster that she saw good in him by his actions on day of holi. 😲 I know that being a fictional serial, there has to be some poetic liberty but as I said.. limit to clunkiness of plot being shoved down our throats.

I was actually looking forward for a strong character opposite a powerful superstar. It would have been fireworks and drama unlimited but unfortunately, it was not handled properly. I hope that this track is handled in a better way than the goldie gangster track which has been present since last 3 or so months. I had also hoped that the original track of Sultan being Antagonist had not been changed. But then, how will CVs adhere to their 'expect the unexpected' rule!

Pushing Sultan in saturday was crap. If they wanted to show, they could have shown on Friday.Whole scene of getting his drunkard father at home and revealing the secrets could have been dealt in one go and not in bits and pieces between varmala & pheras. That too, while promoting the whole show as shaadi special. Why hide behind rishbala shaadi promotion to show what you want. Have the guts to promote it as revelation of sultan's story special!


Edit - Nice discussion with all. M logging out. Further posts - if any, will be replied to later.

Edited by Shazzie - 12 years ago
cardio21 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#36
Agreed!! And I wouldn't be wrong if I say that Goldie is the weakest actor in this whole bunch of talented actors.. All actors in the show were great performers, and have suited their roles to the T. Except for bhai, who has done nothing since day 1, but confuse the audience. He tried everything from a ruthless don to an obedient golden heart, from a strict father to a putty in his son's hands who did rates the don't romantic inclinations, from a grieving husband to a hormonal teenager, and the list is endless.. And the problem is that he was not convincing in any of the roles. We were excited initially to see what he has got. But he was a huge disappointment.
The only entertainment we get out of him is the IF posts on him, else he has zero screen presence.
And then the CVs are so obsessed with him, that they try to butcher all characters to accommodate this glorified extra. But nothing has worked so far. And nothing ever will..

I think the forced love triangle was the biggest disaster CVs could come up with. They should have let him be a antagonist as per the initial plan. But instead of focussing on the story, they busied themselves with goldplating. And now tat OTT goodness is so intolerable.

Edited by cardio21 - 12 years ago
Ananya05 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#37
Gold plating ke keemat sare characters chuka rahe hai...🤣

Nice post Btw..
taraka2005 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#38
Superb Post, very well written

Exactly, Initially I was also excited that after ballu death we are gonna c another strong antagonist but since his entry everything going down the hill. Cvs are too busy in gold plating his heart on cost of existing strong characters just to accommodate him. Everything is so unconvincing about him...even his journey hw he became gangster does not go well with me... if he has golden heart den y he choose this way... y he cant surrender himself to law after completing his revenge for his mothers death...He always said he never saw his father...but photo tells another story..ufff everything so clumsy abt him..😡🤢
if RKs butchering was not enough CVs are gog to butcher image of RKs dad and name..🤢 now if Gangu turns negative den what RK's memories got tainted...damage is done...I am really feeling sad for RK...cant CVs use bollywood and underworld conspiracies to improve Gangus character instead of using this typical Ekta type twist... it would be more interesting to see on TV screen as we never seen before

Shaadi episode was disaster...thx to Hema and Ananya who provide unadulterated vid link nw i m njoying shaadi spl..😊
Edited by taraka2005 - 12 years ago
mevanp thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#39
Fab Post... 👏 can't understand y a gangster is given so much of importance... ? He should be in prison n instead this person is roaming freely everywhere n giving lectures to everybody ... Disgusting ! 😡
BabajiKaThullu thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#40
itna badda essay 🤣
koi nahi meine 3 paragraph read kiye 🤣

have to agree with you re 🤣

cvs naa faluda hi banayenge 🤣

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".