Why Sultan? - Page 3

@mocking-bird : Lovely post as always. I have a very bad feeling that Sultan will not be with us for long...especially after the dialogue on him being granted a boon at 4.30 coming true...it reminds me of Jai-Veeru scene in Sholay. I really really hope that I am proved wrong. I do not want to see a tragic ending to an awesome character...

Originally posted by: likarsh

People may disagree, but honestly I don't like that question. Why Sultan? I feel like it's not a natural question to pose and it's put in there for the sake of hinting at the love angle.

Not that there isn't a connection, and that there's something happening. I just don't think it makes sense that she asked. What's the reason for asking why? Why wouldn't he, after all that's happened, and considering who he is?

I also am not a fan of the reaching out to touch her while crying, but stopping. But that I can deal with.

The kyun, however, I feel was just lazy and added in there just for dramatic purposes. It would have been better for her to just acknowledge it quietly. Or have Aryan interrupt before the kyun.

Originally posted by: ravenheart

@mocking-bird : Lovely post as always. I have a very bad feeling that Sultan will not be with us for long...especially after the dialogue on him being granted a boon at 4.30 coming true...it reminds me of Jai-Veeru scene in Sholay. I really really hope that I am proved wrong. I do not want to see a tragic ending to an awesome character...

Originally posted by: mocking_bird

Do not worry. He will be here. He is the only one Madhu now can count on.

@RAVENHEART...the 4 ,30 pm dialogue was jus to mk madhu feel light...

..it HAS GOT NOTHING to do with sultans death or ny hint of future

Originally posted by: ravenheart

Well her questioning "why Sultan" could be for -

- to show the phankas of sultan-madhu - she has never seen Sultan other than as a human who needed her help OR

- to get Sultan to think about why he still wants to protect woman who refuses his help...ishq vishq pyaar vyaar...all one sided

Melodrama thy name is MEIEJ...

Originally posted by: mocking_bird

I respect your opinion,but,I find the "why" having a very striking purpose. She had asked him not to interfere when he had brandished the gun at RK. She called up and poured her anguish for his interference. Still the man did not deter,did not waver but,continued to maintain if she is threatened or her happiness is compromised with,he will intervene. Any one would have been surprised with this reply,especially when she had expected that she would be rebuked for speaking so harshly about his dead wife. But,his gestures must have taken her by surprise. Hence the question.

But, the more I think of it,the more I feel, Madhu waited a reply which she had expected,her expression said as such.

nd Sultan not touching her was on expected lines,I feel. RK had emphasised she is his biwi and not to mess with her. So that hought must have crossed his mind not to touch her physically.

And that was a gesture only a gentleman would do.know where to draw the line.

I loved your post beautifully written, he is real gentlemen from Aryan side good man, he is very very nice person loved, his entry was rally gave new dimension to the show, he is rocking its proofed form trp break down, Madhu -sultaan relation is so pure n beautiful respectable , she didnot say anything on friendship but she did what he advice she touched by his gesture n concern that was awww. use itne respect n understanding ki habit nahi rahi . trp said that TRP audience has accepted him nicely , we to pahle se hi fida thenow every day our respect is getting increased for him

wow beautifully written .. just loved every bit of it specially d ending .. yes she will understand which anchor to choose n whose hand can hold it

Originally posted by: likarsh

The touching part, my problem was just that it's just something that we've seen many times: going to touch the shoulder, then stopping. They really didn't need to resort to such a cliched, overdone action.

As for the Why. What's happened has happened. But I would've really preferred it not to happen. As I said, I don't think it was necessary. Before the question, she expected to be rebuked, but he told her to let it go. Before the question, she praised him on his ability to maintain relationships. They had already achieved somewhat of an understanding.

I think that question would only be natural when you are wondering, suspecting, want confirmation that there is something.

Anyway, it's happened. So I will just deal with it. 😆 Plus it was probably what led Sultan to clarify later regarding his considering her a friend.

Sorry for putting a somewhat negative post in the topic when all love how the Sulbala scene progressed. I just needed to vent somewhere on that. And I saw your topic.

@Likarsh : not everyone sees the scenes in similar manner. for eg I found the holi scene where Madhu runs away from being coloured or when she is playing with Aryan during the same sequence OTT - i just ignored and acted it never happened 😆