is Madhu doing the right thing? - Page 4

Originally posted by: ArushiSagar

Couldn't have said it better myself. I am incredibly frustrated with the "Madhubala is stupid" comments flooding the forum. Everyone is thinking about what they would do as Madhubala. Well, you're not Madhubala and are not faced with the situation she is. Who knows what you would do in her situation and given her personality. We should look at her in light of her circumstances and her character and not in light of what we would do.

She is doing rite thing acc. to me.She loves aryan and now sultan don't have anyone to take care of him.

Its overdose of kindness and innocence. Sure she is going to be in BIG trouble for all this 'Mahanata'.

Originally posted by: ulakmini

I feel she is right...it does not matter Sultan is a gangster and how powerful he is as a don.. reality is that ,he is alone man who only has old man and small child in his life...when he became so helpless there should be some one for him...

We all know what kind of girl Madhu is...her spirit is different from other girls... ( I hope you remember in very early episode, that short heir lady journalist told to RK " ye ladki alag mitti se bani hein ...Use daro"...) she was right...if another girl is here she will not go to help Sultan.

But Madhu will never miss it...because she knows that Sultan does not have any one to help...

and also she care about Aryan.. how can a girl awake and send the small child, in such as a dangerous place, who already sleeps in her lap... no woman can do it...so she has to go with him...and she has done...

Even i feel the same when it came for helping somebody she never thought who he is or the other person atleas deserves. First she helped mukku & fought for .no matter what she took all pain, when she helped RK giving blood she never thought he is the same person who have made her life hell with a fake marriage. now she is definitely inviting problens by helping sultan but she is doing it for need of the hour & aryan needs sultan & for aryan she is helping him out. so lets wait till Rk comes. this makes turning point for sultan who changes for his son or Rk changes & try to win the trust back

ofcourse she is not wrong, she has started to care for Aryan and another human being shot and kaka elderly,no human being can turn away from that

To add to what I posted before - there is no such thing as right or wrong here. The question is: is her choice to help Aryan and Sultan wise. Only time will tell... We can rarely predict all the long-term consequences of our actions. We can only make the best decision in a situation given our personality and circumstances. I must add, I'm glad that there are people like Madhubala out there who help you out even if they gain nothing in return. If there weren't, the world would be a sad place indeed...

I know where she is coming from...she has always been involved in others matters more...be it in Mukund's case or the Ganpati track where she was bound to make RK believe in God and now taking care of Sultan..I love her character but this side of Madhu totally turns me off...
I don't understand..is Mumbai ka Sultan so weak that she needs to take care of him...where are his men

D'oh! Do I need to tell what I voted for Gari?
She's absolutely wrong! I know that she's always been caring and compassionate towards people! Be it Mukund earlier and Sultan now! But there is A VAST DIFFERENCE b/w the two!
If Sultan had been a normal day to day guy, it would still be justified but THIS? I mean you can't go and help every Gangster no matter his son is innocent! That guy ISN'T! He's a DON! He is as much a sadist like RK... Or may be even MORE! He kills every second man who is not in his gang.
So its absolutely NO!

anything overdose is always bitter. this is all becoz of her innocent nature. she never thinis about consequences. she can take care if aaryan at her home on humanitarian grounds. interfering in sulthan matters is little overboard and it may prove dangerous for her as well as to her family in future. she will get everyone in to trouble as she did to malik in Mukunds case.