What Was That Slap For? - Page 12

Created

Last reply

Replies

188

Views

11.6k

Users

65

Likes

306

Frequent Posters

4ever4love thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
I read your post twice and I (respectfully) cannot find anything to agree with!
I have not lost any respect for Madhu. I would rather she comes out with guns blazing (not literally) rather then look meek. I love her fire. Yes she was emotional but i do not blame her for not wanting RK's help.

What the heck was He THINKING? How can he be surprised or hurt that she pushed him away?? That she did not want his help??

I am completely fine with the slap. I wish there were more ...

And as always Madhu fought him face to face. She did not stick a knife in his back. When Madhu lashes out, she does it right. Not like RK.

My humble opinion!😊
..Tangled.. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
I don't agree with you Madhu was terrified and confused at the moment. The man who broke her emotionally and was about to humiliate her dignity is caring for her... how will she believe him this time? She doesn't want to understand him and why would she... Rk himself broke all ties with her... even I'm confused of RK's mood swings...
.Shiva. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Elite Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: FingerFetish



It is called a violation if the person does not want or grant permission for your assistance. Sure everyone wants to help somebody. But if the person does not want to receive help than you cannot force it onto them. I don't care how good his intentions were. She did not welcome his help and so he should have minded his own business. But NOPE he decides to continue grabbing onto her. If she got injured that would be her own responsibility. She is not a 2 year old that needs guidance. She is an adult and is thus responsible for her own actions.

but she sure was acting like a kid! screaming to let go, i hate you, let me get hurt what difference does it make if i get hurt. she out to now if she had gone away from there she could have been in serious problem but she didn't think like that she just wanted to go and hurt herself. no it would have not been her responsibilty it would have been on rk b/c he was there and like always without thinking they would have blamed him🥱

Madhu deserves a slap too? Did you really just say that!? Honestly I have lost hope in this forum.
yes i said that, why not if rk can get slap for helping her then why cannot he return that favore like she did but he will never do that b/c he knows anger does not solve anything and keeping clam and letting things sink is the best😉 don't lose hope i answer the same way i get answer from others. you said rk deserve that slap and i said then so does madhu b/c rk didn't wanted to harm her yet she slap him.

Now members are preaching that she should be slapped because HE the ruler of all evil got slapped for a bad deed.
if people can talk about rk "R" madhu then what harm did i do by saying that he could have return that favore to b/c if a woman has honor so does men's and you cannot just go on slapping and throwing your dupatta in air saying come on take me. what did she think of rk? did she think he is going to do that to her? na but if it was someone else he would have slap that girl who could think of something like that. she was instigating him to do the sick deeds and for that she needs to be shown the truth which rk will do on monday

Can't even express how horrified I am by your comment.
by god what did i say that you got so horrified😳 do you think a man will stand there and take slap and not return that favor. seems like people has taken rk for granted. anyone can slap him but he has no right to return that favor 🤣what a sinful thinking of people.

YOU contradict yourself completely. You claim that slapping does not solve a problem and yet you preach on about how she deserved to be slapped as well.

👏👏

nope i never deny the truth, slap is wrong and always will be that is why i made this post and i said IF rk had slapped madhu then what? get the facts right. thanks for that clap! oh no it solves according to some people like you who thinks one should get slap even though he/she meant no harm. if a woman has honor so does a man. if rk had slap madhu in reutrn then her self respect would have been gone out the window. he is no saint who will take everything and won't say anything nobody is saint nor rk nor madhu😛 if people can party b/c rk got slap then i can party saying he is an honorable man who didn't reacted back the same way his BIWI did.

I don't even want to bother continuing with his. I clearly got your message and it's so wrong in my eyes that no additional comments will redeem it.

who is telling you to bother with anything, you came here i didn't invited you. you came willing. do i care if it is wrong in your eyes NOPE! to me it seems you wanted to justifed this slap b/c rk deserved it for his past deeds but to me he didn't deserve this slap simple as that. don't need to redeem i didn't do any sin that you need to add additional comments to redeem it😉 i also got your msg defend things when it is not right but forget the deeds has been done to the one and justified others weak acts BRAVO 👏👏and your first post was wrong to my eyes b/c i see no maturity in it but simple frustration to justify any acts but didn't even talk about how a woman has dishonor herself to put her husband down! i see where you coming from no need to see anything else for sure😉

nobodyatnotime thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: spnfan_forever

By slapping him, she showed him that she isn't scared of him anymore, and that's what RK really likes about her. I awaiting for that slap! He deserved it long ago! :P

👏
True, he covered her with the blue stole and he supposedly asked for permission, but he was responsible for Madhu having to dress up in that gown in the first place...he wouldn't need to touch her at all if he didn't make the heroine go home. He suggested that Madhu play the duplicate.

If he thinks up new ways to humiliate her everyday and then feels sorry for her, Madhu is not supposed to believe that, is she? I mean, Madhu already knows last time he was sorry that was only a superstar acting.

You can't simply drag a person into bad positions and then feel sorry and think the other person is going to be overwhelmed with gratitude because you actually didn't go through the entire act.

When Madhu threw up her dupatta, it was her way of showing disgust for the person she had once loved (and perhaps still loves, but at that moment it was disgust and contempt)

I on my part fully support the slap.
.Shiva. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Elite Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: 4ever4love

I read your post twice and I (respectfully) cannot find anything to agree with!


i understand and respect your POV😳

I have not lost any respect for Madhu. I would rather she comes out with guns blazing (not literally) rather then look meek. I love her fire. Yes she was emotional but i do not blame her for not wanting RK's help.

so you think that slap was good and bang on! cool no problem. she has every right to blame rk but what she did was wrong in my eyes. don't want help then leave that room why go on slapping someone! frustration can lead to many things and it did today.

What the heck was He THINKING? How can he be surprised or hurt that she pushed him away?? That she did not want his help??

he knew what was coming! but it's that feelings that came to protect her and when she said no he was like gosh what do i do now.

I am completely fine with the slap. I wish there were more ...

disagree here for sure! the slap was not need at this moment! it was not the right moment nor right time. you wish there were more then what are you going to wish if rk is not to be blame for all this things? you going to wish madhu slaps him more?

And as always Madhu fought him face to face. She did not stick a knife in his back. When Madhu lashes out, she does it right. Not like RK.

she didn't fight face to face but she was trying to bring rk down show how! she went to such an extend that she took her dupatta off! that was not cool for me, that was too much to digest. if she wanted to fight with him then do it why stoop so low like that. when madhu lash out she loses control like she did in the last scene and so does rk when he get's mad he also goes crazy and does stupid deeds both are in the same level no one is better then other according to me.

My humble opinion!😊

.Shiva. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Elite Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: rishbalalover

I don't agree with you Madhu was terrified and confused at the moment. The man who broke her emotionally and was about to humiliate her dignity is caring for her... how will she believe him this time? She doesn't want to understand him and why would she... Rk himself broke all ties with her... even I'm confused of RK's mood swings...


no problem😳 yes some point he did but he didn't humiliate her dignity but covered her honro but she herself dishonor by throwing that dupatta. it is not about believe but about what is right at that moment. i never said in my post to believe him but atleast think before doing anything nor does she have to understand him, he just wanted her to calm down till the light comes on but things got out of hand. to understand his mood swings we have to wait till we find out the real reason behind all this.
.Shiva. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Elite Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: --Shivu--

Someone is ignoring me

who can ignore shivu tell me tell me😡🤣
423728 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
*Bangs head against the wall*. Can you please re-read my message and interpret it correctly? I felt like I said A B C D and you retaliated with Uno Dos Tres. Her bottom was an example! Gosh why do I even bother? You are going to sit there and justify Madhu being rightfully slapped back and that is just sickening. I feel like I have entered the Pratigya forums. Hero's physical and mental abuse was tolerated and encouraged because fanatics found it hot. I suppose that is the justification for your opinion. Oh my he roughly grabbed her arms despite her saying no - how hot hot hot!

This is a public forum. Don't expect that everyone is going to have the same tone or form of expressing their views like you. I was initially enraged at RK's justification. Now I'm simply sickened by the opinions presented. To think that a woman should be slapped back because she fought and struggled against her tormentor is possibly the reason why domestic violence still continues to occur.

Oh please don't give the 'man and wife' examples. That is a poor attempt to justify everything. In fact it just makes the relationship of a husband and wife look disgusting. Be it husband or wife, if the other spouse does not want to be touched, he or she still has no right to do so. Do I have to spell it out for you to understand? S H E D I D N O T W A N T TO BE T O U C H E D. What did he do? Like a raving puppy continued to G R A B O N T O H E R. He could be her husband, father or son. When someone says no, than take it as that. Whatever she did was her business. If she wanted to be humiliated by going to the set than so be it. That does not mean she was asking to be touched. Lord I feel like I'm speaking in jibberish!

RK didn't want to harm her? 🤣🤣🤣 I assume mental and emotional abuse counts to nothing right? It just has to be physical.

Go on the address bar and type up 'www.google.com'. Than search the term 'abuse'. You will find emotional and mental abuse being a part of it. If RK didn't want to harm her physically, he already done the deed by hurling mental and emotional abuses.

I feel like we are riding on a merry go round. So according to you it's not a major hype that it was just her back being exposed? It's not about us complaining. It is about the character - C H A R A C T E R of Madhu being uncomfortable to expose her body to a bunch of randoms. I see the issue here. The audience drools over Drashti's back. Drashti is an actress, Madhubala is the character. Please learn to differentiate between the two. How on earth does the audience liking DD's back got anything to do with Madhubala the character feeling violated for having revealed certain parts of her body that she does not feel comfortable exposing. I literally hope you read this paragraph and understand that your message just did not make sense whatsoever.

It's not like RK would be like to Madhubala 'Hush don't worry, the DDians all love your back anyway'. Madhubala will look at RK and say 'Who the hell is DD?'. See the difference between real and reel?


caffeineaddict thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: .Shiva.


<font color="#990099">who can ignore shivu tell me tell me😡🤣</font>


I dunno😭 I felt that way🤣
AT mein aa!
itsRitzi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 12 years ago
my views are hatke or shud u say mad

😆 but i think slap was much needed from entertainment point of view and also as a mini climax u see all this story mainly began from chaar thappad and now the fifth one it was needed to show madhu is indeed a normal person and has her limits 😳

and it was needed to see how RK wud react but that dupatta part was too dramatic 😕
loved ur last part RK indeed is a very difficult book to read 👏

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".