Posted:
Other mods stay out - this is for Shifali... I wanna know why are mods not reading the topics properly and closing them... why are ppl reporting wrong context and reporting them... This shows that mods are not doing their research properly.
Okay guys,
AT rules were made because YOU guys wanted it. You cannot expect DD I like you, Madhu I like you topics to go in the AT while RK you are hot, RK you are my hero, RK looked so hot and his eyes expressed emotions posts to stay open.
Rules have to be fair to both fandoms. You cannot have one and not have the other. you need to read my reply below in red Shifali... you sound misguided as D.Disha.
Before, we had a rule that along with ATs, only max of 2 drooling/appreciation topics were allowed on the forum. But no one wanted that as it was all 'drool drool drool'.
And then the rules were that all individual character related topics should go in the ATs cuz thats what you guys wanted. That happened.
Then the rules changed so that all drool goes into the ATs and actual character discussion topics stay open. So I don't get what is the problem now? Pls read my reply in the red below - you classify any positive appreciation as drool and close the topic Shifali..
You cannot have only RK discussion allowed on the forum and not Madhubala. When did I say this Shifali - I dares you to point this to me...
I mean you guys made us change the rules and now you guys want them altered. We cannot change the rules at every moment of the day to suit your individual needs. If rules are made, they are here to stay, at least for a month if not more or less.
So on that note,
Topic Closed
Madhubala DT Why is the topic closed...????? I made my suggestions other members can make theirs... bec your 101 billion rules are not working either... Next time you close my posts which is inevitable.. pls atleast give the right information with it. I'm a perfectionist for correct details.. anything which is not - Really annoys me. I never protested fro myself.. I don't use the forum.. but others do - and the way the forum is handled is upsetting many ppl.Thanks.
Those people who blindly report the topic - didn't read and before closing the topic neither did u. I can say this in a PM - But why.. U closed the topic I can't reply - so I'm replying here.
I paste below - my post - kindly tell me - where does it state that keep VD appreciation topics on forum and DD's in AT.
I protested for both the parties to be able to appreciate their fav's on the forum.
And Any postive character discussion - is still being closed - and sent to the AT. So apart fom negative comments - what are ppl supposed to post? Next time read the post Shifali and then comment!!!! PLS.
Mods have tried to bring some balance in the forum - but I'd say that there are issues out there which do not allow everyone to use the forum conveniently.
Maybe we need to get together and make some suggestions openly.
My good friend Nishi's post - which stated some honest fact was closed on by page 4.
Devilwithinu's post which was a character slaughtering one lived till page 34
Which proves that posts created with hard work and love cannot be appreciated.. which is really misfortunate.. like My friend Chakku chudrails post on VD appreciation.. where she was very justified in describing... yes she described why RK/VD had been so amazing.
Number 1 - Not all visitors visit the AT's.
If we are not allowed to promote our show character and actors then how is the show and our fav's going to prosper. BY Making these rules up for the misbehaving forums where you can only praise in AT's is catering for existing members but not for silent readers or those who are shy of joining AT's.
And IF is for everyone.
I think appreciation posts actually create more positivity then negative discussions in any forum.. It's far healthier for the mind also.
Anyways I think if the appreciation topic is detailed then yes it shud be allowed.
One liners appreciation posts should not be allowed.
For Example - where the TM has described what they loved abt the scene or act by their fav and why.. with some technical reason.
Not JUST So and so looked hot today, Or wow she was so good today etc.
Because if we have no positive posts allowed for the main lead's then there should be no appreciation posts on Rishbala either - stick those in Rishabala AT. Because the forum is being unfair to 'just DD' and 'just VD' fans. This forum is for all.. not just for joint DVD'Rishbala fans.
I hope you will all agree - that create positive posts where you can appreciate your fav's and have fun. BUT make it detailed appreciation posts - Not one - two - three - liner ones.
Current Affairs
Real Estate
